The game has some very good ideas and is perhaps a decent foundation for interesting series of large scale fishing simulators, but this initial entry is very far from perfect, though it is playable.
I am not a graphics maniac, but I will start with visuals first this time - the game is pretty poor in terms of visuals, with the exception of some very specific spots and a couple specificThe game has some very good ideas and is perhaps a decent foundation for interesting series of large scale fishing simulators, but this initial entry is very far from perfect, though it is playable.
I am not a graphics maniac, but I will start with visuals first this time - the game is pretty poor in terms of visuals, with the exception of some very specific spots and a couple specific boat models. This would not be an issue by itself, at least for me, but what definitely is an issue is the very poor optimization - despite the poor visuals, you will suffer frame dips, microstutter, etc. Despite updating drivers, etc., it remained problematic, and turning up certain settings would not only cause FPS issues, but also cause graphical issues - texture artifacts, water turning pure black, etc.
Sound design - well, the ambience of the sea is pretty decent, but most of the boats sound weird - especially the first one, which appears to have a lawn mower engine.
The UI also leaves a lot to be desired, and you will have to search for related information by clicking through multiple menus or tabs, most of which are not really necessary other than containing the info you are looking for, which could be moved elsewhere - some streamlining would help a lot. Some crucial information is also missing completely, if you are lucky, it is on the game wiki, but a lot of it is for some reason no properly displayed in the game nor can be found on the wiki, so your options are to data mine or just go with it and see what happens - for example, the game supposedly simulates overfishing, but I never found any indicator of it in the game, and the availability of fish in certain areas changed pretty much randomly on game restarts...
The variety of fish is okay, the crab DLC helps, the multiple fishing styles are also nice, though the minigames going along with some of them are really janky. The availability and variety of ships is pretty good, the game is a bit grindy and requires some commitment, but it's not too frustrating, and when the jank is toned down a bit, the minigames are actually fun enough. The main issue with the game is that there is no "speed up time / wait here" option when not moving, and when you move, it of course consumes fuel, which is annoying AF, and I actually decided to cheat and use a trainer to give myself infinite fuel. Wouldn't have done it if there was an option to just wait without wasting fuel. This isn't much of an issue with bigger ships where you will actually dropy your traps at different places with decent distance away from each other, but with smaller ships, it definitely is - also, fuel is much more of a concern due to A) smaller tank capacity and B) lower income, meaning it hurts a lot more to just swim around your traps waiting for them to fill.
The game also has fog of war hiding pretty much all of the map and you have to go around all of it to uncover it. This by itself would not be too much of an issue if most of it was actually just an empty "wasteland" and so doing it is literal waste of time, but you kind have to do it, because on restart of the game, fishing ground can change and get hidden again by the FOW. I guess it could work as "hardcore" mode feature, but on first playthrough, it's just annoying AF.
Anyways, the base idea is pretty good and I don't believe there is any real competition doing something similar, at least not right now - aside from the second game in the series, which appears to be more of the same in different location, rather than a sequel, but I have not played it, so I digress. Fishing: Barents Sea is an average game. It has some good ideas, some bad, some of it is done well, some of it is not. It can be recommended to fans of fishing or ship simulators, if they intend to buy it at a heavy discount, but everyone else should steer clear, because the few pros it has are definitely not enough to turn you into a huge simulator games fan, and the cons will probably be enough to make you never try anything similar ever again, which would be a shame, as there are a lot of good simulators out there.… Expand