User Score
2.6

Generally unfavorable reviews- based on 2560 Ratings

User score distribution:

Review this game

  1. Your Score
    0 out of 10
    Rate this:
    • 10
    • 9
    • 8
    • 7
    • 6
    • 5
    • 4
    • 3
    • 2
    • 1
    • 0
    • 0
  1. Submit
  2. Check Spelling
  1. Nov 26, 2020
    10
    It's pretty good. Better than past iterations. Good story, less RNG, interesting content, covenants are cool, Torghast is great.
  2. Nov 28, 2020
    10
    Just keeping the game fresh enough to entertain us all for another 2 years.
  3. Nov 26, 2020
    10
    expecting another bfa. but turns out to be a TBC quality. well done blizzard !
  4. Nov 25, 2020
    10
    This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Leveling actually has stories, which is strange for wow. But leveling doesn't make an expansion good, it's just a piece of the puzzle. While I think the story in Ardenweald might be the best in the history of the game in terms of a leveling zone story, (SPOILER: Finding out Ysera was the seed and the payoff cinematic at the end might literally be my favorite WoW moment ever, seriously, I have goosebumps right now thinking about it.) I don't think that alone is what makes this good.

    Firstly lets talk alts. Google the catchup mechanics and also threads of fate. It's one of the best systems they've ever put in the game and it's a game changer.

    I also want to talk about end-game. Dungeons are fun and not too tedious like most in BfA were, the M+ portion is going to be a blast. There seems to be interesting mechanics in each that will hopefully prevent things from getting stale.

    Importantly we need to discuss gear. There is no more incentive to just grind the same repetitive content over and over again once you get your item as was the case with titanforging. If you get lucky on your first dungeon run with all of your BiS pieces? You don't ever have to go there again. You're done. From then on you only have to worry about doing M+. This also applies to the world quests and the other methods of acquiring gear. For the first time in the history of the game they are removing RNG time-gates. You can target and craft your legendary items, no RNG. No titanforging. Less RNG and more rewards from the weekly chest. It's all amazing, it's what these things should have been from the start.

    This expansion is WoW's renaissance. It's got it's flaws, but on the scale of previous WoW expansions, something drastic would have to happen to make this not a 10.
    Expand
  5. Dec 1, 2020
    10
    Blizzard, nice job, I like this expansion, beautiful locations, interesting dungeons, a lot of activities.
  6. Nov 29, 2020
    10
    Best expansion ever. Best quests, leveling and PVP. Just buy it. They bring back everything that was good before.
  7. Dec 20, 2020
    10
    ne of the best expansions I've played in a LOOOONG time. Dunno why tf people are saying this is grindy, since it is the first time in the last 4 years when I can finish my weekly stuff on reset day or Thursday, and for the rest of the week I can actually do what I love. In my case being PvP.
    I am fully epic equipped from PvP, from doing BGs and upgrading the blue gear with Honor till
    ne of the best expansions I've played in a LOOOONG time. Dunno why tf people are saying this is grindy, since it is the first time in the last 4 years when I can finish my weekly stuff on reset day or Thursday, and for the rest of the week I can actually do what I love. In my case being PvP.
    I am fully epic equipped from PvP, from doing BGs and upgrading the blue gear with Honor till epic. Then I've started doing Arenas 2s, and altough PvE playes still have a good advantage cause they get higher ilvl gear from Mythics, I can still enjoy doing 2s.

    I have done ONLY 4 normal dungeons since I hit 60, and that is only cause they had zone ending dungeon quests, else I would have not set foot in any dungeon at all.

    The PvP system implemented is one of the best that ever existed in WoW, and you can earn gear FROM actually playing PVP, and upgrade it on an ilvl direct proportional with your PvP rating.
    Expand
  8. Mar 3, 2021
    10
    They really did a good job this expansion. They eliminated some of the systems from the past 2 expansions that were destroying the game, such as titanforging. The amount of unfun weekly chores that only served as mans to artificially bump up engagement has been drastically reduced. The classes play much better than Legion and BfA, and the unpruning brought back some fan favorite abilitiesThey really did a good job this expansion. They eliminated some of the systems from the past 2 expansions that were destroying the game, such as titanforging. The amount of unfun weekly chores that only served as mans to artificially bump up engagement has been drastically reduced. The classes play much better than Legion and BfA, and the unpruning brought back some fan favorite abilities that were dearly missed. There are, of course, the typical early expansion balance problems, but they are applying balancing fixes once every 2 weeks or so, which is a good thing. Overall, I haven't had as much fun in WoW for years. I only hope SL gets better and better as more content patches are released, and I hope they won't make the mistake of going back on the good decisions they made. Expand
  9. Nov 26, 2020
    10
    -excellent, less confusing story telling
    -no more unbalanced corruption systems but back to the roots simple item system
    -excellent visuals
    -excellent sound/voiceovers
    -story-driven sidequests
    -new catchup mechanic for twinks is awesome and less boring
  10. Nov 25, 2020
    10
    Really solid title and so many things that went wrong in BFA have been fixed. Most importantly classes feel so much better now! Shadowpriest is amazing!
  11. Nov 29, 2020
    10
    Bin einfach super zufrieden
  12. Dec 1, 2020
    10
    Very refreshing as a new expansion. Aside from the extremely beautiful new zones, interesting story, and great levelling experience, systematic changes make the endgame feel great. No infinite grinds, which feels great after the artifact weapons and azerite or Legion and BFA. The gearing changes (removal of titanforging/warforging) also feel great, every piece of gear feels like itVery refreshing as a new expansion. Aside from the extremely beautiful new zones, interesting story, and great levelling experience, systematic changes make the endgame feel great. No infinite grinds, which feels great after the artifact weapons and azerite or Legion and BFA. The gearing changes (removal of titanforging/warforging) also feel great, every piece of gear feels like it matters. Torghast is a lot fun and quite challenging on the higher layers. The legendary acquisition system is a perfect mix of accessibility and challenge, revitalizing professions and really making it feel like you are forging your own legendary. The dungeons are generally pretty good. Overall, the expansion is shaping up to be one of the best ones if its able to maintain this quality in patch content! Expand
  13. Nov 27, 2020
    10
    After BfA a breath of fresh air. As good as no mandatory content. Do what you like to do, rather than developers telling you what to do. Great dungeons, awesome story line to level through and PvP is as good as ever. A++
  14. Nov 27, 2020
    10
    Português Br.

    História - 10
    Som - 10
    Gameplay - 10
    Gráficos - 10
    Diversão - 10

    Esse jogo é incrível uma verdadeira obra de arte muito imersivo você pode fazer o que quiser no game serio mesmo o problema é parar de jogar! Di
  15. Nov 29, 2020
    10
    The leveling was smooth, with a ton of story and dialogue to take in. Queues were problematic but it shows the popularity of the game right now and I could log in early so they did not affect me too much. Once in the end game, alts can level through an alternate experience which instantly unlocks end-game abilities and skips the main storyline, avoiding forced repetition.

    The end-game
    The leveling was smooth, with a ton of story and dialogue to take in. Queues were problematic but it shows the popularity of the game right now and I could log in early so they did not affect me too much. Once in the end game, alts can level through an alternate experience which instantly unlocks end-game abilities and skips the main storyline, avoiding forced repetition.

    The end-game is still mostly locked (raids, m+, rated PvP, most of Torghast including Legendaries) but what I've seen so far feels good, the early levels of Torghast were fun to go through, the Maw end-game zone feels dangerous, especially when solo, dungeons had lots of interesting mechanics and PvP vendors are back, and actually sell the best PvP gear due to the new PvP trinket set bonus. Professions are very simple and take little time to set up and start crafting good items, although there is a lot of investment in order to be able to craft the best Legendaries, as it should be.

    Not to speak of all the treasure / secret / rare / sidequest hunting. World quests are cool to do the first time but quickly get boring, but luckily like the rest of the expansion so far, BARELY ANYTHING FEELS MANDATORY and RNG is at the lowest level in years. There is no war/titan forging anymore, PvP vendors returned and epic BoEs / top-end crafted gear is plentiful and tradeable.

    Hopefully the next weeks are even more fun than the first one, with all the extra content that is incoming, looking forward to it!
    Expand
  16. Nov 28, 2020
    10
    Excelente historia os pactos foram um grata adição, quests empolgantes a tempos não me divertia tanto parabéns Blizzard
  17. Dec 7, 2020
    10
    Очень понравился старт дополнения , насыщенный , много активностей , не утомительных , как это было в BFA , так что пока 10 баллов
  18. Nov 28, 2020
    10
    A true RPG MMO with an amazing lore and an amazing leveling phase, the end-game is complete and we have more choices to do! Perfect job Blizzard, we need more deep mechanics like this and not more races and classes.
  19. Nov 27, 2020
    10
    Sicuramente meglio di bfa. Le ambientazioni sono bellissime e stavolta avremo qualcosa in più da fare.
  20. Nov 26, 2020
    10
    Players have fought against the Burning Legion for 14 yrs and now need new villain. BFA was not much good for the start, but Shadowlands is good for the climax.
  21. Nov 24, 2020
    10
    Fantastic leveling. In my opinion, This Shadowlands is more impressive than Legion. Beautiful and Awesome. I want to be job seeker. BEAT BFA !!!!
  22. Dec 4, 2020
    10
    I love all the idiots who give this game a 0 expansion after expansion for NO reason whatsoever. Their hatred for the most popular and successful MMORPG in history is quite laughable. If that isn't jealousy and envy I don't know what is. Another new set of GORGEOUS zones, music, dungeons, and story arc.

    The game is as gorgeous as ever for a 16 year old juggernaut. Blizzard's team is
    I love all the idiots who give this game a 0 expansion after expansion for NO reason whatsoever. Their hatred for the most popular and successful MMORPG in history is quite laughable. If that isn't jealousy and envy I don't know what is. Another new set of GORGEOUS zones, music, dungeons, and story arc.

    The game is as gorgeous as ever for a 16 year old juggernaut. Blizzard's team is just so damn good. Let the haters keep coming back time and time again. They're so salty it's pathetic. There's an incredible amount of content here to keep anyone busy for hours on end.
    Expand
  23. Nov 30, 2020
    10
    This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. 10/10 expansion, everything is great, everything feels like Blizzard listened to 4 years of feedback and made this expansion accordingly. Expand
  24. Nov 26, 2020
    10
    Blizzard learned from their mistake in bfa and now here is the shadowlands! new features are awesome and new character model customisation and covenent system is nice! ignore negative reviews
  25. Nov 27, 2020
    10
    Wotlk=legion=shadowlands best expansion. Thanks Blizzard entertainment! For the Horde !
  26. Dec 2, 2020
    10
    Im really loving this expansion so far. PVP players finally can gear up only by doing PVP, and that's something i was waiting for years. The story is good, i didnt feel bored with it. Gearing up alts is also easier now, however i thought we will be able to skip more of the storyline what we have already had seen.
  27. Nov 27, 2020
    10
    Fantastic expansion, loads of great new story, improvements in PvP, and some really fun new systems and abilities. Huge improvement over BFA.
  28. Nov 27, 2020
    10
    Jajaja, saw many 0 , from haters, if dont like wow, plz leave, To me is the best expansion since BC and WOTLK, the Art and gameplay on all zones are priceless, I am playing Blizzard games since Starcraft launch, and Hope Blizz stay with us for a long time.
  29. Dec 9, 2020
    10
    A great expansion to a game that is still going strong. Fantastic storyline, questing through it is fun and immersive. Great new features that cater to both new players and veterans alike. Revamped levelling fixes the entry barrier finally making this game accessible to new players. Slight time-gating of content allows you to stay competitive even if you can't afford to spend 10h a dayA great expansion to a game that is still going strong. Fantastic storyline, questing through it is fun and immersive. Great new features that cater to both new players and veterans alike. Revamped levelling fixes the entry barrier finally making this game accessible to new players. Slight time-gating of content allows you to stay competitive even if you can't afford to spend 10h a day every day, which upsets no-lifers sure, but for most players - now they can finally not feel behind whole expansion. Core pve balancing problems addressed and for the most part this game is pure joy in its current state. Spent over a hundred hours in the first 2 weeks alone and still waking up excited to dive in for some more! Expand
  30. Nov 30, 2020
    10
    I absolutely love this expansion. I love the streamlined questing, the removal of titanforging, the gorgeous zones that don't rely on green glowing atmosphere (looking at you, Legion) or a swamp (looking at you, BfA). The covenant abilities are fun and add utility you can choose based on which zone you like most. I'm a m+ player and an AOTC into mythic raider, and I can't wait to get intoI absolutely love this expansion. I love the streamlined questing, the removal of titanforging, the gorgeous zones that don't rely on green glowing atmosphere (looking at you, Legion) or a swamp (looking at you, BfA). The covenant abilities are fun and add utility you can choose based on which zone you like most. I'm a m+ player and an AOTC into mythic raider, and I can't wait to get into the raids they have planned, and start pushing m+ keys. The bad reviews here are from people with nostalgia issues, period. This is the best expansion in every aspect since Wrath of the Lich King Expand
  31. Mar 6, 2022
    10
    Perfect expansion .I was not expecting wow to give good expansion after worst bfa .but here we are .love it
  32. Nov 25, 2020
    10
    This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. great addon, beautiful location, interesting storyline, less grindy gameplay Expand
  33. Nov 30, 2020
    10
    Потрясающе, 10/10. Увлекательно- затягивающая магия Blizzard. Приобрёл H edition
  34. Nov 30, 2020
    10
    Над игрой проделана потрясающая работа. Первые 10 часов не мог оторваться от игры. Интересные квесты, красивая музыка, в 10 раз лучше чем бфа
  35. Nov 28, 2020
    10
    This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Good, good, good, good, good, good, good, good, good, good, good, good, good, good Expand
  36. Nov 30, 2020
    10
    The delay was super worth it.
    Most of the classes are balanced, so are the covenants.
    I.e. I personally have never seen an addon whit better balancing of tanks. Also, the start was super smooth. No big bugs, not endless queue times (even on "full" realms) and I really enjoy the addon a lot so far. This might get my favorite addon next to WotLK. :) Don't see understand the
    The delay was super worth it.
    Most of the classes are balanced, so are the covenants.
    I.e. I personally have never seen an addon whit better balancing of tanks.

    Also, the start was super smooth.
    No big bugs, not endless queue times (even on "full" realms) and I really enjoy the addon a lot so far.
    This might get my favorite addon next to WotLK. :)

    Don't see understand the negative points of my predecessors, to be honest.
    I also don't see why you would give a bad score, because you think the price is too high?!

    Kudos to the teams at Blizzard, you did great work don't let you bring down by those stupid reviews.
    Expand
  37. Nov 25, 2020
    10
    Близы, спасибо. Очень ждал это дополнение и не зря. Прохождение компаний как в первый в вове. Интересный сюжет, прикольные кат-сцены. Норм арена. Рейды думаю тоже будут на высоте. В общем спасибо за работу.
  38. Dec 8, 2020
    10
    New expansion is the most epic and friendly for new gamers.
    Now the best time to "taste" WoW experience
  39. Nov 28, 2020
    10
    It's pretty good and since people give it 0 for minor inconveniences I have to counter that.
  40. Nov 29, 2020
    10
    + Best Addon start since Warth of the Lichking!
    + Nice and New Dungeons
    + better World quests
    + Legendary system witch is affordable
    + Torghast
    + So much to do. Took me over 80h just du finish everything
    + Lore on its best !
    + Old chars can be revisited :D
  41. Nov 26, 2020
    10
    This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Amazig new world,characters,story graphics, zones and more. Well done blizzard,thank you!!! Expand
  42. Nov 26, 2020
    10
    Feels like a decent solo game, a lot of really improved cutscenes and good combat. Skills and talents are meaningful gear system and once again they've revived PVP. This game still has everything to live up to its name. The world feels really filled with people, waiting for queues to login.
  43. Nov 27, 2020
    10
    Great expansion, story line is beautiful classes are fine zones are awesome i'm glad we got that expansion and i can't wait to see what it has to offer
  44. Nov 28, 2020
    10
    These reviews are wack this is the best expansion to date. The wow community is so whiny and toxic.
    Wonderful leveling system! The covenant system actually made me sit and think about what I wanted, all of the options are varied and worth choosing. ALL of the areas are beautiful and well made, the story and lore of the xpac are all well done and coherent. The classes all feel great with
    These reviews are wack this is the best expansion to date. The wow community is so whiny and toxic.
    Wonderful leveling system! The covenant system actually made me sit and think about what I wanted, all of the options are varied and worth choosing. ALL of the areas are beautiful and well made, the story and lore of the xpac are all well done and coherent. The classes all feel great with the new abilities. This xpac is so wonderful and I for one am thankful for all the blizz employees working from home to give us this masterpiece. Torghast is the best end game I've ever seen in ANY game. WoW Community always cry for stupid reason... there cannot be always NEW RACE you have allready TOO MUCH! you cant have always new CLASS .... the expansion looks GREAT enjoy it the way it is!!!!
    Expand
  45. Dec 2, 2020
    10
    Wow has finally gotten some meaning to it. All that carrot-on-a-stick systems are gone, and the game actually feels like good old wow again. Enjoing every single second of it!
  46. Dec 1, 2020
    10
    A really good storyline and world design coming along with fixing old problems like "campaign" tracking or useless grinding of player item power. The pacts are an innovative idea and it's really fun to play. Torghast with its randomly created dungeon logic (a little greeting of diablo mechanics) is a fresh welcome to the dungeon system of world of warcraft. Fun to play!
  47. Nov 24, 2020
    10
    Amazig new world,characters,story graphics, zones and more. Well done blizzard,thank you!!!
  48. Nov 24, 2020
    10
    Beautiful new regions, awesome leveling. Perfect graphics and sounds. Better than BfA in some many ways.
  49. Nov 25, 2020
    10
    Just a great expansion. I lost many hours on story and IT felt like few minutes.
  50. Nov 25, 2020
    10
    The new zones are great. Art team has done a fantastic job. 0/10s being posted by those who haven't even played
  51. Nov 25, 2020
    10
    Absoluetly amazing expansion. Better than legion which was very good.
    It's an apotheosis from every point of view : Universe, graphics, history, music, group activity...
    If you don't like Shadowland, go back to classic. Retail isn't for you.
  52. Nov 25, 2020
    10
    It’s really awesome! Nice design location and dungeon, lore and new graphics! World of Warcraft return!
  53. Nov 25, 2020
    10
    Beautiful zones, soundtracks, story, graphics, dungeons, gameplay.
    Nice launch start. 10/10
    Still the best game and MMO what ever made.
  54. Nov 25, 2020
    10
    Been playing since vanilla, zones are amazing, way better than bfa, haven't enjoyed an expansion this much since WOTLK
  55. Nov 25, 2020
    10
    The people voting 0 are definately working for the Jailer. Come on! You guys are really twisted.
    The game is better! Maybe you got worse.
  56. Nov 26, 2020
    10
    This game brings us back the hole experience of what is World Of Warcraft, you can pass hours leveling and it won't be boring, every minute ia a show of magic and immersion. You can feel a good job done on this expansion.
  57. Nov 26, 2020
    10
    I think this is really better than legion. The graphics, zones, covenats, solbinds, transmog looks really incredible. I thinks this will be an awesome expansion if this continue like this.
  58. Nov 26, 2020
    10
    I can't believe that haters... This expansion is very very good. I am not a fanboy and I give 4 score to BFA but giving 0 to this masterpiece is just disrespectful.

    Art team again did amazing job. New class systems are detailed and good. They improved PVP. Storytelling is not at its best, but still good so far. (Especially after Nzoth disaster) I cant believe people still blaming
    I can't believe that haters... This expansion is very very good. I am not a fanboy and I give 4 score to BFA but giving 0 to this masterpiece is just disrespectful.

    Art team again did amazing job.
    New class systems are detailed and good.
    They improved PVP.
    Storytelling is not at its best, but still good so far. (Especially after Nzoth disaster)
    I cant believe people still blaming about servers... They have probably the best servers in MMORPG world.

    I don't understand how they say world is empty. For 3 days I had to wait for 5 minutes in queue to log in. Don't listen that haters. They just want to vomid their toxicity against Blizzard. This expansion is solid 7 at its worst.
    Expand
  59. Nov 27, 2020
    10
    Very good gameplay and lore, wonderful locations! I've got many pleasure from this addon. Recommended for buy.
  60. Nov 27, 2020
    10
    Great locations, interesting quests, great start, amazing addon. GJ Blizzard!
  61. Nov 27, 2020
    10
    You know why tere are so many "negative" reviews? Yeah, it's because milions of players are busy enjoying the game right now.

    As for now after doing full 8/8 m0 dungeon cycle i can tell that i will already love(and hate myself) while playing m+ because dungeons will be really hard, blizzard promised to exclude raiding as something mandatory and they did, now everyone is free to do what
    You know why tere are so many "negative" reviews? Yeah, it's because milions of players are busy enjoying the game right now.

    As for now after doing full 8/8 m0 dungeon cycle i can tell that i will already love(and hate myself) while playing m+ because dungeons will be really hard, blizzard promised to exclude raiding as something mandatory and they did, now everyone is free to do what they want to do, you're not being forced to do anything and can enjoy which aspect of the game you want without being behind because you skipped other parts of the game.

    There need to be some tuning made before next content update, but overall all of 3 classes and 4 specs i played seemed good on their own.

    It is too early to tell anything more, since first raid is going to be released december 8th and i assume way more content will be announced during blizzcon.

    Haters gonna hate.
    Expand
  62. Nov 27, 2020
    10
    It shines like diamond on the summer sun! Tonns of new contntent and mechanics only at first patch, enemies gotted stronger and more dangerous, perfect working system of covenants, pretty good plot, new graphics and a lot of little things that made it game much better!
  63. Nov 27, 2020
    10
    Having a blast so far! The sweaty people aren't happy, but I haven't run into any issues at all as I'm just enjoying the levelling experience and dungeons.
  64. Nov 27, 2020
    10
    Wonderful leveling system! The covenant system actually made me sit and think about what I wanted, all of the options are varied and worth choosing. ALL of the areas are beautiful and well made, the story and lore of the xpac are all well done and coherent. The classes all feel great with the new abilities. This xpac is so wonderful and I for one am thankful for all the blizz employeesWonderful leveling system! The covenant system actually made me sit and think about what I wanted, all of the options are varied and worth choosing. ALL of the areas are beautiful and well made, the story and lore of the xpac are all well done and coherent. The classes all feel great with the new abilities. This xpac is so wonderful and I for one am thankful for all the blizz employees working from home to give us this masterpiece. Torghast is the best end game I've ever seen in ANY game. Expand
  65. Nov 27, 2020
    10
    Best expansion since legion, No infinite grinds, better story, easy leveling, beautiful art, wonderful songs, fun tower levels with crazy powers. I can't wait for raiding to begin!
  66. Nov 27, 2020
    10
    This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. И так дополнение Тёмные земли.
    На мой взгляд, это просто один из самых лучший аддонов или самый лучший аддон.
    Не хуже легиона уж точно, и скорее всего даже лучше выйдет.
    С первых минут игры чувствуется эпичность и необычность происходящего.
    Квесты понятные и доступные (они озвучены голосом), прокачка цепляет и это первый раз за всё время моей игры в WoW (с 2009) когда на прокачке мне было абсолютно плевать на мой уровень, и я просто проходил все задания и совсем не спешил взять максимальный уровень потому, что было прям интересно.
    Красивые локации, крутые подземелья (одни только "туманы скитта" и "та сторона" чего стоят, торгаст который можно проходить даже одному, всё это даёт огромный кредит доверия дополнению с первых дней.

    10/10 Я в восторге!
    Expand
  67. Nov 28, 2020
    10
    I feel like any reviews at this point after the expansion's release are premature, positive or not, but the amount of negative reviews already surfacing have forced my hand.

    I've played WoW since Classic and this is easily the most fun I've had at the start of an expansion since Wrath of the Lich King. I think that the longer the game goes on, the harder it becomes to make any viable
    I feel like any reviews at this point after the expansion's release are premature, positive or not, but the amount of negative reviews already surfacing have forced my hand.

    I've played WoW since Classic and this is easily the most fun I've had at the start of an expansion since Wrath of the Lich King. I think that the longer the game goes on, the harder it becomes to make any viable plot and pathways for decent story, as you have to veer away from the previous events and create new history to tie off any loopholes. Blizzard once again manages to handle this pretty efficiently and I think that the only people that could complain about that aspect of the expansion are obviously well-versed in the art of writing and have written multiple award-winning, international best selling fantasy novels... or maybe they're just incredibly negative and look for anything to complain about.

    Out of any expansion I've played, this is easily the expansion where Blizzard's work is most tangible. It's clear that they wanted to make changes and improvements and you can feel that at every point throughout expansion. Each zone is incredibly well done, both audibly and visually and I honestly still can't choose a favorite. Covenants, soulbinds, and conduits are a very interesting way to progress through the end game and bolster your character. If anybody is concerned about balance or CLEAR CUT BIS choices, they'd have to swallow the painful and objective truth that is 'meta.' There will always be a meta. You can never completely eliminate a meta. As far as end-game character progression goes, this is pretty good. There's a nice spectrum of balance for things that may work better for your playstyle, even if it's not what's best for the class.

    I won't even get started on Torghast. I'll just say this, I don't know how anybody could be upset with Torghast as it stands, it's the first week, we've only seen two floors... and the ceiling for potential content is so high with how they've designed it.

    If your goal is to preorder a game, start complaining four days after it was released, and post a negative review, I have some advice: Refund the game and stop playing. The atmosphere would be better without people that can't be pleased and refuse to acknowledge that negativity breeds more negativity.

    Thanks Blizzard for more than a decade's worth of hard work.

    Edit: I gave this a 10 review to counter balance the insane and ridiculous 0 reviews I read. In all honesty, my actual rating would be an 8/10 or a 9/10.
    Expand
  68. Nov 27, 2020
    10
    One of the best expansions they have done. Made new and returning players welcome with easy to catch up tutorials and experiences. Beautiful new zones, npcs and a compelling story.
  69. Nov 27, 2020
    10
    Great story as Blizzard takes things to the afterlife of the World of Warcraft! I'm intrigued to see how things develop!
  70. Nov 27, 2020
    10
    No titan forging
    PVP scaling removed
    Doesnt take 30+ hours to level a toon
    Dungeons are good
    Gear matters more
    Zones are interesting

    Cant wait for raid
  71. Nov 27, 2020
    10
    Fantastic expansion as well, don't know what people are complaining about.
  72. Nov 27, 2020
    10
    These reviews are wack this is the best expansion to date. The wow community is so whiny and toxic. Best expansion for new players to join.
  73. Dec 1, 2020
    10
    Пока моя личная оценка 7 з минусом, но ставлю 10. Люди же ставят 0 хотя этот аддон явно такого бала не заслужил то почему бы мне не поставить 10. Много чего понравилось, но не без проблем, игровые механики на которых базируется сама игра, такие как абилки ковенантов или проводники не сбалансированы, некоторые спеки были переработаны сильно, а некоторые вообще не трогали. Так же естьПока моя личная оценка 7 з минусом, но ставлю 10. Люди же ставят 0 хотя этот аддон явно такого бала не заслужил то почему бы мне не поставить 10. Много чего понравилось, но не без проблем, игровые механики на которых базируется сама игра, такие как абилки ковенантов или проводники не сбалансированы, некоторые спеки были переработаны сильно, а некоторые вообще не трогали. Так же есть проблема с багами, хотя их не так много если вспомнить предыдущие аддоны. В общем старт не плохой но надо будет смотреть как все пойдет дальше, ведь дренор изначально тоже все хвалили. P.S люди что пишут про то что нету новой расы или класса, в бфа было аж 8 новых рас, эти расы помогли аддону? спойлер нет. Стоит ли брать решать уже вам, мое мнение субективно как и у всех критиков и ютуберов, не слушайте ни меня что поставил 10 ни тех кто поставил 0. Просто решите для себя эта игра по кайфу или нет :D Expand
  74. Nov 27, 2020
    10
    Good expansion with decent storyline. Trols will be cry at comments, look at their post 24 and 25.11.2020 srsly they coment about 1 day nc about this;D
  75. Nov 27, 2020
    10
    I see score bombing, I act. Game is brilliant. Don't worry about sad boomers posting 0 points reviews, sad life forcing them to complain or they getting paid to do so.
  76. Nov 27, 2020
    10
    Beautiful new zones, interesting lore, promising dungeons and best of all no infinite grind.
  77. Nov 27, 2020
    10
    Great expansion! Bastion zone is beautiful and there are lots of things to do. I always have enjoyed this game and never played it as a competitor to hit the max level under hours or so. If you do that you never loved the game at all. For me it is 10 and above, folks!
  78. Nov 27, 2020
    10
    This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Ultimately the worst thing about this game as a whole, is the elitist, toxic, childish, and unappreciative vocal minority who put their opinions on their channels or turn it into memes so that their opinion is echoed by the wanderers of the internet who join in on something "for the meme". The player base is the absolute worst thing about the game. League of legends (Which is notoriously toxic) is like a glass of fresh water compared to the venom that is spewed in WoW these days.

    The people giving 0 reviews a few days into the expansion are buffoons. It is literally impossible to have played, experienced, or even unlocked all of the content that was added with this expansion. It is the first week and people are judging the first part of the story (yes the leveling experience is only the first part of the story in ANY given expansion).

    To address some of the "Issues" people have:

    - There doesn't need to be a new class every other expansion. Let them work on balancing the classes they have first. I'm sure the people crying about not getting a new class, are also the people crying that they aren't balanced or "complete". Constantly adding new classes makes balancing more difficult, and causes class homogenization.

    - Saying "Classes unfinished" literally means nothing. Unfinished means incomplete, not "if only we had x ability that I just thought up spot then we'd top the meters! But since that ability doesn't exist the class is unfinished!" By that logic no MMO ever has a "complete class"... Just because your class underperforms from what you want doesn't mean its "unfinished" it just means either you go the short end of the stick and didn't get to be the top of the ranking tier this expansion, and/or you just suck at playing your class. Not every single class can be top tier at the same time. There will always be a best and worst.

    - They don't need to add new races this expansion they literally spent the last expansion adding races to the game.

    - The dungeons have all been great, there is a nice range of difficulties amongst them and I look forward to running keys in them.

    - There are tons of recognizable characters as well as the new ones, if you don't recognize the old ones you obviously didn't play back in the day. They have to introduce new lore, story, and characters in order to keep things interesting. The people who complain about them adding new story and characters basically just want classic.

    -Lets list the recognizable characters in the expansion so far just off the top of my head: Sylvanas, Jaina, Thrall, Baine, Anduin, Tyrande, Bolvar, Calia, Nazgrim, Whitemane, Morgraine, Lady Vasjh, Draka, Uther, Kael'Thas, Kel'Thuzad, Taelia, Vol'jin, Hakkar, Milhouse Manastorm, Mueh'Zala (check classic stranglethorn), and others that i cant recall currently. not to mention ones such as Garrosh (who might show up as he was in the revendreth cine) or even characters like Arthas, who haven't shown up yet but almost definitely will, on top of all the small cameos from minor characters such as Cookie from Deadmines.

    - The professions are much better than they were in some (but not all) of the other expansions, (namely BFA and WoD were way worse). And the fact that they are used to make Legendary gear is a good sign for them maintaining a little more relevance throughout. Although Engineering seems to be lacking so far.

    - The zones are nice overall, but people seem to say they like the look of one and then **** on the rest for not matching the aesthetic they like. They weren't supposed to be the same as each other, of course some neckbearded edgelord isn't going to like bastion or ardenweald. The game is made for more people than just you.

    - The people saying "no new systems or features" are, first of all, forgetting that Torghast was added and the game hasn't had something like that before. On top of that they seem to fail to realize that the systems and features they don't seem to see is in fact the covenant and sanctums. They have literally reused assets and systems since they started releasing expansions for this game. Literally all the way back to BC. They always taken things from past expansions and try to put a new spin on it or change it in some way. stop acting like the gaming industry standard of reusing and rehashing ideas is a new thing. its not a new thing. Just look at Elder Scrolls, Skyrim has literally just been reformatted for different platforms and graphically updated and rereleased exactly the same for the last DECADE.

    - People seem to fail to realize that you will get more content as you upgrade your covenant? And that it takes time to do so? And that "time gating" is used to prevent the aforementioned neckbeards from tearing through the whole expansion in a week and then crying that there is no new content for the next few months while the rest of us play like sane people who have jobs, lives, and families outside of the game.
    Expand
  79. Nov 27, 2020
    10
    Absolutely amazing so far.. it’s fun, engaging, runs so smooth and looks beautiful
  80. Nov 27, 2020
    10
    Played through the Story, capped all the stuff i have to cap in ~15-20 hours played on Max level so far.
    Perfect for casual players and for the type of player who sink in to a game.
    The Dungeons are beautiful, the Boss fights are awesome, can´t wait for the Raid to open.
    Even the pvp is fun again with no gear scaling.
  81. Nov 27, 2020
    10
    Everything from the endgame to the quality of life improvements are the best that WoW has seen. For the first time in WoW history, Blizzard figured out how to make decent looking in-engine cutscenes and it made the story much more memorable even if it wasn't exactly my cup of tea.

    This is a perfect time to jump in for the first time or to return after a long hiatus.
  82. Nov 27, 2020
    10
    This expansion was definitely a breathe of fresh air. It made me moist really. Truly the developers have created a basement flooding experience worthy of the gods! The zones are well done and the story line is an enticing little morsel that makes you crave resolution but leaves you wanting more. UUUUUUUGH Its got me just dripping with excitement! The classes have been improved in a wayThis expansion was definitely a breathe of fresh air. It made me moist really. Truly the developers have created a basement flooding experience worthy of the gods! The zones are well done and the story line is an enticing little morsel that makes you crave resolution but leaves you wanting more. UUUUUUUGH Its got me just dripping with excitement! The classes have been improved in a way that allows for the creative and versatile type of play that makes me scream with satisfaction! 10/10 BRAVO BLIZZARD! BRAVO!!!!! and for those reading this... You're Welcome. P.S. This is not sarcastic.... No really its not. (Its actually not) Expand
  83. Nov 27, 2020
    10
    Really solid and nice looking expac. The class feel is much better and the zones are well made. Story is solid too
  84. Nov 27, 2020
    10
    I have played every expansion launch since Wrath of the Lich King, and this must be the best expansion launch ever, for a few reasons.
    No1: The first launch ever in which I haven't faced any Lag or Bug issues, everything was smooth and the way it was intended.
    No2: Blizzard learned their mistakes with non-alt friendly systems, such as essences, corruptions, artifact/azerite powers, etc.
    I have played every expansion launch since Wrath of the Lich King, and this must be the best expansion launch ever, for a few reasons.
    No1: The first launch ever in which I haven't faced any Lag or Bug issues, everything was smooth and the way it was intended.
    No2: Blizzard learned their mistakes with non-alt friendly systems, such as essences, corruptions, artifact/azerite powers, etc. Even questing, now you must go through campaign quests in only one character, after that, you may level up the way you most desire, free of penalties or other consequences.
    No3: the expansion theme is fresh, authentic with new lore stuff that continue stories that we thought were over.
    No4: we have less RNG in gearing systems, for both pvp and pve. Players can once again do all their gearing through pvp. Farming legendaries isn't an issue, as it was in Legion expansion, or other inconvenient systems we had before, such as war/titanforging and corruptions.

    Everyone telling this expansion launch is not good, don't really know what they're looking for. They're just criticising a good job from Blizzard after the overall opinion that BfA was bad. They have fixed what players said "made BfA bad", and still players criticise the game.
    Expand
  85. Nov 27, 2020
    10
    By Far the best XPAC since WOTLK. Super proud of the Blizz development team. This may be what will restore my passion for the Warcraft Universe.
  86. Nov 28, 2020
    10
    They did, what they didn’t in bfa. Design of locations is awesome, main history is enthralling and interesting.
  87. Nov 28, 2020
    10
    Honestly don't understand the negative reviews. This is at least as good as Legion. I'm gonna address some of the negative reviews here.

    I was a cynical **** going into this. BFA was the lowest point in WoW for me. I didn't quit in WoD because classes were actually fun, BFA though, ye that was a mess. No new class is disappointing, I'll concede that. No new race is laughable
    Honestly don't understand the negative reviews. This is at least as good as Legion. I'm gonna address some of the negative reviews here.

    I was a cynical **** going into this. BFA was the lowest point in WoW for me. I didn't quit in WoD because classes were actually fun, BFA though, ye that was a mess.

    No new class is disappointing, I'll concede that. No new race is laughable considering the amount of new customisation we got. Borrowed power I get, they've been at that since Legion and it does feel bad at the end of the xpac. UI is a non-issue when the game supports addons. I won't comment on server problems, I play on a low pop server and haven't been dc'd once or had to queue. Levelling feels fantastic this time around imo. Then given the levelling revamp, not really sure what the issue is for people here.

    Not many features? That's just a straight up lie. Covenants, Torghast, Soulbinds/conduits, legendary crafting, Classic has raid logging, that's about it. Launch did have issues for some, for me it's been smooth as butter. A crap load of content was added, again see features above.

    As to Covenants, choice and balance. I was a cynical POS going into this, I picked my Covenant based on power. I'm part of a pretty regular group. We have members that went BIS Covenant and members who went worst because it was one they liked. We have yet to notice any real difference in terms of player power. I'm sure it's there, but it's negligible. This'll probably change a bit once the raid comes out and people start logging. At the very least that'll change community perception towards the "worst" choices. But honestly, I'm fine with it having played it now, it's not nearly the big issue we thought it would be. Currently my biggest concerns are aimed towards soulbinds and changing between them with different specs.

    So ye, I'll leave it there as a lot of the other reasons listed are either incomprehensible due to spelling and grammar errors, or just repeating ones already addressed.

    TLDR: I honestly think this is at least Legion levels of good. I had zero expectations going into this because of Blizzard over the last number of years but I'm pleasantly surprised. If they can address some of the problems that exist, this could be a very, very good expansion. I look forward to what we have to come. And I have one piece of advice. If you're enjoying yourself and think it's good, stay off forums for a few weeks (including Reddit). People will taint your own opinion with their **** and reading half of these reviews, they're left by people I can only conclude haven't actually bothered playing the game to end game.
    Expand
  88. Nov 28, 2020
    10
    Está expansión tiene todo lo que no han tenido las anteriores expansiones.
  89. Nov 28, 2020
    10
    Nice change after bfa. I dont understand how people could rate this expansion with 0.
  90. Nov 28, 2020
    10
    Nice Game :D great story. Torghast fills refreshing for a new Game mode. I can't wait more yo play de raids and dungeon no mythic.
  91. Nov 28, 2020
    10
    New expansion ads a lot of fun new content and the covenants are great! Don't listen to the haters that are mad about not getting a new class or race, this expansion is awesome!
  92. Nov 28, 2020
    10
    Отличное дополнение, приятные локации, удобная система прокачки для альтернативных персонажей. Очень гладкий старт дополнения.
  93. Nov 28, 2020
    10
    Amazing job Blizzard. I have had many times where I lost faith in the capabilities of the Studio. But I hope this is a sign of things to come later in the expansion. Classic revived my passion for the game and I hoped that one day I would play retail again. Coming from Classic to this has been fantastic so far. I do miss the weird and and crazy interactions in the more sandbox ClassicAmazing job Blizzard. I have had many times where I lost faith in the capabilities of the Studio. But I hope this is a sign of things to come later in the expansion. Classic revived my passion for the game and I hoped that one day I would play retail again. Coming from Classic to this has been fantastic so far. I do miss the weird and and crazy interactions in the more sandbox Classic version of the game. But I somehow feel that I can appreciate the quality of life improvements a lot more. It’s just a different game. Expand
  94. Dec 5, 2020
    10
    I have played all wow expansions and I’m sure this can be the best one, I will give it 10/10 because 6.1 is to low for this
  95. Nov 28, 2020
    10
    This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. I like that the leveling and intro quest chain through all zones are largely aligned. No more max level at 2 zones and missing all the content.

    Also, I can't speak for all the covenants, but the night fae induction is friggin hilarious! Kudos to the writers on that one, the who sequence is awesome.

    The covenant progression so far feels good. Honor bound, anima, renown, a few ways to grind.

    The new solo/group instance seems pretty legit. If you ever wanted to play Diablo with your wow character, this is your chance.

    The zones are huge and all have very distinctive feels, and the interesting moral dilemma each presents is interesting. The launch was incredibly smooth. Only issue I saw in the first few days was a world server being down for a couple of hours.
    Also, with the newest gear specs, it's been super easy to bounce between tanking and dps, so getting quick queues is easier than ever.
    Expand
  96. Nov 28, 2020
    10
    I have been playing evry day now and im just loving the game. Leveling feels great and the story is really good, dung are top notch...
  97. Nov 28, 2020
    10
    I created a MetaCritic account solely to review this game after I saw the abysmal (and childish) reviews it was getting. I just hit level 60 and am nearly finished with the Ardenweald story, and I had to stop to write this. I've been playing WoW off and on since 2004, and I felt neutral? about BFA, and went into Shadowlands with low expectations. I am blown away. The graphics areI created a MetaCritic account solely to review this game after I saw the abysmal (and childish) reviews it was getting. I just hit level 60 and am nearly finished with the Ardenweald story, and I had to stop to write this. I've been playing WoW off and on since 2004, and I felt neutral? about BFA, and went into Shadowlands with low expectations. I am blown away. The graphics are incredible, the worlds are immersive, the little treasure hunts are fun (vs previous xpacs where it'd be some amount of "war resources" etc and junk to sell, this is mostly fun pets and unique surprises). The quests alternate between "just pure fun" with a sense of humor and serious story. The cutscenes can be downright "MY EMOTIONS" at times, which I didn't expect at all. I actually stopped playing only a few hours in on release day because I knew this was a game I wanted to savor (and oops I'm max level already, I've been bingeing it since). This might be my favorite expansion of all, which I realize is a big claim. I'm thoroughly enjoying it so far and I hope it's not over too soon. (Will that be my fault for rushing, or will that be evidence of not enough content? Who knows!) I just wanted to give an honest, thoughtful review because I'm really delighted with it and offended by all of these...frankly garbage, immature comments here. MORE LIKE THIS PLEASE, Blizz! :) Expand
  98. Nov 28, 2020
    10
    Отличные локации, очень интересный сюжет, НЕВЕРОЯТНО красивые данжи и локации,
  99. Nov 28, 2020
    10
    Best expansion! Rares are now little adventures. Side quest have one long story and mechanics. Graphic is beautiful. Dungeons are super interesting.
    Whole vibe of SL is Destiny meeting Planescape Torment.
    Great job Blizzard!
  100. Nov 28, 2020
    10
    Gorgeous addition !!! People who are unhappy with something, sorry, but you got drunk! the first week of the supplement, and you are already drawing conclusions. The Covenant is awesome, score 10/10
Metascore
83

Generally favorable reviews - based on 32 Critic Reviews

Critic score distribution:
  1. Positive: 31 out of 32
  2. Negative: 0 out of 32
  1. LEVEL (Czech Republic)
    Apr 12, 2021
    80
    Blizzard finally comes with an alt-friendly expansion that brings back the best features of the previous ones. The patch that WoW desperately needed. [Issue#309]
  2. Jan 29, 2021
    90
    World of Warcraft: Shadowlands certainly manages to capture the same feelings we’ve had since first started playing the game. The leveling experience overhaul, constant sense of progress with rewards, and new campaign stories make Shadowlands a must-have for any avid player.
  3. Jan 27, 2021
    90
    World of Warcraft: Shadowlands is a return to greatness for the franchise. The content is both accessible and fun for all types of players, and the story actually makes you feel like everything you’re doing is helping to save the Shadowlands. Torghast is one of the best features ever added and makes each experience unique and fun. While there are some issues which can slow down the time it takes to get everything you want, the journey there is still enjoyable.