Matchmaker Agency is a cute game that is easy to get into both for fans of the management space and for newcomers who are attracted by the idea of getting people to fall in love with each other. The mystical powers element is a little weird, but the mechanics built around it mostly work, although there are moments when the events and their effects don’t fully make sense. The core character selection is good, as is the variety of people coming to the agency for help. Over time, the selection of date locations starts to feel limited, and it becomes annoying to see repeated situations. Matchmaker Agency could have used some extra polish but still delivers the satisfaction of creating new couples via the magic of a carefully considered match.