Black Swan

9

LatinCritic13Nov 19, 2016

I know that this is late and all, but after watching this movie; it completely blew my mind. The direction, the imagery, the performances, the classical musical score, and the cinematography is just absolutely amazing. And let's try not toI know that this is late and all, but after watching this movie; it completely blew my mind. The direction, the imagery, the performances, the classical musical score, and the cinematography is just absolutely amazing. And let's try not to forget Natalie's performance, her performance is just brilliant...… Expand

1 of 2 users found this helpful11

All this user's reviews

1

Man3Dec 12, 2010

This movie is a horror flick and is not worth the money to see it. The story and script are terrible. Perhaps the acting is good, but it is wasted on this terrible horrific film. Save your time and money and skip this one.

9 of 20 users found this helpful911

All this user's reviews

1

carldamnitDec 18, 2010

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Spoilers!!! Not that much of the plot revealed below would be surprising after watching the first 10 minutes of the film. 1. The premise is flawed. Why would they select such a spiritless, vapid, flat emotional wreck to carry Swan Lake.

2. Natalie Portman's performance is spiritless, vapid and flat for 90% of the movie and laughably over the top for the remainder. Though the laugh factor is not entirely her fault, because....

3. The forced combination of surrealism and melodrama provided by the script and Aronofsky's direction would be hilarious if it wasn't so embarrassing.

4. At least Showgirls had nudity and memorable one-liners.

5. I'm sure Aronofsky and whoever wrote this has seen The Piano Teacher and that pisses me off, because both movies include:

a. A sexually and emotionally constricted woman that trains vigorously in a performance art

b. a disturbingly intimate relationship with a mother who is overbearing

c. a closing shot of the lead having stabbed themselves at one of their performances

6. Even the frequent masturbation scenes and casual lesbianism that was included to keep straight guys like my brother interested in the movie was unsuccessful. According to my brother, these ladies are thin and gross.

7. The frequent shifts in what is real and what is a hallucination is tiring and I eventually lost interested in telling the two apart, thus making me indifferent to what was I assume meant to be a tragic ending.

8. Aronofsky put me in the uncomfortable position of feeling bad for laughing when other people might not have realized how stupid this movie is.

9. This movie sucked.

10. My brother may never trust me to choose a movie ever again. Here is my brother's two word review of the movie: **** Swan.

.… Expand

7 of 17 users found this helpful710

All this user's reviews

10

MkMDec 6, 2010

Make note: of the two idiots who gave this bad reviews, one did so to draw attention to a technical problem with the metacritic site and the other wrote his based on the trailer, which made him "angry" even though he doesn't seem to know whatMake note: of the two idiots who gave this bad reviews, one did so to draw attention to a technical problem with the metacritic site and the other wrote his based on the trailer, which made him "angry" even though he doesn't seem to know what the movie is actually about. Frustrating. Oh, and by the way, the movie is one of the best to come out this year.… Expand

4 of 10 users found this helpful46

All this user's reviews

8

KundKDec 21, 2010

Some may mockingly call it "Repulsion in a Tutu", but the movie works. The acting is top notch, lifting the heavy atmosphere of repression (sexual and otherwise) and body horror above the Grand Guignol theatrics into pure gut-wrenchingSome may mockingly call it "Repulsion in a Tutu", but the movie works. The acting is top notch, lifting the heavy atmosphere of repression (sexual and otherwise) and body horror above the Grand Guignol theatrics into pure gut-wrenching psycho-terror and pain. Portman (in Machinist-style emaciation) is sublime in her descent into psychosis, Hershey is fabulously creepy as her domineering mother, Ryder does wonders with her few minutes on screen and Kunis is a great fiery and free-flowing opposite to the frigidly perfect Swan Queen. Aaronofsky is a bit heavy-handed with symbolism and uses too many of his trademark tracking shots from behind, the script could have been better, but there might be some awards here, especially for Portman and Kunis. Well worth a watch.… Expand

2 of 5 users found this helpful23

All this user's reviews

9

tinar1Dec 23, 2010

Great film. Natalie delivers one of her best performances to date.
Not for all the family because of the sexual tension on it.
It has many levels, if you can see trough it.

2 of 5 users found this helpful23

All this user's reviews

10

athinnesDec 6, 2010

An excellent psychological-horror film. The score does a wonderful job of setting the mood and tone, along with the excellent cinematographic. The acting overall is phenomenal. It would be a shame if Portman did not get OscarAn excellent psychological-horror film. The score does a wonderful job of setting the mood and tone, along with the excellent cinematographic. The acting overall is phenomenal. It would be a shame if Portman did not get Oscar consideration for her role. In a age where for some, being entertained at the movies is a rare occasion, Black Swan succeeds triumphantly.… Expand

2 of 5 users found this helpful23

All this user's reviews

10

ExordiomDec 14, 2010

An excellent movie. Definitely a Best Picture. The acting is just brilliant and if you don't see it know I guarantee you will be missing out on an important piece of 21st century cinema.

2 of 5 users found this helpful23

All this user's reviews

10

drawkward86Dec 18, 2010

Wow. The one weak link is the screenplay (Cassel has to say some truly awful lines). I couldn't possibly care less. I haven't seen a film this visceral in years, maybe ever. Portman is career-best (by a lot) and Barbara Hershey is superb.Wow. The one weak link is the screenplay (Cassel has to say some truly awful lines). I couldn't possibly care less. I haven't seen a film this visceral in years, maybe ever. Portman is career-best (by a lot) and Barbara Hershey is superb. Perfectly captures the weird dichotomy of the deathly serious and the absurd that any obsessive artist confronts themselves with on a daily basis... why do we let ourselves tear ourselves to shreds over something that, in the grand scheme, should be so trivial? Black Swan doesn't answer the question and doesn't seek to, but it does explore it through a totally committed performance from Natalie Portman that has to be one of the most difficult acting assignments I've seen someone take on in a film in years. A dizzy, demented film that doesn't give a damn about the line between reality and delirium. I love that.… Expand

2 of 5 users found this helpful23

All this user's reviews

10

jdolan74Dec 19, 2010

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. I really feel like Aronofsky has found a happy medium between Requiem for a Dream and The Wrestler with his latest masterpiece, Black Swan. He definitely takes his interpretation of Swan Lake and All About Eve to some unique places with the film. And he doesn't feel the need to have to make sense on a practical level, because he is using his chosen medium to express the torment Natalie Portman's character is going through as she prepares for the greatest role of her career. And the film parallels both the stories of Swan Lake and All About Eve's storylines on a metaphorical level that is raw and provocative. I have talked with many people who hated this film and our biggest degree of separation is the fact that I felt this film perfectly conveys what it is to put one's self out there on the stage, and what an actor (or dancer) must do to get to a certain place. They felt that the film's unrealities derailed it from the point it was trying to make. But I don't think a good filmmaker must be constricted by reality when trying to prove a point. An artist must separate themselves from who they are and become what the character demands. Portman's character didn't need to change to be the White Swan. But to be the Black Swan, she had to abandon everything her mother wanted her to be. Which brings me to the relationship between Portman and Barbara Hershey. I personally know girls who have this EXACT relationship with their mothers. I even know a girl who was named after Baryshnikov, who trained as a ballerina as a young girl, but ultimately gave up that dream and she has this exact relationship with HER mother. So needless to say this relationship REALLY spoke to me. The mother wants her daughter to remain innocent and perfect and be the ballerina in the box. But she ultimately becomes the broken and chipped away figurine because that's what life does to us. She has to rebel against her mother, her company, and even herself to find the darkness within that she needs to play this part. And if people don't really believe this is what artists go through, they don't have to look as far back as Van Gogh severing his ear to remember the fates of Heath Ledger and River Phoenix. Some artists who try and tap into the darkness wind up killing themselves in the same way Portman's character slips over the edge. That's why I think this movie is so spectacular, and why Portman deserves the Oscar. Her transformation was flawless. And lovely to watch. And Clint Mansell's hypnotic score ushered us along in perfect sync with Portman's descent. For someone who has enjoyed ballets and operas and theatre in general, Aronfsky has given us a dour tour de force that should satisfy most pallets, whether they can handle the macabre elements or not. I can't wait to see what he does with The Wolverine. Haha.… Expand

2 of 5 users found this helpful23

All this user's reviews

9

martinexDec 21, 2010

I've never used this word before but this movie was breath taking. It started out a little slow but man does the pace pick up as the movie goes along. Portman deserves Oscar consideration for an amazing performance. The camera work wasI've never used this word before but this movie was breath taking. It started out a little slow but man does the pace pick up as the movie goes along. Portman deserves Oscar consideration for an amazing performance. The camera work was fantastic. I've never attended a ballet before. I think I'd like to go to one now.… Expand

2 of 6 users found this helpful24

All this user's reviews

9

nomdiploomDec 25, 2010

Definitely worth seeing. The acting is as brilliant as the psyches portrayed are perverse.
Brooding, dark, and mysterious, while compelling you to watch, ever mindful that you do not know what what is truth or delusion.

2 of 6 users found this helpful24

All this user's reviews

10

nutterjrJan 6, 2011

Bravo! Encore! The best film I have seen for a very long time.
A spectacular film, through the brilliant mind of Aranofsky who never ceases to impress me. The story is gripping, with strong contrast between beauty and elegance with darknessBravo! Encore! The best film I have seen for a very long time.
A spectacular film, through the brilliant mind of Aranofsky who never ceases to impress me. The story is gripping, with strong contrast between beauty and elegance with darkness and insanity. The score is really moving and adds to the suspense and the surprisingly the previously shallow Portman brings a rich in layer and depth performance worthy of many awards!… Expand

1 of 3 users found this helpful12

All this user's reviews

9

wishmasterDec 22, 2010

this movie is the best I saw in 2010, amazing, one of the best music underscore.! Portman just wonderful, everything was spectacular ... This combination of psychological drama is a mixture of feelings that you uncoordinated and keeps youthis movie is the best I saw in 2010, amazing, one of the best music underscore.! Portman just wonderful, everything was spectacular ... This combination of psychological drama is a mixture of feelings that you uncoordinated and keeps you glued to the screen until the last minute… Expand

1 of 3 users found this helpful12

All this user's reviews

10

Bama72Dec 21, 2010

This movie is stunning. I just love a movie when, after you leave, you can't stop thinking about it and talking about it. Well made and well acted, a must see.

1 of 3 users found this helpful12

All this user's reviews

10

Mary7Feb 27, 2011

Outstanding. No doubt one of the best films of the year. Best thriller/drama movie I've seen yet. Natalie Portman's performance is incredible, such as the other actors in the film.

1 of 3 users found this helpful12

All this user's reviews

9

ckaryDec 19, 2010

"Black Swan" is a terrifying and beautiful psych-thriller which completely blew me away. I almost felt genuinely sick while watching the movie, similar to the feeling I had while watching the downward spiral that was "Requiem for a Dream;""Black Swan" is a terrifying and beautiful psych-thriller which completely blew me away. I almost felt genuinely sick while watching the movie, similar to the feeling I had while watching the downward spiral that was "Requiem for a Dream;" but I can't say that it wasn't amazing. "Black Swan" hits you at your emotional core, and Portman's performance in the film may very well be her best outing to date. The film follows Nina (Natalie Portman), the main character and recently selected lead in her studio's upcoming production of "Swan Lake," through the weeks leading up to the debut of the play (which is re-instated in a more simple form to attempt to defibrillate the struggling company). As her instructor Thomas (Vincent Cassel) states, the role is very dynamic, and requires her to get "loose" to play the seductive and deceptive black swan. She struggles at first, but soon finds darkness in a life filled with innocence, and becomes ensnared in the role. The movie turns into a nightmarish and terrifying struggle between good and evil, as Nina battles amongst herself to try to come to grips with the ballet role that is consuming her life, and her soul. The film is edgy, raw, and at times, outright frightening. It has that visceral and striking presence which Aronofsky is so masterfully talented at projecting, although it is purposely flawed so that you are sick to your stomach with Nina's mental health. It makes heavy work of symbolism and irony, and repeating themes include duality, hatred, anger, control and insanity. Personally, I loved the film. It is almost impossible to not be hypnotized by the intense cinematography, the outstanding performances, and the bold imagery. The entrancing score by Clint Mansell, a long-time collaborator of Aronofsky's, is real and powerful, and perfectly captures the essence of the film's most intense moments. I guess the one thing which kept me from giving it a ten would be that the film almost does too much at times. It is complicated, and although brilliantly conceived, it draws away from an audience which may more greatly appreciate it for it's terrifying reality, and not its symbolism and depth. Regardless, the movie is greatness in a bottle. If you haven't seen it yet, treat yourself over the holidays; you won't regret it.… Expand

1 of 3 users found this helpful12

All this user's reviews

10

DKayJan 5, 2011

F'in Masterpiece. F'in Masterpiece. F'in Masterpiece. F'in Masterpiece. F'in Masterpiece. F'in Masterpiece. F'in Masterpiece. F'in Masterpiece.

1 of 3 users found this helpful12

All this user's reviews

6

ovi_bzMar 6, 2011

Let's face it: the movie is poor. The only worth mentioning idea is the hallucinating part of Natalie; apart from this, i was very frustrated and nervous watching this movie. I somehow felt it from the beginning that is a poor movie, but iLet's face it: the movie is poor. The only worth mentioning idea is the hallucinating part of Natalie; apart from this, i was very frustrated and nervous watching this movie. I somehow felt it from the beginning that is a poor movie, but i give it a chance. i was disappointed. It is for sure not worth the Oscar. It will be forgotten in time.… Expand

1 of 3 users found this helpful12

All this user's reviews

7

Surtr13Jan 13, 2011

The idea behind the film is pure excellence, especially when compared with The Wrestler. Portman is fantastic of course, but I felt quite bored through large chunks of the film. Good film but I can't say I'll watch it again anytime soon.

1 of 3 users found this helpful12

All this user's reviews

7

TheTerpJan 22, 2011

I am not sure what all the hype is about this flick. It was interesting to watch but the blurring of reality and fantasy made it hard to watch and even believe. Her relationship with her mom was "on the button" and I could feel theI am not sure what all the hype is about this flick. It was interesting to watch but the blurring of reality and fantasy made it hard to watch and even believe. Her relationship with her mom was "on the button" and I could feel the suffocation but everything seemed distanced and forced and unreal. Portman does a great job but her character is down right painful to watch as she careens over her personal cliff... Ilyich's music is used to great effect and the dancing scenes are fascinating...… Expand

1 of 3 users found this helpful12

All this user's reviews

10

JuanmaFernandezMar 5, 2011

With echoes of â

1 of 3 users found this helpful12

All this user's reviews

10

timmcdMar 10, 2011

This movie is easily the best of the year. The film is as intriguing as a Christopher Nolan film and as beautiful as any movie. Natalie Portman is at her best in this movie. Mila Kunis showed us that she is able to do more than just dumbThis movie is easily the best of the year. The film is as intriguing as a Christopher Nolan film and as beautiful as any movie. Natalie Portman is at her best in this movie. Mila Kunis showed us that she is able to do more than just dumb comedy television. It seems that this could be the jumping off point for a very long career for a very talented actress.… Expand

1 of 3 users found this helpful12

All this user's reviews

2

jeanphiltOct 19, 2016

So depressing, I gave 2 stars for the actors great performance .

1 of 3 users found this helpful12

All this user's reviews

9

PierFeb 6, 2011

Again Darren Aronovsky proves he is one fo the few directors trying to push the envelope of cinema. Black Swan is the story about an inner conflict pushed at it's limits, it is not a movie about ballet or the famous Swan Lake. This is aAgain Darren Aronovsky proves he is one fo the few directors trying to push the envelope of cinema. Black Swan is the story about an inner conflict pushed at it's limits, it is not a movie about ballet or the famous Swan Lake. This is a psychological drama, ballet is just a vehicle for that conflict and so ballet fans will probably be disappointed. In fact in the early versions of the script the story unfolded in the world of theater.… Expand

1 of 4 users found this helpful13

All this user's reviews

10

DarkCriticDec 30, 2010

I really love Natalie Portman's performance ever in this dark twisted movie. She really scared everyone in the audience. Black Swan is a perfect film that shows a character who really wanted to become a perfect ballerina so she can be in theI really love Natalie Portman's performance ever in this dark twisted movie. She really scared everyone in the audience. Black Swan is a perfect film that shows a character who really wanted to become a perfect ballerina so she can be in the musical stage and then she got split personality on herself that she couldn't control herself all because of the fears of practicing ballet. But also,I really love for my personally favorite is to all of you men,that we love to see Natalie Portman and Mila Kunis are making out in this picture,that's it!… Expand

1 of 4 users found this helpful13

All this user's reviews

8

TVJerryDec 18, 2010

Natalie Portman gives a career-defining performance as a ballerina who's been chosen to dance the title role in "Swan Lake." Her lack of confidence and obsession with perfection rise to hallucinatory levels before it's all over. DirectorNatalie Portman gives a career-defining performance as a ballerina who's been chosen to dance the title role in "Swan Lake." Her lack of confidence and obsession with perfection rise to hallucinatory levels before it's all over. Director Darren Aronofsky knows how to create a character's world that's intimate and potent. This time he and Portman have plumbed the depths and emerged with a dark, compelling character study.… Expand

1 of 4 users found this helpful13

All this user's reviews

9

JonnyFendiJan 9, 2011

The little girl in LEON: THE PROFESSIONAL (1994) had grown up now. Natalie Portman is at her peak performance so far. Team up with heavy-caliber Director Darren Aronofsky, they made a beautiful story but horrifying at the same time. AronofskyThe little girl in LEON: THE PROFESSIONAL (1994) had grown up now. Natalie Portman is at her peak performance so far. Team up with heavy-caliber Director Darren Aronofsky, they made a beautiful story but horrifying at the same time. Aronofsky is invincible, especially when he explored human desperation, like in his previous films REQUIEM OF A DREAM (2000), THE FOUNTAIN (2006) and THE WRESTLER (2008). For about 100 minutes of the movie, I felt like I was experiencing the theater performance, not just like a common movie. It filled with beautiful images and great orchestra. Nina (Portman) is a chosen ballerina to fulfil her dual roles all at once, to be irresistible innocence White Swan and also to become seductive evil Black Swan. Slowly but sure, the darker side of Black Swan absorbs her real life. I love the brilliant Cinematography. Aronofsky seemed to use two techniques of camera work. One was for The Long Shot, he used steady conventional method. And the second for The Close-up, he used Hand-held Camera. I had ever said that Hand-held Camera is modern technique in today cinematic world. Not only for Action, but recently for Drama as well, Hand-shake Camera is able to effectively drag you into the middle of ongoing situation, if you are not using Hand-held Camera, you are out of date now. The Cast is amazingly fit. Vincent Cassel is fit for provocative and ambitious Ballet Instructor. Mila Kunis is fit for seductive and ambitious Nina colleague. Barbara Hershey is fit for authoritarian and ambitious mother. And even a brief but impressive appearance by Winona Ryder as anxious and ambitious competitor. Yeah, it is all about ambition and you can see it in each character, all of them have their own ambition. However, the star of all stars above is Portman herself. She shows her darker side successfully, you could literally feel her pain, pressure and paranoia situation. The movie becomes more mysterious with some unusual sex scenes. For the last half hour of film duration, she drives us into beautiful but ironic condition, sometimes absurdity become the part of it. Those last scenes are extremely horrified, with broken fingernail, peeling skin and fractured bone for the elements. I almost could categorize thiz movie as a Horror movie. The movie emphasizes in every beautifulness of ballet, there is dark side that we never know before. Finally, I just want to say, It was perfect.

Visit My Blog on JONNY'S MOVEE : http://jonnyfendi.blogspot.com… Expand

1 of 4 users found this helpful13

All this user's reviews

0

Goddessof_BlahMar 17, 2013

a pathetic man's fantasy combined with tricks to convince commercial retards that they're watching an intellectually challenging drama full of culture. Overly dramatic, poorly scripted,a used up ridiculous plot and zero entertainment. It wasa pathetic man's fantasy combined with tricks to convince commercial retards that they're watching an intellectually challenging drama full of culture. Overly dramatic, poorly scripted,a used up ridiculous plot and zero entertainment. It was like watching a cheap street drug addicted prostitute wearing plastering cosmetics in her effort to look beautiful. Or college kids wearing trendy glasses, woolly scarves and holding a copy of War and Peace whilst secretly reading Twilight.… Expand

1 of 4 users found this helpful13

All this user's reviews

8

JamesLDec 18, 2010

This movie was good but the story limited the effect as one knew what the outcome would be. They did a great job of keeping you rattled and not sure of what was real and unreal. Portman dazzled as did Hershey who creeped me out. This willThis movie was good but the story limited the effect as one knew what the outcome would be. They did a great job of keeping you rattled and not sure of what was real and unreal. Portman dazzled as did Hershey who creeped me out. This will make my top ten but not the first five.… Expand

1 of 5 users found this helpful14

All this user's reviews

10

WriteInkDec 17, 2010

Leaving the theater, my friend and I overheard a man say, The lesbian scenes werenâ

1 of 5 users found this helpful14

All this user's reviews

0

Jake98May 29, 2011

Absolute garbage. ...........................................................................................................................................................

1 of 18 users found this helpful117

All this user's reviews

9

ShiiraDec 23, 2010

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. At the end of Rob Marshall's "Chicago", in an effort to clear up any lingering doubts from moviegoers about what they just saw, the titles proudly trumpet that the principal actors did all their own singing and dancing. So adept were Richard Gere, Catherine Zeta-Jones, and Renee Zelwegger at both performing arts, some audience members may have presumed that professionals were called in to do all the heavy lifting, especially the dancing, where, as is the norm for any movie that requires multi-tasking(stunt work, stripping, etc...) of its actors, a double can be inserted whenever the camera catches the body without a head. Knowing this, the novelty aspect behind a Hollywood starlet, a veritable household name, casting vanity aside and trying to disappear into the role of a top-flight ballerina is dispelled, right off the bat, when the filmmaker establishes his subject's competence(or dare I say, mastery) in dramatic fashion. Dancing by herself, establishing shots of Natalie Portman in balletic repose, give way to a close-up of disembodied feet, whose legs, cut off somewhere above the knee, could belong to anybody, but are indeed Portman's, when a camera tilt, along with the dancer's contortions, reorientates the actress to her lowest extremities, right after those thought-to-be-anonymous feet go from horizontal to vertical(in other words, "on point"), and then in gilded motion, like a pro. It's a goosebump moment, believe me. It's really her, the stripper who wouldn't strip in Mike Nichols' "Closer"...doing THAT! With Portman's credibility issues out of the way, this neo-"Repulsion" story becomes the focal point, which wouldn't be the case if Nina Sayers, a woman-girl with mommy issues(and sexuality issues) who's losing it, was heavily subordinated by a Julliard-trained stand-in to do all the hard stuff. The camera doesn't lie, especially a hand-held one, a probing thing that gets in Nina's grille(on and off-the-job), and Portman's body, all sinewy muscle and bone, is the truth, and passes with flying colors. The unbridled passion and masochism and predilection for self-sacrifice that every hungry, up-and-coming dancer possesses is captured in unerring detail by Portman, who on a short-time basis, obviously, went through the same taxing process herself, because you can see, actually see, that she's thinking, as opposed to acting, like a dancer in the cut-throat world of New York City swan-making. When asked by her lecherous ballet director(Vincent Cassell) to embody the second swan with the same assuredness as its white doppleganger, the virginal Nina goes down a rabbit hole of repression and self-hatred when the unformed girl is forced to ruminate over sex, a subject she clearly deflects through overcompensation, in which ballet has proven to be a stunting mechanism for this grown woman(who still lives with her mom and has a room populated with a menagerie stuffed animals), thereby creating a vast disconnect between her emotional and chronological age. When you get right down to it, "Black Swan" is all about f*cking. In her room, Nina touches herself, and is made to feel guilty about having desire, all at once, upon discovery of her mother asleep in a bedside chair(or is she?), indicating a past history in which Erica(Barbara Hershey), a failed dancer who has mixed emotions about her daughter's success, impeded Nina's sexual development through calculated sheltering. Not wanting to draw comparisons with Michael Haneke's "The Piano Teacher", Nina and her mother sleep in separate rooms, but the disturbance created by Erica, her seeming entitlement to be in such close proximity to her adult daughter, suggests that the bedtime arrangements are still new. In a sense, the mother helped birth the black swan that haunts Nina. As a result of her psycho-sexuality, Nina stabs the dark bird, stabs Lily(Mila Kunis), for awakening her greatest fear, inflaming the fragile ballerina to stab herself, out of self-hatred for not being the white swan, mother's "sweet girl".… Expand

0 of 2 users found this helpful02

All this user's reviews

7

DalemDec 26, 2010

{Spoiler alert] Very good movie in many respects. The acting is good and, from a quite formal point of view, the film is well-structured. One of the interesting things about the film is the many thematic references. It references{Spoiler alert] Very good movie in many respects. The acting is good and, from a quite formal point of view, the film is well-structured. One of the interesting things about the film is the many thematic references. It references Freud in dealing with repression and the relation between a woman and her mother. Jung is referenced in the story of how a person must come to terms with his or her "shadow" which is often referred to as a doppleganger. Even French Symbolist poetry with its fondness for the swan, which in French is the "signe"--the sign or symbol, comes into play. If you are a person who really likes things intellectual like this, you will probably get a lot out of this film. However, on an emotional level, the film never takes flight. We really never connect to the character. There is very little emotional variety in this film. It's the same emotion throughout with just an increasing intensity. It may be a "tour de force" but after a while it kind of gets monotonous. When I saw the film, audience members laughed at a scene of a dead body being dragged. (A ballerina dragging a dead body is funny!) I have heard of other viewings with hoots and hollers at the sex scenes. I think people just get bummed out at such "very serious theater" sort of business. At the end of the film, the main character dies. I have yet to hear of anyone shedding a tear for her.… Expand

0 of 3 users found this helpful03

All this user's reviews

8

LynJan 4, 2011

This movie is like "Requiem for a Dream," but with ballet. (Awarded an extra point for Portman's performance -- and actually, Hershey is excellent as well.) I found the mix of blood-sex-fantasy and lunacy quite riveting, but if you want aThis movie is like "Requiem for a Dream," but with ballet. (Awarded an extra point for Portman's performance -- and actually, Hershey is excellent as well.) I found the mix of blood-sex-fantasy and lunacy quite riveting, but if you want a "ballet movie," rent "The Turning Point."… Expand

0 of 2 users found this helpful02

All this user's reviews

9

kingshahidNov 12, 2011

I really enjoyed this movie. I am now a fan of Natalie Portman - who played both naughty and nice in the same movie pertaining to her actual role as black swan. The movie left me confused in many parts but I do understand its use ofI really enjoyed this movie. I am now a fan of Natalie Portman - who played both naughty and nice in the same movie pertaining to her actual role as black swan. The movie left me confused in many parts but I do understand its use of psychology of those that delve into perfectionism. This movie was not something I looked forward to watching - but I'm glad I did.… Expand

0 of 1 users found this helpful01

All this user's reviews

6

BairdoJan 5, 2011

I just plain didn't enjoy this movie. I'd give it another chance if I thought I could sit through it again. It's not a ballet thing either... I could enjoy watching anything if I found the story engaging. Vincent Cassel is great at playingI just plain didn't enjoy this movie. I'd give it another chance if I thought I could sit through it again. It's not a ballet thing either... I could enjoy watching anything if I found the story engaging. Vincent Cassel is great at playing douches...there, I found something semi-positive. Did anyone notice that there was a lot of crotch grabbing in this film? That's all positive.… Expand

0 of 2 users found this helpful02

All this user's reviews

8

egovirusApr 3, 2011

I enjoyed this movie rather more than I had expected to. The first thing I noticed was the novelty of an environment I am utterly ignorant of, a ballet company, rife with all its requisite ambitions and jealousies. Nina's paranoid delusionsI enjoyed this movie rather more than I had expected to. The first thing I noticed was the novelty of an environment I am utterly ignorant of, a ballet company, rife with all its requisite ambitions and jealousies. Nina's paranoid delusions are completely random, and quite unsettling, giving the feeling that we are just as out of control as she since we cannot tell who or what is real at any given moment. What I found most intriguing of all was that for Nina to perform her role as black swan, she had to self destruct/let the crazy out that she (and her mother) had so assiduously kept contained. We are left to imagine the epilogue of this story, and I am rather grateful for that, because we the viewer can always write a better movie than some Hollywood hack factory, right? The movie ends just as Swan Lake ends, with a death, and that is rather clever in that "Black Swan" borrows from a master, to give us a subsidiary tale that can only exist in the shadow of that genius, but oh what a shadow! Tchaikovsky opened the door with his Black Swan, Aronofsky, Heyman, and Heinz merely dared to descibe some of the furniture within, with theirs.… Expand

0 of 1 users found this helpful01

All this user's reviews

9

guitarplayer11Mar 28, 2011

This is one of my favorite movies ever! Natalie Portman deserved her Oscar for her amazing performance. Ever since I saw it, I have been obsessed with it. The acting, story, direction, screenplay, visuals, and music are all perfect. A perfect movie.

0 of 1 users found this helpful01

All this user's reviews

10

MedinaReviewsJan 12, 2011

'"Black Swan'": Horrifically Beautiful

In a year full of great films by Hollywood's most talented storytellers, Black Swan manages to rise above the rest. In today's modern age of crystal clear high-definition and mind-blowing 3D effects,'"Black Swan'": Horrifically Beautiful

In a year full of great films by Hollywood's most talented storytellers, Black Swan manages to rise above the rest.

In today's modern age of crystal clear high-definition and mind-blowing 3D effects, director Darren Aronofsky is not afraid to create a beautiful piece of visual art with grain and grittiness. But how would you classify this film? Psychological thriller? Horror? Art dance piece? The truth is it is all of these, executed to perfection.

A good film is usually respected because the filmmaker is able to execute one or two important elements really well. Either the story is unique and well told, or they were able to get great performances, but it is truly a rare film that is able to tell a compelling story while at the same time using each aspect of filmmaking to its full potential. In "Black Swan", Aronofksy was able bring together production design, cinematography, editing, and sound design in such away that the audience was brought completely into the world of Nina Sayers, played by Natalie Portman. From the very first frame, with Portman dancing alone in a spotlight, the audience can't help but be captivated and drawn into the film.

There were some very interesting, very brilliant choices in cinematography throughout the film. What is truly amazing, looking at the technical specs, is that while most of the film was shot on 16mm film stock, some sequences were seamlessly integrated into the film that were shot on the Canon 7D, a digital camera. How they were able to utilize and intercut the two mediums is remarkable in itself, but Aronofsky and his cinematographer, Matthew Libatique were able to achieve a specific look for every scene in such a way that would have been impossible using only one medium, all the while keeping the overall asthetic of the film surprisingly consistent. But what is really noteworthy of Aronofsky's distinct visual style is his camera work. Starting in "The Wrestler", he began shooting many of his scenes following directly behind his subject. While some storytelling traditionalists might find this odd because you would normally be missing the facial reactions of the characters, it does make you feel like you are experiencing the locations and situations right in the person's shoes, much more so than a point-of-view shot could ever hope to accomplish.

It was remarkable to see the level of perfection they were able to achieve with the camera operation during the dancing sequences as well. What must have taken take after take to nail it just right came across almost effortless, yet ultimately added so much to the choreography and movement of the dancers. Darren Aronofsky is one of the few directors that doesn't just use his camera as a device to show his story to an audience, but rather uses it as an integral storytelling tool.

But what ultimately gave these spectacular shots their power was the editing. With some of the strongest cuts to be put on the screen in decades, editor Andrew Weisblum was able to tell a complicated story at a relentless, riveting pace. Once cut in particular immediately stood out, and that is when the camera is following Portman walking into the Lincoln Center, and we jump-cut to another location while keeping her perfectly in the center of frame. This kind of editing really should not work, because it is visually jarring, yet at the same time it is so intriguing, and practical, to keep the story moving that it perks your attention and keeps you always wanting more. It should be noted here, however, that it is impossible to have this level of editing without having a great sound design accompanying it.

Despite every single member of the crew obviously performing their jobs expertly, this film really only belongs to one person, and that is Natalie Portaman with the role of her lifetime. We have certainly seen different sides of her as an actress, and how she can, with the right direction, completely immerse herself into a character in her previous work, but never like this. Her burden of carrying this film must have been both emotionally and physically draining beyond imagination. When it comes to an actor being dedicated to their craft, you don't get much better than this. Having to not only perfectly execute the transformation in character from a shy, timid girl into a powerful dancer but all the while having to pull off looking like a world-class ballet dancer is not a job for every actress. Portman always had a certain way of drawing the audience in and being completely captivating to watch, but in this film she really had to go into some dark emotional places that she was able to translate directly onto the screen.

medinareviews.com
twitter.com/medinareviews… Expand

0 of 1 users found this helpful01

All this user's reviews

8

AaronMFeb 6, 2011

There are just a lot of really good things about this movie, which includes Natalie Portman and the complexity of her acting role, the directing, and the story. Bravo to solid filmmaking!

0 of 2 users found this helpful02

All this user's reviews

10

GVirus16Apr 11, 2011

I cannot understand why people keep saying that this movie will be "forgotten". I don't think that I will be able to unsee the images I witnessed in this film, and for that, I applaud Black Swan. This is an incredibly beautiful, utterlyI cannot understand why people keep saying that this movie will be "forgotten". I don't think that I will be able to unsee the images I witnessed in this film, and for that, I applaud Black Swan. This is an incredibly beautiful, utterly disturbing film, which will leave you on tenterhooks the entire time. A must-see, and a must-have for the household (though the kids may not want to watch...).… Expand

0 of 1 users found this helpful01

All this user's reviews

9

DukeJan 4, 2011

We manifest our own destiny; we either create our own brilliant success or our tragic downfall. Regardless of the situation, most of our problems donâ

0 of 1 users found this helpful01

All this user's reviews

8

VAFrankyDec 26, 2010

This movie was excellent. Some of the scenes made you feel so embarrassed or ashamed for the main character, but I think that is exactly what Aronofsky was going for. This movie contains some of the best acting that I have seen out of NatalieThis movie was excellent. Some of the scenes made you feel so embarrassed or ashamed for the main character, but I think that is exactly what Aronofsky was going for. This movie contains some of the best acting that I have seen out of Natalie Portman yet which totally validates my thoughts that she has been throwing her potential away thus far in her career. Mila Kunis, Vincent Cassel as the slimy Ballerina director and; surprise, Winona Ryder are also excellent. The movie also gets its message across and gets out, instead of lingering on needlessly like many art house type movies tend to do. This movie may be a little emotionally draining for some but I think that it is one of Aronofsky's best work. I'm not even that fond of Aronofsky's earlier films save The Wrestler, but I think he did a really good job with this one.… Expand

0 of 2 users found this helpful02

All this user's reviews

10

chotzyJan 24, 2011

mila kunis eating the clung out of natalie portman please this is 10 out of 10 material it was a shame u didnt get to see the company director get up to his nuts in guts though

0 of 2 users found this helpful02

All this user's reviews

9

bitburnJan 14, 2011

Mila Kunitz + Nathalie Portman = Sublime! Awesome movie, weird, dark, spooky, yummy! One of the best film I have seen this year. Portman is a wonderful actress that finally gets the shot of her career.

0 of 1 users found this helpful01

All this user's reviews

9

InfamousPrinceJan 7, 2011

I'm not a big fan of this type of movies, but I'll still separate this film, because as far as the cast, this film is phenomenal, in terms of story, is simply great and I think this film, with all the awards and nominations he has received,I'm not a big fan of this type of movies, but I'll still separate this film, because as far as the cast, this film is phenomenal, in terms of story, is simply great and I think this film, with all the awards and nominations he has received, is excellent. Strongly recommend that you look, whether in cinema or on TV.… Expand

0 of 2 users found this helpful02

All this user's reviews

8

cinemaquoteJan 30, 2011

Aronofsky very much tries to make the case of Black Swan as a companion piece for The Wrestler... yet it isn't. Evidently, bi-dimensional Portman + sexy Kunis + perfect Winona + just a pinch of Cassel - botoxed Hershey = great cast. I wasAronofsky very much tries to make the case of Black Swan as a companion piece for The Wrestler... yet it isn't. Evidently, bi-dimensional Portman + sexy Kunis + perfect Winona + just a pinch of Cassel - botoxed Hershey = great cast. I was more moved by the Rodarte's costumes that the final punch. Nonetheless, this should be watched as a chapter in Aronofsky's career and most certainly Portman's. Can do without the french fiance-dancer. @cinemaquote… Expand

0 of 2 users found this helpful02

All this user's reviews

9

SyrnykDec 25, 2010

Great film. Cements Natalie as a solid actress capable of playing any role. This film twists the very foundation of art and makes one look at dance from a different frame - examining the damaging components. One of the strongest films to beGreat film. Cements Natalie as a solid actress capable of playing any role. This film twists the very foundation of art and makes one look at dance from a different frame - examining the damaging components. One of the strongest films to be released in 2010 for sure.… Expand

0 of 2 users found this helpful02

All this user's reviews

10

davidp1045Jan 9, 2011

Really good movie. Excellent acting from the cast, especially Natalie Portman. The scene with her and Mila Kunis in her bedroom was amazing. I left the theatre stunned, in a good way. Go see it now!

0 of 4 users found this helpful04

All this user's reviews

8

2GUI2Feb 18, 2011

Itâ

0 of 2 users found this helpful02

All this user's reviews

8

allystewJan 10, 2011

This movie is two people. Darren Aronofsky is back to his deep psychological best and Natalie Portman in a definate Oscar nomination role. This movie will not be for everyone, but if you've seen Requiem For A Dream (in my opinion stillThis movie is two people. Darren Aronofsky is back to his deep psychological best and Natalie Portman in a definate Oscar nomination role. This movie will not be for everyone, but if you've seen Requiem For A Dream (in my opinion still Aronofskys best work) and could handle the tough but powerful scenes and performances then this is for you. A deep and dark delight.… Expand

0 of 2 users found this helpful02

All this user's reviews

7

macks4386Jan 2, 2011

I still haven't decided whether this movie was good or not; but it certainly was one of the most enthralling films I have seen in a long time (Gives new meaning to the genre of psychological thriller). Portman's acting is out of this world,I still haven't decided whether this movie was good or not; but it certainly was one of the most enthralling films I have seen in a long time (Gives new meaning to the genre of psychological thriller). Portman's acting is out of this world, and the cinematography is certainly unique and complex. Definitely worth a watch...… Expand

0 of 3 users found this helpful03

All this user's reviews

10

jbarkin13Jan 2, 2011

From the opening scene to the final credits this movie had me completely wrapped around its finger for the whole time. Natalie Portman gives a performance of a lifetime. The story and direction are executed brilliantly. Though I could talk adFrom the opening scene to the final credits this movie had me completely wrapped around its finger for the whole time. Natalie Portman gives a performance of a lifetime. The story and direction are executed brilliantly. Though I could talk ad nauseum about the depth and message of the movie, it can simply be summed up by saying everyone involved in this movie deserves any award they are nominated for.… Expand

0 of 3 users found this helpful03

All this user's reviews

10

timeformimeJan 19, 2011

(old review) Critics who don't get this movie or old prudes need not apply. This is one of the most beautifully chaotic yet intelligent movies I have seen. As long as you have good taste and a functioning brain you'll like it, and especially(old review) Critics who don't get this movie or old prudes need not apply. This is one of the most beautifully chaotic yet intelligent movies I have seen. As long as you have good taste and a functioning brain you'll like it, and especially so if you are an artist yourself because it gives you, not so much a comment or exploration (fast becoming a cliche in the critical world), but a feeling of art and the excesses to which artists willingly go for their art. This is why I have a feeling some critics didn't "get it." Critics too often calculate and add up too much to recognize their own feelings about a movie, and frequently judge a movie based on its adherence to a particular formula, but this movie tosses away a formula and creates its own impressionistic view of a situation, much like Aronofsky's Requiem for a Dream. There is an added bonus if you are an artist who has given themselves to a project and sacrificed something for it, because this movie shows you the extremes to which you can go for that feeling of having done your job to perfection. As an actor I sympathize mostly with Nina's desire to be perfect and to successfully fulfill her director's wishes, and I'm sure it would apply to so many other fields of creative art.

Make no mistake, it is a melodrama, and I would compare its tone to the books of Dostoevsky, only with less dialogue and more chaotic dance. It's really quite Russian, as ballet was embraced by the Russians more than many other countries, and let's face it, no one else has matched Fyodor's skill for introspective melodrama in any medium. The end result is that the tone and the subject seem made for each other. Nina is consumed by one zealous focus similar to Alexei Ivanovich, and the style added by Aronofsky's direction makes it totally his. The fast editing, mesmerizing dance choreography, and excellent score made me dizzy, and that was exactly the point. But the one thing that made it truly great as opposed to a beautiful disaster was Natalie Portman. Good God, she gave herself to this role and jumped into the deep end. It's a lovely thing to see an actress these days with talents to match her beauty, and as evidenced in Leon, Natalie has always had talent, but she seemed to have left it at home for a while. Well, all her other roles were warmups compared to this. Paychecks to make it to this script. So haters gonna hate, but you will love or at least appreciate this movie if you let it take you away to another world, or in the case of this one, into someone's eff'd up but utterly fascinating mind. All who love art and good movies go see this now!… Expand

0 of 3 users found this helpful03

All this user's reviews

9

tyronerubinJan 5, 2011

In Black Swan, Darren Aronofsky creates a nightmarish world that the audience is viscerally thrown into, with continuous twists and surprises at every step of the way, never knowing what will happen next. We only hope there is some salvationIn Black Swan, Darren Aronofsky creates a nightmarish world that the audience is viscerally thrown into, with continuous twists and surprises at every step of the way, never knowing what will happen next. We only hope there is some salvation at the end. Black Swan is created by one of the most passionate bright young filmmakers alive. The camera style is more regimented and thoughtfully composted compared to the cinema verite, looser, documentary style of The Wrestler. Every shot is perfectly thought out, and the use of mirrors in this film is simply magnificent. The monochromatic colour tone is stunning and at all times the colour palette of everything in shot is tempered to enhance the story. Especially in the wardrobe coloring. The Wrestler was based in the real world, the world we all live in, where a man is grappling with the failures in life, has a daughter, works part-time as a butcher, falls for a stripper and tries to resurrect his fledgling career. It deals with his ego and his determination. Its almost documentary in style. Black Swan is a film sprung from Darren Aronofsky's imagination, aided by a team of talented writers. It is a dark tale of ones inner struggle with perfection. In essence the film centers on the central character of Nina Sayers as she grapples with life as a star ballerina. She does all she can to find perfection within her self and with others. We go into the depths of her mind, and at times the film is as frightening as a Polanski film, at its best. Natalie Portman went on a rigorous training regime for this film and it shows, her performance is mature, dark and stunning. I can continue to write numerous pages on pledging my love for this film but I wont waste my time, or yours, as if you need further information on this, the web is abound with it. When Darren Aronofsky was recently talking about his next film, The Wolverine he made a very interesting point "Iâ… Expand

0 of 2 users found this helpful02

All this user's reviews

10

criticalrangerJan 9, 2011

Almost certainly one of the best films I have ever seen. It has the same levels of intensity as a **** film, and uses the same black and white depiction of good and evil to visually emphasize the thematic progression. To say this film rockedAlmost certainly one of the best films I have ever seen. It has the same levels of intensity as a **** film, and uses the same black and white depiction of good and evil to visually emphasize the thematic progression. To say this film rocked me, frightened me, and amazed me would be an understatement. I have never, ever had to sit down in the theatre lobby after a movie to process what was just viewed - to do it for 30 minutes, only saying to my friends over and over and over again how good the film was, really made it clear that what I watched was something of great power. An important film in the history of film, I hope. Certainly an important film thematically, touching so many ideas and breaking so many expectations - leaving you confused and terrified for the truth....

Absolutely stunning.… Expand

0 of 3 users found this helpful03

All this user's reviews

7

juliankleissJan 7, 2011

Warns that inexorable perfectionism may lead to insanity. Picturing two opposite, and problematic extremes of living: safe, or self-destructive; eventually leaving the audience to conclude for themselves, that it would be best to pursue aWarns that inexorable perfectionism may lead to insanity. Picturing two opposite, and problematic extremes of living: safe, or self-destructive; eventually leaving the audience to conclude for themselves, that it would be best to pursue a balanced middle way. Sympathetic character, some quite shocking moments.… Expand

0 of 3 users found this helpful03

All this user's reviews

10

GoldheartMar 7, 2011

I just watched the film yesterday, and I can honestly say that "Black Swan" is, without a doubt, my favorite film of all times, (beating my former favorite: Fellini's "Eight and a Half"). In a sense, both films have lots in common. BothI just watched the film yesterday, and I can honestly say that "Black Swan" is, without a doubt, my favorite film of all times, (beating my former favorite: Fellini's "Eight and a Half"). In a sense, both films have lots in common. Both explore the inner turmoil and real-life hardships of people working in the entertainment business, or that of artists in general. Both films are centered on characters how are under massive pressure from the people in their lives, and both little by little fall appart because of it.
Now that I think about it, however, unlike "Eight and a Half", "Black Swan" is not a "comedy" (as Fellini himself defined his film) but is almost a horror film. Nina Sayers (amazingly performed by Natalie Portman, who has become my second favorite actress, after Marion Cotillard) is evidently losing her mind, suffering from hallucinations and paranoia, which may or may not be completelly unjustified, living under the rule of a manipulative and oppressive mother, who tries to compensate her own failure as a ballerina by forcing her daughter to devote her whole existence to ballet. Nina is unhealthilly obsessed with perfection, and it seems as if she was a robot, whose only purpose is to dance.
"Black Swan" is enthralling, disturbing and terrifying. It keeps you on the edge all the way, even if the whole premise becomes obvious and predictable, because the film's point of view is completelly focused on Nina, and thus, even the most surrealistic events don't seem entirelly unreal. Near the end of the film, you lose, just like Nina, the ability to distinguish between what is real and what isn't.
The other actors are excellent in their performance, and the soundtrack, which I guess belongs to the actual "Swan Lake", is not only fitting but it even helps to pull you into every scene, but the largest assets are the scarse, but bone-chilling, special effects, and Natalie Portman's mind-bending, trully Oscar-deserving performance.
You want a good mind-f***k? Go and watch "Black Swan"!!
Score: 10.0… Expand

0 of 2 users found this helpful02

All this user's reviews

10

jsadamsJan 9, 2011

Variously described as a psychological thriller, a body horror film or a descent into madness, the film follows the mental and emotional detoriation of a young ballerina attempting the lead role in swan lake. Pressured by her overbearingVariously described as a psychological thriller, a body horror film or a descent into madness, the film follows the mental and emotional detoriation of a young ballerina attempting the lead role in swan lake. Pressured by her overbearing mother living vicariously through her, her fiercly competitive peers and her psychologically and sexually assertive director her already frail personality deteriorates.
The film variously addresses the balance between perfection, control and passion. It also portrays Obssesive complusive disorder, body dysmorphism, self mutilation, bulimia, anorexia and the visual hallucinations of psychoses.

The film is shot in a grainy, close up, hand held style and in such a manner the audience is barely able to disthinquish reality from fantasy much as the main character herself can not. The file is a likely n od for best picture, best director and best actress and perhaps other technical awards as well. Not for everyone but definitely a critical and artistic acheivement of note.… Expand

0 of 3 users found this helpful03

All this user's reviews

10

FranciscoAzenhaJan 10, 2011

Wonderful film, both artistic and psychological approaches were fantastic. Nina didn't distinguish reality from imagination until the end, it was necessary for her to kill Lily so she could be her alter-ego (in the way it resembles Lily),Wonderful film, both artistic and psychological approaches were fantastic. Nina didn't distinguish reality from imagination until the end, it was necessary for her to kill Lily so she could be her alter-ego (in the way it resembles Lily), certain psychological depth. She took the path of the self abyss, so when she could became perfection she died, has a being she could never achieve.
I've red so many critics, and still, I doubt if some journalists should have their way in critics.
Certainly the best of the year… Expand

0 of 2 users found this helpful02

All this user's reviews

9

DPadsJan 10, 2011

The best way to describe Black Swan would be to call it an artsy psychological thriller. Darren Aronofsky goes from making us sympathize with large sweaty men hitting each other with chairs to making pretty girls in tutus scary as hell, andThe best way to describe Black Swan would be to call it an artsy psychological thriller. Darren Aronofsky goes from making us sympathize with large sweaty men hitting each other with chairs to making pretty girls in tutus scary as hell, and he does it with style. From the first frame to the final fade Swan is a breathless descent into madness which left me breathless at the end. I went into the movie expecting it to be intense, but I was in no way prepared for what was in store and I will say I left the theatre very happy. Very disturbed, but happy. Portman is amazing as Nina pulling the audience down into madness with her, making a gradual transition which is captivating to watch (which is good because she gets the vast majority of the the screen time). Mila Kunis is frightening as Lily, changing from breezy and friendly to dark and scary on a dime creating a terrifying antagonist for Nina while also serving to be a great foil as well. However the one dark horse in the movie is Winona Ryder, who doesn't have very much screen time but makes every second count making the audience deathly afraid of her character while still feeling an overwhelming sense of pity as well. Aronofsky's direction is certainly felt, but it never gets in the way, deftly moving from scene to scene and gradually increasing the tension like a master. The visuals of the film are nothing short of beautiful, even with the purposefully dark and grainy filming. In my opinion it is one of the best of the year, the best thing both Portman, Kunis and Aronofsky have done as well. However the dark tone and graphic nature of the film is definitely not for everyone.… Expand

0 of 2 users found this helpful02

All this user's reviews

10

ziggy2dopeJan 22, 2011

My full review is available on my blog at www.thecriticalfan.blogspot.com My very general thoughts below:

Darren Aronofsky once directed a gorgeous film called â

0 of 1 users found this helpful01

All this user's reviews

10

ZorglyFeb 8, 2011

A dark, twisted, haunting masterpiece. If Portman doesnt win her first oscar here I will be surprised. Aronofsky is one of the best directors currently in hollywood.

0 of 4 users found this helpful04

All this user's reviews

8

LillyanneS1Jan 16, 2011

If you have watched Mr Magoriam With Dustin Hoffman you would know that Black Swan's star Natalie Portman stars alongside Hoffman ^she does deserve her GG & SAG nominations

0 of 2 users found this helpful02

All this user's reviews

9

QuneJan 18, 2011

reaayggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggvbnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnn

0 of 3 users found this helpful03

All this user's reviews

9

lyric555Jan 19, 2011

This movie is definitely worth watching. Natalie Portman does a superb job as a dwindling and fragile young ballerina, and the beautiful artistic direction is wonderful to watch on screen. Within the first 20 minutes of watching, I hadThis movie is definitely worth watching. Natalie Portman does a superb job as a dwindling and fragile young ballerina, and the beautiful artistic direction is wonderful to watch on screen. Within the first 20 minutes of watching, I had immediately decided that I liked the film. On the negative side, the dialouge was bland and Mila Kunis' character had no depth. Otherwise, this film is a must-see from 2010.… Expand

0 of 2 users found this helpful02

All this user's reviews

9

Stephmeister02Jan 20, 2011

This movie is imaginative and new. It's an experience. The use of mirrors in this movie was creative and unique. And Natalie Portman was phenomenal. Enough said.

0 of 2 users found this helpful02

All this user's reviews

8

mattcarrJan 21, 2011

Darren Aronofsky has a flair for a finale. Black Swan blazes towards the finish line with the same incredibly devastating force Requiem for a Dream had close to the end, more than justifying the time you commit. Both films are uncomfortableDarren Aronofsky has a flair for a finale. Black Swan blazes towards the finish line with the same incredibly devastating force Requiem for a Dream had close to the end, more than justifying the time you commit. Both films are uncomfortable but arresting viewing, and both are worthy of any praise they can be given. A return to form for Aronofsky and the inconstant Natalie Portman, and one well worth the Oscar buzz.… Expand

0 of 2 users found this helpful02

All this user's reviews

9

fitchbuckJan 22, 2011

Iâ

0 of 3 users found this helpful03

All this user's reviews

8

hollowayJan 31, 2011

When appraised as a melodrama with all the heightened sense of reality of the ballet within the film, the barbed accusations of overacting and lack of believability seem rather less sharp. Similarly, there's a sense of inevitability to theWhen appraised as a melodrama with all the heightened sense of reality of the ballet within the film, the barbed accusations of overacting and lack of believability seem rather less sharp. Similarly, there's a sense of inevitability to the tragic climax that renders accusations of predictability mute. Natalie Portman puts in a career-defining performance that puts the ghost of the Star Wars prequels well and truly to rest. Darren Aronofsky paints a surprisingly chilling picture with a vibrant palette. The audience is perpetually on edge, and it is this tension that ensures the film's eroticism never becomes gratuitous titillation. The climax is a stunning crescendo of sensory overload that will leave even the most manly men clamouring for tickets to the next production of Swan Lake.… Expand

0 of 3 users found this helpful03

All this user's reviews

8

Aiden26Feb 2, 2011

Let's make this short and sweet, Natalie Portman was outstanding and I wouldn't know how to make a movie about ballet interesting but Darren did a hell of a job. There was a little but of confusion on my end as to what was real and whatLet's make this short and sweet, Natalie Portman was outstanding and I wouldn't know how to make a movie about ballet interesting but Darren did a hell of a job. There was a little but of confusion on my end as to what was real and what wasn't but all in all this movie was fantastic.… Expand

0 of 3 users found this helpful03

All this user's reviews

9

nk40699Feb 6, 2011

Black Swan was, by far, the best movie of the year. Going into the movie, I didn't quite know what to expect besides that it was a dark ballet movie. I was honestly blown away with what I received from that movie. To take ballet and transformBlack Swan was, by far, the best movie of the year. Going into the movie, I didn't quite know what to expect besides that it was a dark ballet movie. I was honestly blown away with what I received from that movie. To take ballet and transform it into that is just amazing. Great movie from start to finish, especially that of the last twenty or thirty minutes. That was the truly breathtaking segment of the movie. All that needs to be said about Natalie Portman is amazing and best actress of the year. And for Darren Aronofsky, best director. This movie, hands down, deserves those three Oscars.… Expand

0 of 3 users found this helpful03

All this user's reviews

10

SpykeFeb 7, 2011

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Portman delivers a brilliant performance in this beautifully illustrated film about a girl picked to be the White Swan in her Ballet group's next performance of Swan Lake, only to go mad from stress and her fear another girl is trying to get her part.

Kunis came right out of Family Guy to give us her OSCAR Snubbed performance that let's us see her in an all new light!

The film brings ballet, something that would put a man off by but it captures the thrills and the horror and neatly sows them into place into this artistic picture everyone can enjoy.… Expand

0 of 2 users found this helpful02

All this user's reviews

10

ranmancarmelFeb 10, 2011

This movie pulls you in demanding an emotional response and keeping you on edge. Surely this is what movies are all about: making you invest in the story and want to see the outcome, no matter how nail-biting the ride may be. The final tenThis movie pulls you in demanding an emotional response and keeping you on edge. Surely this is what movies are all about: making you invest in the story and want to see the outcome, no matter how nail-biting the ride may be. The final ten minutes are stunning, as is Natalie Portman's performance. I could feel her pain and uncertainty. I went away thinking that it was the best performance, and transformation, since Meryl Streep in "Sophie's Choice". And, having had a schizophrenic child in my household, complete with his delusions of grandeur and hallucinations, I can completely understand the darkness in Portman's character. When she said, "I want it to be perfect" I knew her at once, without the obvious bulimia or scratching or delusions. The people around her had tortured her into becoming the caged animal waiting to break out. Bravo!… Expand

0 of 3 users found this helpful03

All this user's reviews

9

Critic_PleaseFeb 12, 2011

Beautiful. Real. Spellbinding and intense. Natalie Portman is timid and fragile and utterly hopeless incapable of dancing the Black Swan. The stress and strain of the dancing world is deeper the physiology...it's a state of being - inBeautiful. Real. Spellbinding and intense. Natalie Portman is timid and fragile and utterly hopeless incapable of dancing the Black Swan. The stress and strain of the dancing world is deeper the physiology...it's a state of being - in perfection. The quest for it is at the loss of so many other things. A loss? Nay, perhaps a worthy compromise. Black Swan is not the fragile, delicate ballerina movie you might expect. Nearer is the comparison to The Sixth Sense, with gripping ferocity amidst bashful vulnerability.… Expand

0 of 2 users found this helpful02

All this user's reviews

8

YumnyMar 20, 2011

Black Swan offers a bizarre and overwhelming look inside the mind of a psychotic artist. Viewing the film leaves any perceptive audience questioning what caused the heroine to become so twisted, and what causes her sadistic supervisors toBlack Swan offers a bizarre and overwhelming look inside the mind of a psychotic artist. Viewing the film leaves any perceptive audience questioning what caused the heroine to become so twisted, and what causes her sadistic supervisors to keep believing in such a frail and inept person. Some scenes fit into the clichÃ© horror film, some others are so psychologically disturbing it leaves you breathless. Natalie Portman performs greatly accurate and clearly crosses boundaries in her acting the script would've otherwise kept lesser great actresses from. Mila Kunis is an unusual but perfectly fitting addition to an artsy, brilliant cast. In conclusion, the movie is scarier and more surprising than it's beginning promises - a must see, but not for the weak hearted.… Expand

0 of 1 users found this helpful01

All this user's reviews

8

BathtubTomFeb 23, 2011

I admit, that as a teenage guy it was a little hard to watch a movie that focused on dancing. But as it turns out this movie is quite good. The entire movie has an art type feel to it, which im sure the movie was trying to portray. TheI admit, that as a teenage guy it was a little hard to watch a movie that focused on dancing. But as it turns out this movie is quite good. The entire movie has an art type feel to it, which im sure the movie was trying to portray. The symbolism is beautiful and im not surprised to see it nominated for best picture. (though it wont win)… Expand

0 of 2 users found this helpful02

All this user's reviews

8

jimmytancrediMay 29, 2011

If someone stole the whole show was Natalie Portman. She delivers the performance of a lifetime. Forget "Star Wars", "V for Vendetta" and keep a bit of "Leon" and "Garden State"... You are not the best young actress at the moment but you areIf someone stole the whole show was Natalie Portman. She delivers the performance of a lifetime. Forget "Star Wars", "V for Vendetta" and keep a bit of "Leon" and "Garden State"... You are not the best young actress at the moment but you are definitely on the top one! If Natalie doesn't deserve an Oscar for her portraying of Nina Sayers then nobody ever did. This movie takes the story of dual personalities to a whole new level of unknown, which is beautifully portrayed by Natalie Portman, taking her to a spot where the Oscar doesn't look like just a dream anymore. It's a touching story, based around a small group of characters, and that's a place where Aronofsky is at his best (i.e. Requiem for a dream). Also, it would be unfair to forget Vincent Cassel, who showed himself in a totally different manner creating a strong, patriarchal character. In the end, this work of art is worth every single dollar and minute you spend on it. It's a guaranteed classic!… Expand

0 of 1 users found this helpful01

All this user's reviews

9

Mr_dYbFeb 22, 2011

One on the most disturbing movie i have ever seen! Portman it's just amazing. Darren Aronofsky made a wonderful direction with this movie. The music of clint mendell its probably one of the best soundtrack of all times.

0 of 2 users found this helpful02

All this user's reviews

7

Efreet69Feb 22, 2011

I just want to say this is my inaugural review on Metacritic. As they say in the sports radio world, I've been a "longtime listener; first time caller." in regards to Metacritic. But, you know, with reading and writing. Having said that, letI just want to say this is my inaugural review on Metacritic. As they say in the sports radio world, I've been a "longtime listener; first time caller." in regards to Metacritic. But, you know, with reading and writing. Having said that, let me say this about Black Swan Here's my review... -------------- Black Swan. "The gripping tale of a schizophrenic's quest for the ultimate orgasm." I just don't know how else to tagline this movie. Portman is transcendent in this deeply psychological role. I don't see her losing the Best Actress Oscar. And Mila Kunis holds her own -- and some of Portman's -- in a deftly turned supporting performance. The music is beautiful, as would be expected, and the film gives you a greater respect for ballerinas as expert craftswomen. At least, it did for me. The story itself seems more a lattice upon which the performances flourish like ivy, as opposed to the characters driving a strong, riveting story. This may be a disappointment to some who desire a more traditional three-act story with a clear resolution. And one last thought. Kudos to Winona Rider for her particularly dark, near-cameo turn as a past-her-prime prima ballerina. Quite riveting. My Verdict: Three and a half Stars -------------- Check out my taste in movies here: http://bit.ly/MyMovies… Expand

0 of 2 users found this helpful02

All this user's reviews

10

UfandetchitchuFeb 24, 2011

This is the type of movies that elevates cinema as an art to a whole higher level. There's been a very few in the last decade, and "Black Swan" is one of them. It's transcending. It's something else. Makes you remember/realize how powerfulThis is the type of movies that elevates cinema as an art to a whole higher level. There's been a very few in the last decade, and "Black Swan" is one of them. It's transcending. It's something else. Makes you remember/realize how powerful movies can be and how they can truly be masterpieces and have a life and a full universe of their own. As disturbingly beautiful as Munch's "Scream" is.… Expand

0 of 2 users found this helpful02

All this user's reviews

9

BShea423Feb 25, 2011

One of the best movies I have seen in a while. The directing was absolutely spectacular, and the way the main character's transformation mirrored the storyline of Swan Lake was excellent. Portman is absolutely deserving of an oscar for herOne of the best movies I have seen in a while. The directing was absolutely spectacular, and the way the main character's transformation mirrored the storyline of Swan Lake was excellent. Portman is absolutely deserving of an oscar for her performance.… Expand

0 of 2 users found this helpful02

All this user's reviews

10

CarlosAugusto15Feb 26, 2011

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. This movie is one of the best. It has suspense from beginning to end, the actors are great. I love these thrillers. History is great, the script is great. The soundtrack of a touch of suspense in the songs. One of the best films of 2010 to 2011.… Expand

0 of 2 users found this helpful02

All this user's reviews

8

dlynch18Feb 27, 2011

Great acting and storyline had twists and turns that kept me interested throughout the whole film. The best movie I saw all year. Great to see an original movie, when all that is being put out right now is sequels and remakes of a TV showsGreat acting and storyline had twists and turns that kept me interested throughout the whole film. The best movie I saw all year. Great to see an original movie, when all that is being put out right now is sequels and remakes of a TV shows from the 80s.… Expand

0 of 2 users found this helpful02

All this user's reviews

10

steve_stiffFeb 28, 2011

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. An amazing movie with the best spectacular performance of Natalie Portman. It's another good movie by Aronovsky. Undoubtedly worth seeing. Go to the cinema!… Expand

0 of 2 users found this helpful02

All this user's reviews

8

Dylanmc12Mar 15, 2011

I LOVE J/PhycoLogical Horror!
This is just great!
Natalie Portman puts a lot of work into it. The director is awesome! And there's a lesbian sex scene in 'ere. It's not awesome for obvious reasons, it's well directed, it has a huge impact onI LOVE J/PhycoLogical Horror!
This is just great!
Natalie Portman puts a lot of work into it.
The director is awesome!
And there's a lesbian sex scene in 'ere.
It's not awesome for obvious reasons, it's well directed, it has a huge impact on the plot, and it actually "Means" something!

Oh.. and it's scary as ****… Expand

0 of 1 users found this helpful01

All this user's reviews

7

KendylKlownfishMar 5, 2011

While I'm a bit appalled by its premise, Black Swan is embracingly intense, indescribably frightening, and seductive, with wonderful performances by Natalie Portman and Mila Kunis.

0 of 1 users found this helpful01

All this user's reviews

10

JuggernautMar 8, 2011

It pretty obvious whats going to be the ending, but its beautifully delivered. The actors are beyond expectations. Great production team. The dialogues are poor in a few parts. One of the best movies i have seen. Worth watching.

0 of 2 users found this helpful02

All this user's reviews

9

Wheezy247Apr 11, 2011

This is Natalie Portman's best role, period. She nails her role as a tortured ballerina that is slowly losing her mind. The plot isn't extraordinary, but it is still griping from beginning to end. The music and cinematography are absolutelyThis is Natalie Portman's best role, period. She nails her role as a tortured ballerina that is slowly losing her mind. The plot isn't extraordinary, but it is still griping from beginning to end. The music and cinematography are absolutely beautiful. It was thrilling and many times gave me a chill. There were multiple times where I cringed at what was occurring on screen. When I first heard about this movie, I thought it was going to really about ballet, and it did not seem to interest me that much, but it is far from it. It involves ballerinas, but it is more about being able to be a little crazy to reach artistic perfection. It was thrilling and occasionally scary at parts, and I definitely believe that Natalie Portman deserves the award she received.… Expand

0 of 1 users found this helpful01

All this user's reviews

10

schmageggeyMar 30, 2011

I'm a very picky person, and I only have a very short list of mives that are my all time favorites, and not is Black Swan in that list, but it tops off that list. It is simply the best film I've ever seen. Number one Natalie Portman wasI'm a very picky person, and I only have a very short list of mives that are my all time favorites, and not is Black Swan in that list, but it tops off that list. It is simply the best film I've ever seen. Number one Natalie Portman was phenominal in her role as Nina. It was a very hard role, and she had it doen to a T. She totally desereved her Oscar. The real star though is Darren Aronofsky. His direction in this film was absolutley breathtaking. He is one of the best filmmakers left in Hollywood. His movies are always good, if not great. The way he directed this film was a spooky and creepy. The way the classical music was used in this film was absolutley genius. The cinematography in every scene was excellent. It created the tension for the film and never let you go until the last moment. The use of black and white as symbolism was also a very good mood and the love scene between Natalie Portman and Mila Kunis was beautiful. It wasn't gratuitous or exploitative. It was forced or thrown in. It went with the movie. The film creeped me out, it had at the edge of my seat and at that final moment, it had me tearing up. Why didn't this movie win any more Oscars? It was absolutley perfect. This film stayed with me even after I watched it and I have a feeling that it will stay with me for a long time.… Expand

0 of 1 users found this helpful01

All this user's reviews

10

jacobo23Apr 3, 2011

This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Just... perfect.........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................… Expand

0 of 2 users found this helpful02

All this user's reviews

10

farlcoonApr 20, 2011

10 because watching it at an independent cinema about a month after it released was the best cinema experience i've had. If this film was watched at anything less than a home cinema, it wouldn't have been anywhere near as enjoyable.

0 of 1 users found this helpful01

All this user's reviews

8

lovemusicMay 20, 2011

Natalie Portman deserves a lot of props. she was excellent in this film. it was gorgeous to look at. the ending was the best. it was acted to perfection by Portman. the choreography was good. Natalie Portman deserved the Oscar

0 of 1 users found this helpful01

All this user's reviews

10

ImmortalGeorgeMay 14, 2011

One word describes the entire film phenomenal !!!! I loved the cinematography and the fascinating plot that keeps you on the edge of your seat ,and left you craving to perceive what was approaching next . This film easily sucks you in andOne word describes the entire film phenomenal !!!! I loved the cinematography and the fascinating plot that keeps you on the edge of your seat ,and left you craving to perceive what was approaching next . This film easily sucks you in and won't let your interest vanish.… Expand

0 of 1 users found this helpful01

All this user's reviews

8

randomdudeJun 6, 2011

Definitely more a ch... err woman's flik, but I still enjoyed it.

Slow paced, but for a reason, not to milk the clock.

Nuanced performances that satisfied. All around a solid movie, that deserves my 8 and then some.

0 of 1 users found this helpful01

All this user's reviews

6

keep_yr_biasFeb 15, 2012

I finally saw this movie recently. If I were rating this on a scale of ballerina/dance movies, it would get a flawless 10 out of 10 score. I never would have thought that a ballerina/dance movie could be this interesting. A lot of theI finally saw this movie recently. If I were rating this on a scale of ballerina/dance movies, it would get a flawless 10 out of 10 score. I never would have thought that a ballerina/dance movie could be this interesting. A lot of the credit goes to Natalie Portman, who is phenomenal in this movie. All that being said, as a movie, it's just pretty good. It simply wasn't entertaining enough, and there were too many scenes that didn't seem to have much of a point. Worst of all, I didn't feel much of a connection with any of the characters (as good as Portman was). I've heard some people compare this to the Wrestler (which seems pretty fair). The difference between those two though is that Mickey Rourke's character seemed so much more human than Portman's character. It's pretty hard to really like Portman's character in this, considering she's a borderline pyscho. Decent movie, overhyped, probably won't see it again, but don't regret seeing it. Certainly gets points for originality.… Expand

0 of 1 users found this helpful01

All this user's reviews

3

kublay0880Dec 19, 2012

This is the most OVERRATED movie of 2010, it has pretty bad picture, the story was kind of interesting but at the same time it make me think that it was just someone's wet dream brought to the big screen. It has a very bad ending too.This is the most OVERRATED movie of 2010, it has pretty bad picture, the story was kind of interesting but at the same time it make me think that it was just someone's wet dream brought to the big screen. It has a very bad ending too. Couldn't see the artistic part of the movie. But it may be a good option to watch on a weekend if you couldn't find anything else on the T.V.… Expand

0 of 2 users found this helpful02

All this user's reviews

4

ExKingMar 29, 2013

sorry to break it to you fan boys but this movie is overrated the story is confusing Natalie Portman performance was solid but that can be said about anyone that will take her part in the movie the writing was awkward and don't even getsorry to break it to you fan boys but this movie is overrated the story is confusing Natalie Portman performance was solid but that can be said about anyone that will take her part in the movie the writing was awkward and don't even get me started on the homosexual parts of the movie.… Expand

0 of 3 users found this helpful03

All this user's reviews

6

WJSMar 19, 2016

Natalie Portman is very good here, as is Mila Kunis, but unfortunately I just couldn't get into it. Just like ballet in real life, I just have no interest. I did really like the cinematography though.

0 of 1 users found this helpful01

All this user's reviews

Black Swan

User Reviews