Renegades is clearly a step forward compared to Edge of Fate. Where that expansion mainly focused on traversal but otherwise felt empty, Renegades actually adds something meaningful to the sandbox. The Star Wars-inspired flavor works surprisingly well, the gunplay is excellent, and the new systems are fun to play around with. Still, without strong endgame hooks, without a new raid, and with a shrinking community, it becomes difficult to keep the light burning for our Guardians. A real shame, because the foundation is still very solid. The big question is how long Bungie can continue to support it.