ESPN NFL 2K5

 PlayStation 2
  • Publisher: Sega
  • Release Date: Jul 20, 2004
User Score
8.6

Generally favorable reviews- based on 115 Ratings

User score distribution:
  1. Positive: 94 out of 115
  2. Mixed: 12 out of 115
  3. Negative: 9 out of 115
Buy Now
Buy on

Review this game

  1. Your Score
    0 out of 10
    Rate this:
    • 10
    • 9
    • 8
    • 7
    • 6
    • 5
    • 4
    • 3
    • 2
    • 1
    • 0
    • 0
  1. Submit
  2. Check Spelling
view
per page
  1. akelz7
    Apr 22, 2011
    10
    This game defined my LIFE from 2005-2009. Yes, 4 years and this game was my most played game. The controls are excellent (the first and only football game that makes it humanly possible to kick/punt, play defense, or call a **** play), the graphics while far from state of the art don't hinder the game's fun. The mini-games found in the "crib" are fun as hell, and the teams and players wereThis game defined my LIFE from 2005-2009. Yes, 4 years and this game was my most played game. The controls are excellent (the first and only football game that makes it humanly possible to kick/punt, play defense, or call a **** play), the graphics while far from state of the art don't hinder the game's fun. The mini-games found in the "crib" are fun as hell, and the teams and players were APPROPRIATELY rated (3rd string QBs do NOT get an 80 rating, Madden.) I never downgrade to madden after this masterpiece of sports gaming. The only flaw that I found was having to play within punching distance of my older brother.… Expand
  2. SpankBank
    Mar 27, 2011
    10
    Even after all these years, this stands the time as one of the best football games ever made. The presentation is unparalleled and the game is so packed with features that it still has life nearly 7 years after its initial release. ESPN NFL 2K5 is our generation's Tecmo Bowl.
  3. ShawnG.
    Aug 10, 2004
    10
    This game is outstanding! The graphics and presentation alone make you feel like your watching an ESPN Sunday Night game. Anyone who bashes this game in favor of Madden is biased with a capital B. I'll be the first to admit that Madden was the better game of 2004, but in 2003 the 2k was just as good as Madden. When I saw that there were Madden lovers rating the 2k5 at a 6 and lower I This game is outstanding! The graphics and presentation alone make you feel like your watching an ESPN Sunday Night game. Anyone who bashes this game in favor of Madden is biased with a capital B. I'll be the first to admit that Madden was the better game of 2004, but in 2003 the 2k was just as good as Madden. When I saw that there were Madden lovers rating the 2k5 at a 6 and lower I had to put in my 2 cents. Thats foolish! Im not sure which game they played. Save your hard earned money, listen to someone who has an unbiased opinion and just wants the best football game year in year out regardless of the title. ESPN has slightly harder controls only because there is more options and decisions for you the gameplayer, but after playing a few times it becomes easier. I've also seen complaints about dropped passes in the ESPN 2k5. I dont think that every pass that hits a receivers hands is caught during the NFL season. Overall the game is realistic, the players get tired, tackles are broken and the more you play and learn the controls the more you can affect each and every play in the game. You should definitely give this game a chance. … Expand
  4. VernonB.
    Jul 25, 2004
    9
    ESPN NFL 2K5 totally rocks! The graphics are great, and the espn style presetation is awsome. The gameplay is also good, it does seem a little bit choppy to me. It is very easy to run. Other than that there are some small glitches that I noticed. But no game is perfect.
  5. MikeN.
    Aug 15, 2004
    10
    Best Football game ever made. Hands down. Those that give it a low rank are disengenuouse. Madden is a great game,..no doubt about it. I own madden 01, 02 and 03. I have also played 04. I was and am a madden fan. However ESPN is a better game. Face it, ESPN is the best Football SIMULATOR. And those that rank it below an 8 out of 10 will never get a second look from me when I am looking Best Football game ever made. Hands down. Those that give it a low rank are disengenuouse. Madden is a great game,..no doubt about it. I own madden 01, 02 and 03. I have also played 04. I was and am a madden fan. However ESPN is a better game. Face it, ESPN is the best Football SIMULATOR. And those that rank it below an 8 out of 10 will never get a second look from me when I am looking for a good game review. … Expand
  6. Mike
    Aug 20, 2004
    10
    Dont bother buying Madden for $50, get this one.. $20 and a better game. Graphics and gameplay are outstanding.. the best football game out there!
  7. DevonO.
    Aug 20, 2004
    10
    Great game all around! Superb graphics, realistic gameplay, smart AI, excelent franchise mode. What more do you need?
  8. KhrisB.
    Jul 22, 2004
    10
    The best football game ever...hands down a must buy.
  9. [Anonymous]
    Jul 23, 2004
    10
    This game is simply amazing. I have yet to experience a game so well made. The graphics on PS2 are comparable to graphics for other games on XBOX and there is a lot of detail put into this game. This game has gotten a HUGE facelift since 2K4 such as the Franchise mode and the new VIP feature. The VIP allows you to play against different profiles and NFL coaches and it also allows you to This game is simply amazing. I have yet to experience a game so well made. The graphics on PS2 are comparable to graphics for other games on XBOX and there is a lot of detail put into this game. This game has gotten a HUGE facelift since 2K4 such as the Franchise mode and the new VIP feature. The VIP allows you to play against different profiles and NFL coaches and it also allows you to view an offline person's VIP and view their tendencies! I absolutely love this game and apart from some minor glitches, it is perfect.… Expand
  10. BillK.
    Jul 27, 2004
    10
    I've been playing Madden since the FIRST one came out and I'll probably guy the next one too. I only played Sega's franchise once previously on Dreamcast. Having said that, I was completely blown away at how much it has changed and how good it is. First off, there is an in-game manual among other "books"... football terms, a football primer (MUCH better than the I've been playing Madden since the FIRST one came out and I'll probably guy the next one too. I only played Sega's franchise once previously on Dreamcast. Having said that, I was completely blown away at how much it has changed and how good it is. First off, there is an in-game manual among other "books"... football terms, a football primer (MUCH better than the Madden's explaining just a few plays), a tips section. The game is so deep its ridiculous; there's just so much to do. Obviously there's a deep Franchise mode, and its great that you can prepare/scout all week for each game. I also love the detailed stats (pie charts even!) they give you on your style of play. This ends up being your VIP and when your friends play you can save theirs and practice playing them when they're not even there. The Crib feature is pure genius and gives me far more incentive to keep playing than collecting Madden cards, which I never use anyway. Celebrities calling you at your Crib and challenging you to games (through their VIP) with their own created teams is a fun touch too. Best part about ESPN is it doesn't feel like AI is cheating or letting you cheat. I don't like how Madden has to punish whichever team is losing just to make games close and exciting. That's so cheap. I'd prefer the exciting games just happen. The thrilling comebacks would mean so much more...and in ESPN it feels honest. Now I've knocked Madden in this review and I might end up buying it because I'm a huge football fan, and there are a lot of good features in it. But as of right now it feels like Madden is playing catch-up to ESPN. Also, thank you for making this game $20 and I hope more developers follow suit...another reason ESPN has won me over.… Expand
  11. BikoG.
    Aug 13, 2004
    10
    After having played both NFL 2k5 and Madden 2005, ESPN truly wins the battle. The realism, graphical smoothness, and new preparation mode clearly outmatches any new feature that madden has brought to the table. Also, NFL 2K5's counterpart to ESPN Basketball's isomotion system makes the game even more spontaneous, allowing a player to perform combinations of jukes, as opposed to After having played both NFL 2k5 and Madden 2005, ESPN truly wins the battle. The realism, graphical smoothness, and new preparation mode clearly outmatches any new feature that madden has brought to the table. Also, NFL 2K5's counterpart to ESPN Basketball's isomotion system makes the game even more spontaneous, allowing a player to perform combinations of jukes, as opposed to the running game of madden, which is slower and less real. The new wrap up tackling system is also another plus, which forces both players to "fight" just like in real life. Rushers can now drag tacklers unlike madden which stops after contact has been made( unless one performs a stiffarm, which is inconsistent in itself). And even though Madden made major leaps in presentation, it still cant compare to the professionalism and reality of the ESPN-based commentary. Overall, both are good football games, but ESPN football takes the cake. And Bob S., jump off the bandwagon; you're making me sick.… Expand
  12. TuomasK.
    Aug 15, 2004
    10
    This game owns Madden in any category! Graphics and Gameplay are milestones ahead of ANY EA game! And the price!! 20 BUCKS! If you don't own this, go check your head!
  13. TonyC.
    Aug 4, 2004
    10
    I'm a former Madden lemming that gave ESPN a try last year, it was so good I'm now an NFL 2K... devotee. The fluid animations are so much better than Madden, and the running game is simply awesome. The running is a lot tougher this year compared to last, but all aspects of gameplay are tunable via sliders, so the game can be challenging to the newbie or die-hard pigskin fan. VIP I'm a former Madden lemming that gave ESPN a try last year, it was so good I'm now an NFL 2K... devotee. The fluid animations are so much better than Madden, and the running game is simply awesome. The running is a lot tougher this year compared to last, but all aspects of gameplay are tunable via sliders, so the game can be challenging to the newbie or die-hard pigskin fan. VIP is cool, ever wanted to play the best online player but was too scared to get your butt kicked? or you aren't good enough for him to give you a shot? then just load his vip and play him, you can learn a lot about different strategies. play against yourself to see your weaknesses. It's all about getting better, and who doesn't want to get better?… Expand
  14. JamesJ.
    Aug 6, 2004
    10
    It's the best football i have ever seen in my whole entire life any foot ball fan must get this game if u dont you are unlucky it is simply to good to pass up this game is ten times better than madden.
  15. DieHardMaddenFan
    Jul 24, 2004
    9
    I was about as skeptical as you can get... not Madden & only 19.99? This game HAS to suck right? NO!! I don't know what new additions they made to Madden 2005, but there had better be a TON if they wanna keep up with ESPN NFL 2k5! Believe it coming from a die hard Madden fan... This game is EXCELLENT!! The only flaw with the game I can see is some audio screw ups by the announcers I was about as skeptical as you can get... not Madden & only 19.99? This game HAS to suck right? NO!! I don't know what new additions they made to Madden 2005, but there had better be a TON if they wanna keep up with ESPN NFL 2k5! Believe it coming from a die hard Madden fan... This game is EXCELLENT!! The only flaw with the game I can see is some audio screw ups by the announcers that are only noticible if you're listening for them (wrong name announced made the tackle, etc.)… Expand
  16. Gov.Terminator
    Jul 28, 2004
    9
    This goes out to the folks out there giving this game under a 7. Did you guys try out maximum passing? since it is not preset...you have to select it from the "team select menu". Without this feature, the passing game is mediocre, since most of your passes will be dropped. Turn this feature on, and you'll be able to control whether you want to lead your receiver, in any which way. This goes out to the folks out there giving this game under a 7. Did you guys try out maximum passing? since it is not preset...you have to select it from the "team select menu". Without this feature, the passing game is mediocre, since most of your passes will be dropped. Turn this feature on, and you'll be able to control whether you want to lead your receiver, in any which way. Not only does every pass that you throw have your signature on it (since maximum passing allows you so much control), but it makes you earn every catch. running game is hands down better than last years, more moves...monster hits, hit the hole and the field is all urs. I bought this game a week ago and didn't figure out maximum passin till last nite...changed my whole outlook on it. i have to take a point off for recycled commentary and animations...come on sega!!! i know it's only $20 but keep it fresh.… Expand
  17. AdamC.
    Aug 13, 2004
    9
    This game is so much better than Madden PERIOD!
  18. G.H.
    Aug 21, 2004
    10
    The only reason Madden outsells the 2k series is because of brainwashed hardcore maddenites and not because it's a better game. Visual Concepts has created another masterpiece, "the best football game ever made" in ESPN NFL Football 2k5. NFL 2k5 is the most realistic football game available. You're not going to find "long bomb hailmary money-plays in triple coverage and 72-65 The only reason Madden outsells the 2k series is because of brainwashed hardcore maddenites and not because it's a better game. Visual Concepts has created another masterpiece, "the best football game ever made" in ESPN NFL Football 2k5. NFL 2k5 is the most realistic football game available. You're not going to find "long bomb hailmary money-plays in triple coverage and 72-65 scores on 5 minute quarters" in this game. If that is what you want, then buy Madden 2005. NFL 2k5 is for true football fans that appreciate "real" football. You actually have to make smart decisions on the field to be successful in NFL 2k5. The AI in 2k5 is the most realistic ever made for a football game. Simming a game in "real time" is jaw dropping and believable. Franchise mode is very good, but not as good as Madden's. Other than franchise, 2k5 has Madden beat in everything else. If "real" is important to you, then buy ESPN NFL Football 2k5.… Expand
  19. DavidMasters
    Dec 12, 2008
    9
    This is a great game for the football fan. Its not easy to score like most of the older games i played on sega it can be very challenging and addicting for sure! Decent commentary and play by play though some is repeated but to be expected it is a game lol. I enjoy the game it beats madden
  20. rtkiii
    Nov 13, 2012
    10
    For the time it was the best FB game of all time. Graphically and mechanics have faded away with the times but the presentation is HANDS DOWN the best I have every experienced in a video game and I still wish 2K Sports would bring out another FB game to put Madden in it's place. Come on NFL 2K14!
  21. 2ksnipefest
    May 11, 2013
    10
    The year is 2013 and this game is still amazingly fun. I've played 2k5 for over a thousand hours. I will play against anyone in the known universe. As it stands only seven challengers have ever beat me. The rest of my foes were utterly annihilated.
  22. AdamQ.
    Aug 4, 2004
    6
    I bought this game for one reason: Its 20 bucks. That is the only reason I dont' feel too upset I bought it. I probably expect too much because madden is done so well, but the both the gameplay and presentation aren't as good.. I went back to playing madden '04 shortly after buying this game, and i'm just waiting for madden 05 to come out. There are some kinda cool I bought this game for one reason: Its 20 bucks. That is the only reason I dont' feel too upset I bought it. I probably expect too much because madden is done so well, but the both the gameplay and presentation aren't as good.. I went back to playing madden '04 shortly after buying this game, and i'm just waiting for madden 05 to come out. There are some kinda cool ideas, where espn makes its mark. First person football is novel, but its still poor when it comes to playability. The stuff with chris berman is a good idea, but it gets boring after two games cuz there are maybe a total of 20 comments. In the franchise mode, game prep is just tedious, but i guess you can turn it off. Buy this game if you just feel like getting a football game, and aren't used to the madden series, because this doesn't hold a candle to it.… Expand
  23. Kevin.
    Aug 14, 2004
    1
    Anyone that rates this game higher than Madden should be publicly stoned to death so that everyone knows that there is a price to be paid for being a dumbass. Madden rules. ESPN's playability is comparable Madden 98. On defense, the control is garbage, and on offense it's way too easy. I guess if you suck, this game might be the one for you.
  24. BenP.
    Nov 4, 2004
    7
    This game just doesn't flow well enough for me, that and I spent a whole Franchise season passing the ball the Owens for about 50 td passes and racked up over 100 sacks with Kearse(sp?). Even after all that, the only part that I liked better than Madden was the defensive line's controls, but that was only until I understood how to control it on Madden. I haven't been able This game just doesn't flow well enough for me, that and I spent a whole Franchise season passing the ball the Owens for about 50 td passes and racked up over 100 sacks with Kearse(sp?). Even after all that, the only part that I liked better than Madden was the defensive line's controls, but that was only until I understood how to control it on Madden. I haven't been able to go back to 2k5 after the first day of Madden. Madden just controls SO much better.… Expand
  25. CaseyP.
    Jul 22, 2004
    4
    This game does not compare to Madden in any which way. Randall Cunningham is the greatest quarterback ever.
  26. BobS.
    Aug 5, 2004
    0
    This game can't even carry Madden's jock strap. This game is worse than the 989 games. I can't believe I wasted 20 dollars on this horrible excuse for a game.
  27. RobW.
    Aug 9, 2004
    1
    This game would get a zero, but I was able to return it for a $20 credit that I will put towards Madden. I agree with some other guy that said this looked, and played about as well as Madden 98.
  28. LuisM.
    Aug 9, 2004
    6
    It's essentially a poor man's Madden (and I'm not only talking about talking about the price tag). I honestly cannot come up with an element of the game that surpasses last year's Madden. The gameplay is pretty good, but can still be a bit sluggish from time to time. The franchise mode has most of the same elements that Madden offers during the regular season, but the It's essentially a poor man's Madden (and I'm not only talking about talking about the price tag). I honestly cannot come up with an element of the game that surpasses last year's Madden. The gameplay is pretty good, but can still be a bit sluggish from time to time. The franchise mode has most of the same elements that Madden offers during the regular season, but the off-season doesn't offer much at all. The draft is a crap shoot because the scouting is weak. The on-line play also needs improvement. The server often cannot establish or maintain the connection between players. The kicking game is, for lack of a better term, retarded. Despite it's flaws the game is still enjoyable. The $20 price tag is also very enticing. I wasn't going to pick up a football game this year, but at that price a person can afford to let curiosity get the better of them. My only advice, don't be fooled by the rave reviews. If you've played Madden, you'll easily figure out which of the two is better. If you're a novice football video game fan looking to kill some time then I recommend this game to you. … Expand
  29. MikeS.
    Sep 25, 2004
    0
    Doesn't even compare to Madden. Don't bother!
  30. JohnnyC.
    Nov 16, 2004
    0
    I like the player celebrations but that's it.
  31. JGamer
    Jul 29, 2004
    9
    I like this game. I wish it was a little easier getting around in the franchise mode, but I wished the same thing for Madden last year. For $20 I recommend it to everyone. I think it is definitely on par with Madden.
  32. JayPM.
    Aug 10, 2004
    9
    The only thing i wish you could change the players uniforms, like spat tape and visiors.
  33. JohnT.
    Aug 2, 2004
    9
    Gameplay is fantastic!! And thats all I care about . . . Madden has options galore, franchise etc . . . but when it comes down to pure gameplay and graphics ESPN rules.
  34. PierreG.
    Aug 4, 2004
    7
    This game is a lot better than espn2k4. But there is still a long way before you can compare it to madden. The players body is unrealistic and the gameplay is average at best. Sega made a big step in the right directions with 2k5 but in the end madden is still the best. Tapping the x button to run faster??? Come on!!!
  35. MitchS.
    Jan 1, 2005
    7
    I really like this game but I do have a few complaints. This game is easier to pass on but running is difficult. Also it will seem like you just sacked the QB for a big loss but then it turns out it was only a 3 or 4 yard loss. All in all I really like this game.
  36. RashadC.
    Apr 28, 2005
    10
    Good Game i love to play this game all night long its an addictive game.
  37. GaryB.
    Oct 5, 2004
    9
    Don't listen to people who say "This doesn't even comparte to Madden!!" or "This is way better than Madden" because we all know they aren't too much different. I've always preferred Sega's sports games because they allow me to do really stupid things - like in their football games I like to punt it through the uprights, and they even have specific commentary for Don't listen to people who say "This doesn't even comparte to Madden!!" or "This is way better than Madden" because we all know they aren't too much different. I've always preferred Sega's sports games because they allow me to do really stupid things - like in their football games I like to punt it through the uprights, and they even have specific commentary for it!! That and the fact that EA uses very bad, out-of-place music in all their games gives Sega the edge. So I think people should save their money this year and buy the Sega games if they usually buy EA, because even if you don't like them as much it won't me a huge difference, or you just might like them more.… Expand
  38. MarcusB.
    Jul 26, 2004
    9
    To all of the whiners who would rather "throw away their money", please shut up. This game, at only $20 is one of the best bargains of all time. I'm sick of crybaby fanboys who always complain about 1)price 2)length of the game 3)how the previous version was better. Maybe Madden will be better, but it is a damn fine game.
  39. LeRoi
    Jul 31, 2004
    6
    People talkin about the graphics? They look like Madden 98 or something. Gameplay looks fine, but the menu, and the crib are so Super NES. Big, and blocky. The defensive control is terrible. Madden used to have this problem, but over time has fixed it. ESPN needs to focus on their whole game, not just the price. I'll be renting the next one before I buy it. It could be worth buying People talkin about the graphics? They look like Madden 98 or something. Gameplay looks fine, but the menu, and the crib are so Super NES. Big, and blocky. The defensive control is terrible. Madden used to have this problem, but over time has fixed it. ESPN needs to focus on their whole game, not just the price. I'll be renting the next one before I buy it. It could be worth buying after a few more years of trial and error. I got tricked into buying it ($20.00) My mistake. I'm waitin on Madden.… Expand
  40. SmithM.
    Aug 29, 2004
    10
    This game is great.
  41. M.D.
    Aug 3, 2004
    5
    I was really looking forward to this game after reading the reviews. But after renting it, I was very disappointed. The gameplay seems choppy, the players look unrealistic, and the franchise mode is thinner than Lara Flyn-Boyle. The crib feature is interesting and much better than the all-but-useless Madden Cards available in EA's offering. But the lack of defensive player control, I was really looking forward to this game after reading the reviews. But after renting it, I was very disappointed. The gameplay seems choppy, the players look unrealistic, and the franchise mode is thinner than Lara Flyn-Boyle. The crib feature is interesting and much better than the all-but-useless Madden Cards available in EA's offering. But the lack of defensive player control, the unrealistic player models (sorry, but Dante Hall is NOT that built) and aforementioned weak franchise mode means that I will go back to Madden this year.… Expand
  42. SteveM.
    Sep 2, 2004
    10
    Best football game evaaaar!!!
  43. Ricky
    Sep 4, 2004
    10
    This is way better then madden.
  44. AnonymousMC
    Mar 7, 2005
    8
    more of the same gam we've seen for years except for some minor improvements.

    lots of little extras and such, training mode is kinda cool.
    if gameplay is what you want though then espn 2k5 is where its at... unfortunately it probably won't be around for another 5 years. heres to hopeing madden gets better with out any competition............
  45. BretF.
    Jul 21, 2004
    9
    Gameplay is great and easy to learn, the graphics are outstanding, and the presentation is by far the best of any sports video game.
  46. SmithM.
    Jul 24, 2004
    10
    This game is great.
  47. SteveC.
    Jul 25, 2004
    5
    I was in the mall the other day and couldn't decide what to do with my money. Two choices buy ESPN 2K5, or throw my money away and step in front of a bus. I should have gone with my second option. I'd probably get out of the hospital in time to buy a great game I like to call Madden. This game is terrible.
  48. Dave
    Jul 26, 2004
    9
    I read an article the other day about games getting better without really changing much. Anyway the subject of conversation was EA's NCAA 2005 and it seems to be the curse for many of the EA franchises and even caused me to leave the NHL series behind for ESPN's awesome NHL series. This year the $20 price tag made me take a gamble on ESPN that was totally worth it. I have been a I read an article the other day about games getting better without really changing much. Anyway the subject of conversation was EA's NCAA 2005 and it seems to be the curse for many of the EA franchises and even caused me to leave the NHL series behind for ESPN's awesome NHL series. This year the $20 price tag made me take a gamble on ESPN that was totally worth it. I have been a long time Madden fan, but this year ESPN has made a great football game. Still have to wait and see if Madden has improved or just hidden the same game under new features and cool animations. This is a great game with great graphics and responsive controls and it plays like real football. No up by two tuchdowns and the computer scores 3 in a matter of :40 seconds.… Expand
  49. Reggie
    Aug 18, 2004
    9
    This game is the best football, I think its even better then NFL Madden 2005 !!! They have all the same stuff. I have Madden and I plan on selling it.
  50. Madden'saGiant
    Aug 9, 2004
    10
    The best thing about this game is that u dont have to listen to john maddens painfully stupid commentary. while the commentary can be a bit repetetive it is not nearly as irritating as madden overstating the obvious. the graphics and the physics are incredible and there are plenty of options to keep the game interesting. plus the sportscenter feature is sweet. ill never waste money onThe best thing about this game is that u dont have to listen to john maddens painfully stupid commentary. while the commentary can be a bit repetetive it is not nearly as irritating as madden overstating the obvious. the graphics and the physics are incredible and there are plenty of options to keep the game interesting. plus the sportscenter feature is sweet. ill never waste money on madden again, even if IT goes down to 20 bux.… Expand
  51. KevinA.
    Sep 24, 2004
    10
    While Madden is a great game, ESPN has it beat hands down. Better graphics, more realistic presentation (it looks like an actual ESPN broadcast!), better online features, and the extra $30 in my pocket have me singing praises for Sega's masterpeice. With the $19.99 price tag, this is the year to try out the franchise that has finally sucessfully challenged, if not defeated, the While Madden is a great game, ESPN has it beat hands down. Better graphics, more realistic presentation (it looks like an actual ESPN broadcast!), better online features, and the extra $30 in my pocket have me singing praises for Sega's masterpeice. With the $19.99 price tag, this is the year to try out the franchise that has finally sucessfully challenged, if not defeated, the mighty Madden. And John Madden doesn't do the commentary here. Rating++ … Expand
  52. Ace4567backer
    Jan 9, 2005
    9
    Kicks maddens @$$!!!
  53. KeithL.
    Apr 12, 2005
    10
    Best Football Game Ever, Period! Get it now!
  54. TreyP.
    Dec 3, 2004
    10
    If Madden 2005 is so good then how come its price dropped to $30? Especially if it "has no competition." Madden 2005 is a great game if your playing football for the first time in your life. You can throw 60 yard passes at anytime, and the cornerbacks jump like 10 feet in the air. E.S.P.N is the best football game out there looks better, feels better, is better. The only reason people If Madden 2005 is so good then how come its price dropped to $30? Especially if it "has no competition." Madden 2005 is a great game if your playing football for the first time in your life. You can throw 60 yard passes at anytime, and the cornerbacks jump like 10 feet in the air. E.S.P.N is the best football game out there looks better, feels better, is better. The only reason people like Madden more is because it's been around longer. Oh yeah and whoever the guy is who got 100 sacks in a season either plays to much football or you had the game on rookie.… Expand
  55. Bob
    Jul 25, 2004
    6
    Reading these comments, I feel like I've woken up in a Bizarro world. This game could be considered worth buying if it came out in 1999. Has anyone out there played a game since Madden 98? The graphics suck. The Playability is like Preschool Football. Where's the challenge? Pure crap. I am however comparing this to Madden which actually takes some measure of football knowlege to Reading these comments, I feel like I've woken up in a Bizarro world. This game could be considered worth buying if it came out in 1999. Has anyone out there played a game since Madden 98? The graphics suck. The Playability is like Preschool Football. Where's the challenge? Pure crap. I am however comparing this to Madden which actually takes some measure of football knowlege to play, unlike this game, which could be "mastered" by a blind, one-armed monkey. Thanks. P.S. This game sucks compared to any Madden game put out since 99.… Expand
  56. JuliusM.
    Jul 31, 2004
    7
    I got this game cause it was cheap, and I got what I paid for. There's nothing in this game that is as good as Tecmo football, and it doesn't even touch Madden. The Front End is hard to navigate, and has a lot of extra steps. The running game is too easy and unrealistic (on every setting) Passing is lame on it's own, and worse when comparing to Madden. Too much stuff worse I got this game cause it was cheap, and I got what I paid for. There's nothing in this game that is as good as Tecmo football, and it doesn't even touch Madden. The Front End is hard to navigate, and has a lot of extra steps. The running game is too easy and unrealistic (on every setting) Passing is lame on it's own, and worse when comparing to Madden. Too much stuff worse than Madden to type. Just because it's less than Madden, doesn't mean it's worth buying. Save your money and put it towards Madden. At best, this game is a "renter."… Expand
  57. Ron
    Aug 11, 2004
    9
    A very polished game. Exciting to play and easy to learn. Seems to play at a quick pace which is nice when short on time. I would have rather seen the video highlights of my game rather than the still shots that are covered during halftime and post game. A superb deal for $20. Having bought NCAA 2005 and now NFL 2K5 leaves me with the impression that this year's spare time will A very polished game. Exciting to play and easy to learn. Seems to play at a quick pace which is nice when short on time. I would have rather seen the video highlights of my game rather than the still shots that are covered during halftime and post game. A superb deal for $20. Having bought NCAA 2005 and now NFL 2K5 leaves me with the impression that this year's spare time will almost all be spent playing 2K5.… Expand
  58. kk333
    May 26, 2017
    9
    Amazing game! Best nfl game for ps2 out there. Controls are excellent, teams are well-rated and it is actually fun to play a football game on a console.
  59. ramah71
    Mar 17, 2017
    10
    ESPN NFL 2K5 is still one of the most beloved sports titles ever, and for good reason. The gameplay is arguably better than Madden iterations released over a decade later and on platforms two generations ahead. The run game in particular stands out; blocks develop naturally, player tackles feel like they have weight behind them, and even screen passes (long a sore spot for Madden) unfoldESPN NFL 2K5 is still one of the most beloved sports titles ever, and for good reason. The gameplay is arguably better than Madden iterations released over a decade later and on platforms two generations ahead. The run game in particular stands out; blocks develop naturally, player tackles feel like they have weight behind them, and even screen passes (long a sore spot for Madden) unfold in a satisfying manner. 2K5 also gets a lot of aspects of the pass game right. The dropback feels fluid and pass accuracy is actually improved when the quarterback delivers a strike after completing his drop. The ability to put touch on passes is also welcome, and it is extremely gratifying to drop the ball into the hands of a receiver streaking 30 yards downfield. This is not to mention the laundry list of game modes that are included within the title, including a franchise mode experience that is deep and benefits immensely from the ESPN association. Sports games aren't supposed to have this kind of longevity due to their iterative release cycles, which makes this as deserving of a 10 as any football game ever released.… Expand
  60. MasonDavidson
    Oct 21, 2017
    10
    Nearly 14 years post-release and 2K5 is still THE premiere football game to play. 2K5 still manages to leave me floored with its surprisingly deep and realistic gameplay and thorough, meticulous simulation aspects. I don't typically enjoy sports games in any capacity but a friend of mine who knew my love of simulation and management games recommended this to me last year, so I have noNearly 14 years post-release and 2K5 is still THE premiere football game to play. 2K5 still manages to leave me floored with its surprisingly deep and realistic gameplay and thorough, meticulous simulation aspects. I don't typically enjoy sports games in any capacity but a friend of mine who knew my love of simulation and management games recommended this to me last year, so I have no nostalgia for this title or attachment to the sport, as a grown man who would've passed this game up in its day I can safely say that 2K5 surpasses even the most current game in the Madden series in content and quality. Though the simulation and management aspects of this game are great, the gameplay itself got plenty of polish too. The controls are tight, responsive, gameplay is easy to get the hang of while still being challenging (and rewarding) to master. Surprisingly, while not feeling at all current, the graphics hold up in a way that stops them from being distracting, it must've looked pretty stellar in 2004, but these days it still gets the job done visually.

    It's incredibly sad that EA gained exclusive rights to make games based on the NFL because although the Madden games typically feature tight controls, good gameplay and solid graphics, they lack the depth and features that the 2K series delivered. Maybe Madden is a good football game, but 2K5 was a great football SIM, giving an expansive and rewarding gaming experience on and off the digital field.    … Expand
  61. anthonybobby
    Jul 2, 2023
    10
    ''Anyone that rates this game higher than Madden should be publicly stoned to death so that everyone knows that there is a price to be paid for being a dumbass. Madden rules. ESPN's playability is comparable Madden 98. On defense, the control is garbage, and on offense it's way too easy. I guess if you suck, this game might be the one for you.'' -Kevin

    ''Anyone that rates this game    ''Anyone that rates this game higher than Madden should be publicly stoned to death so that everyone knows that there is a price to be paid for being a dumbass. Madden rules. ESPN's playability is comparable Madden 98. On defense, the control is garbage, and on offense it's way too easy. I guess if you suck, this game might be the one for you.'' -Kevin

    ''Anyone that rates this game higher than Madden should be publicly stoned to death so that everyone knows that there is a price to be paid for being a dumbass.''

    Ok, Kevin. How about you stone yourself to death for being a disgrace to human life and us. And you should know that there is a price for you to pay for being a scumbag. Also, you're a disgusting, retarded, awful EA fanboy. You must still live with your mom, huh? Loser. I bet people hate you for that

    Go back playing with your toys that EA Sports made called Madden NFL 13, EA fanboy loving 12 year old kid. See you later, failed being.    … Expand
  62. JayhawkerZoomer
    Mar 10, 2020
    10
    The most accurate representation of football in a video game ever made, and it's over 15 years old.
  63. SanderI
    Mar 24, 2020
    10
    I loved this franchise, too bad it was fine now although I'm looking forward to whatever that new deal with the nfl will mean

    I might actually buy another football game and have fun at the same time
  64. CarsonTK
    Apr 14, 2020
    10
    This game is my life. It’s the greatest game I’ve ever played. They had The Crib, Create-a-Team, Historical teams, EVERYTHING! It’s awesome! The game also feels like I’m watching a real ESPN football game. Love 2K. We need 2K football games again.
  65. fjtrull
    Aug 30, 2020
    10
    here is 2020 trying to piece together in my mind how madden was ever the franchise that survived this battle. This game is still ,16 years later, the best football sim I have ever played in my life. There are 3 games I grew up with that regardless of their graphics I will still play today with a wide grin. Metal Gear Solid , Second Sight and ESPN NFL 2K5. Back then i was a 15 year old kidhere is 2020 trying to piece together in my mind how madden was ever the franchise that survived this battle. This game is still ,16 years later, the best football sim I have ever played in my life. There are 3 games I grew up with that regardless of their graphics I will still play today with a wide grin. Metal Gear Solid , Second Sight and ESPN NFL 2K5. Back then i was a 15 year old kid who thought games would only get better and more in depth and immersing... now I'm 31 realizing how naive I was.… Expand
  66. stepbackthree
    Aug 24, 2021
    10
    The greatest football video game ever made. There are no negatives -- the complete football video game.
  67. RegularNintendo
    Nov 14, 2020
    9
    Great presentation, great gameplay, and great fun! This game I would say is one of the best video game NFL licensed foodball games ever made! This is a must play.
  68. 2KsniperStud
    Mar 9, 2021
    10
    Absolutely great football simulation game. This game is well balanced fun to play on the defense offense and special teams. A very well polished game. Tackling is realistic and so is the way every NFL player moves. I have been playing this game since 2004. I love popping it into my PS2. Over 1300 hours of gameplay and still having fun. Best pick up a copy worth every penny. The franchiseAbsolutely great football simulation game. This game is well balanced fun to play on the defense offense and special teams. A very well polished game. Tackling is realistic and so is the way every NFL player moves. I have been playing this game since 2004. I love popping it into my PS2. Over 1300 hours of gameplay and still having fun. Best pick up a copy worth every penny. The franchise mode is the best one ever in any football game. I love how you can edit rookies and make real players in the draft like editing a player and naming them Rob Gronkowski and draft him. I even edited a rookie and made myself then drafted myself. The commentators are so entertaining and very funny. The Crib mode is cool you customize and unlock items to decorate your suite. They give you a large trophy room. Watch as your trophies pile up and everyone has a date and time when achieved. This is the best Football game and I say it will all sincerity. I'm in 2021 and still play religiously. This game is hard to put down. The franchise is so immersive. Trading for star players is exciting and fun. Enjoy this gem and Keep rocking the Playstation 2 Nostalgia.… Expand
  69. NOTFOUNDkkkk
    Mar 14, 2021
    10
    this is the greatest sports game of all time and madden is the worst game ever created why did they kick out their founder they are bad and very greedy and those who say its a bad game should paralize themselves and have the police cut their head of f you dumb people who say espn nfl 2k5 is bad i will hunt you down and chop your head of f you haters of espn nfl 2k5 here are one of thethis is the greatest sports game of all time and madden is the worst game ever created why did they kick out their founder they are bad and very greedy and those who say its a bad game should paralize themselves and have the police cut their head of f you dumb people who say espn nfl 2k5 is bad i will hunt you down and chop your head of f you haters of espn nfl 2k5 here are one of the people i saw with negative reviews @jhonnyc @mikeS @ robW @ bobS @ caseyP And last and the least @kevin all of those name i listed are ****… Expand
  70. Zski
    Aug 23, 2023
    9
    Years later, this football game with outdated rosters still stands against the test of time. The gameplay is just so tight and refined that while it’s a little primitive in terms of some of the mechanics compared to what we have today, it’s just so well woven together into a complete package that you can still pick it up and enjoy it all the same today in 2023. The graphics are good withYears later, this football game with outdated rosters still stands against the test of time. The gameplay is just so tight and refined that while it’s a little primitive in terms of some of the mechanics compared to what we have today, it’s just so well woven together into a complete package that you can still pick it up and enjoy it all the same today in 2023. The graphics are good with consideration to them being on PS2. The game has always shined with the sound, commentary, and presentation. It’s weird that Madden just cannot get it together after this game made a massive effort 20 years ago. It’s still incredibly exciting to pick up and play whether it’s against the computer or against a friend. With consideration to the generation that this came out in, it’s easily among the most legendary sports titles.… Expand
  71. TotallyCubie
    Apr 20, 2023
    10
    The best NFL football video game ever released. While it lacks the features of Madden 2005, such as the team creator, and the franchise mode isn't as in-depth as Madden 2005's, the core gameplay is more realistic and is, in my opinion, superior to Madden's. The ESPN presentation is fantastic, the VIP and Crib system provide incentives to work towards, and the extra modes, such as situationThe best NFL football video game ever released. While it lacks the features of Madden 2005, such as the team creator, and the franchise mode isn't as in-depth as Madden 2005's, the core gameplay is more realistic and is, in my opinion, superior to Madden's. The ESPN presentation is fantastic, the VIP and Crib system provide incentives to work towards, and the extra modes, such as situation mode and the ESPN moments, are very fun and add even more reason to keep coming back.… Expand
  72. apocalyptic
    Dec 9, 2021
    10
    Absolutely fantastic game. Better than any modern football game hands down. From gameplay to depth to controls this game is fabulous.
  73. BlakkSteel
    Jul 28, 2023
    10
    A masterpiece!! As close as you'll ever get to perfection, in a video game about American football. The game modes, the movements, the presentation,are all still unmatched, even in 2023!!
  74. sandspeedruns
    Feb 25, 2023
    10
    An undisputed classic. While I never was able to get the game on release (in fact, I only picked it up last year), the presentation and gameplay blew me away. Even though it is a 20-year-old game now, it has stood the test of time. The gameplay still feels really fluid and realistic, much closer to how NFL games feel than any modern attempt. The VIP system is ingenious (who wouldn't wantAn undisputed classic. While I never was able to get the game on release (in fact, I only picked it up last year), the presentation and gameplay blew me away. Even though it is a 20-year-old game now, it has stood the test of time. The gameplay still feels really fluid and realistic, much closer to how NFL games feel than any modern attempt. The VIP system is ingenious (who wouldn't want to play themselves every once in a while?), and the Crib also gives you a great space to unwind. There are some limitations - modes are limited, and there are only so many things to do. And of course, it might take some time to get used to the worse graphics. But after playing modern Maddens for almost a decade, this felt like a breath of fresh air.… Expand

Awards & Rankings

7
#7 Best PS2 Game of 2004
10
#10 Most Discussed PS2 Game of 2004

Critic Reviews

All reviews »
Metascore
90

Universal acclaim - based on 37 Critic Reviews

Critic score distribution:
  1. Positive: 37 out of 37
  2. Mixed: 0 out of 37
  3. Negative: 0 out of 37
  1. GameZone
    93
    Visual Concepts has done an awesome job of squeezing every ounce of power that the PlayStation 2 has to offer while developing this game. The player’s faces look like their real life counter parts, and everything is smoothly animated.
    Read full review
  2. Game Over Online
    93
    Deep, customizable gameplay along with a number of innovative features go a long way to giving "Madden" a run for its money.
    Read full review
  3. GameSpot
    91
    For all of its excellent modes and gameplay, however, ESPN NFL 2K5's greatest asset comes in the form of its graphics. Hands down, flat out, undeniably, inarguably, this is the best-looking football game ever made.
    Read full review
See all critic reviews »