Obduction

 PlayStation 4
Metascore
61

Mixed or average reviews - based on 5 Critic Reviews

Critic score distribution:
  1. Positive: 1 out of 5
  2. Mixed: 3 out of 5
  3. Negative: 1 out of 5
  1. Eurogamer
    Aug 31, 2017
    Myst's spiritual successor offers a lot of the same delights as its 1993 forbear, but is hampered by litany of technical issues.

User Reviews

All reviews »
User Score
5.8

Mixed or average reviews- based on 18 Ratings

User score distribution:
  1. Positive: 8 out of 18
  2. Mixed: 4 out of 18
  3. Negative: 6 out of 18
  1. GBG_Jason
    Sep 27, 2017
    9
    Every now and then, there comes a developer that defines a genre. Rare did it for platformers on Nintendo, and Cyan Worlds did it with puzzleEvery now and then, there comes a developer that defines a genre. Rare did it for platformers on Nintendo, and Cyan Worlds did it with puzzle adventures on PC. The latter of the two recently had a fairly successful Kickstarter for a game in the vein of what made them so popular. With the likes of Myst in 1993, Riven in 1997, and Myst V: End of Ages in 2005, it was beyond time for Cyan Worlds to create a new adventure.

    Obduction isn’t Myst VI, but rather a spiritual successor to the series. I was very young when I first encountered Myst, and I was blown away by it. The environments were haunting, and the story was creepy. The FMVs were off-putting, but in a good way. I played it with my older brother and learned the secrets of the world with each visit we made to our grandparents’ house. I eventually made a friend that also enjoyed the game because of his dad, and found out they had released a sequel. While I was still unsure of how we discovered all the solutions to Myst, I mentioned Riven every chance I got in the hopes of receiving it as a gift. Turned out I wasn’t good at it. I didn’t understand the intricacies of the world, or how to solve most of the puzzles by myself.

    Despite my lack of skills, adventure titles, as well as puzzle games in general have served as one of my favorite genres over the years. There’s always been the joy of that “A-HA!” moment when you figure out the solution, as you’re then faced with another problem. But the payoff was typically worth it, especially in the Myst series, as there was a narrative for you to decipher. Discovering the story is not as taunting as that of the Souls games, but it isn’t spoon fed to you either.

    The opening of this title is rather magical. I really didn’t expect the narration that was going along with it – top notch stuff. My wife was in the other room and asked what I was watching, because it didn’t sound like something you’d hear from a game. And she knows I love extra-terrestrial stuff (she does not), so it’s not unlikely I was watching something about alien abductions. But obviously that was not the case. As you move through a forest area, you catch a glimpse of an alien object zipping through the night sky, and are soon approached by it. Just as soon as you saw it, you find yourself in a completely different environment.

    It’s at this point in the adventure that the game really begins. I played the majority of it in the manner you’d play The Witness; with free roam. But knowing where this game comes from, it also offers the option of having you play in a fixed camera mode, where you click about to move, look, and select the parts of the environment that you can interact with. While most people that never played older games will likely scoff at this, it was a neat addition to the game. It certainly helps with focusing on what you should be looking at if you happen to get stuck.

    I was curious as to if I was just smarter than I used to be (I mean… I am), or if this game was easier than previous entries from these fine folks, so I looked to the internet for opinions. It seems the puzzles in this game are indeed simple, as it’s more or less a scavenger hunt for many of the solutions. However, I don’t see that as a bad thing – far from it. If a game has a puzzle you can’t solve, that will likely a) turn you off from playing the game or b) make you look up the solution. The second option is by no means something to be frowned upon, but it takes away a lot of joy that you can derive from the game. Puzzle games don’t need to be simple, but I don’t think they need to be artificially difficult either.

    The Unreal Engine does this game wonders, as the world around you is spectacular to view. The areas in direct contact with you in the beginning are very familiar, with an alien world juxtaposed right next to it. Soon you are walking into that world and being transported elsewhere, and things are both beautiful and confusing. You’ll want to take note of things that you read and see, as they’ll often serve to be solutions for puzzles later on. In some instances you’ll need to change the solution you saw ever so slightly to receive the answer you need. Each tool will have multiple forms of interaction that you must discover yourself, as often times there isn’t a manual to guide you.

    The story is as fascinating as ever, and the music/voice work is top notch. While not everyone will be able to make it past the initial area of Hunrath because the game just isn’t their cup of tea, I’d recommend sticking to it and doing your best. Even if you need to follow a guide here and there, this is what Bioshock is to System Shock.

    It’s wonderful to see that Cyan Worlds can still create a competent adventure game after all these years. If you’ve ever loved adventure titles, you owe it to yourself to play the newest game from the creators Myst.    … Full Review »
  2. Agarwel
    Jul 26, 2021
    4
    I have really really mixed feelings about this game.
    In its core this is exactly the game I would normally love. Great puzzle game with great    I have really really mixed feelings about this game.
    In its core this is exactly the game I would normally love. Great puzzle game with great graphics and interesting enviromnent. This is my cup of tea.
    But this game has also some questionable gamedesign elements are are draging it down. And making it almost unfinishable.

    Let me be more specific without spoilers. This game takes place in several open areas. And for some reason I dont want to spoil, some puzzles are spread over multiple areas. So you have to go there and back again to solve them. And the loading between these areas are long. 1-2 minutes on PS4. (10-20sec on PS5). This problem is not noticable at the beginning where you have only one area available. But it gets worse over time as you unlock more of the game. The first time you have to go there and back again between levels you will be like "oh. What and interesting idea". Later you find a puzzle that will requere you to go 6 times between level and you will be like "oh. Was that really neccessary?". And then you find a puzzle that by you estimation will require at least 20 loading there and back again and you will be like "oh no. Im not doing that" :-(

    Another problem may be pixel hunting? The areas in the game are pretty big. And sometimes all it takes is to miss one small interactable object and you will become completelly stuck. With no idea where you should be looking now. (did you miss something in the current area? Did you forgot something in the previous one? Should you go back to the junkyard and check every single object there because one of them may be interactable? There is no way to know).

    These are just two issues. But unfortunatelly big ones. You will get stuck, you will get tired of lodings and you will stop having fun because of this :-(    … Full Review »
  3. bergcamp101
    Oct 5, 2020
    9
    And they did it again! Not only does this game have Myst vibes, but it's something really new. New and beautiful. And now it's probably theAnd they did it again! Not only does this game have Myst vibes, but it's something really new. New and beautiful. And now it's probably the best puzzle game on PS4.… Full Review »
See all user reviews »