Todd McCarthy
Select another critic »For 1,835 reviews, this critic has graded:
-
49% higher than the average critic
-
2% same as the average critic
-
49% lower than the average critic
On average, this critic grades 2.5 points lower than other critics.
(0-100 point scale)
Todd McCarthy's Scores
- Movies
- TV
| Average review score: | 63 | |
|---|---|---|
| Highest review score: | Mulholland Dr. | |
| Lowest review score: | Showgirls | |
Score distribution:
-
Positive: 947 out of 1835
-
Mixed: 724 out of 1835
-
Negative: 164 out of 1835
1835
movie
reviews
-
- Todd McCarthy
The audaciousness that marked Todd Haynes’ earlier work has been supplanted by self-important preachiness in Safe.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Raunchy humor laced with gradually revealed vulnerability makes for a winning combination in Obvious Child, a wildly funny and appealing female-centric comedy that launches very promising talent on both sides of the camera.- The Hollywood Reporter
- Posted Jun 5, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
The connection between art and technology is explored in an entertaining and accessible way in Tim's Vermeer, a documentary that demonstrates how a savvy and dedicated amateur with sufficient resources was able to create a remarkable likeness of a great 17th century painting.- The Hollywood Reporter
- Posted Nov 5, 2013
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Created as a comic vehicle for the lead actor, pic depends entirely too much on Wayans to carry the day, but at this point he is far more eager and willing than he is funny.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Gubbins’ script is tart, verbally lively and neatly constructed, while director Josephine Decker, in her first outing since her well-received 2018 Sundance entry Madeline’s Madeline, keeps a very tight rein on things, adroitly mixing in tension, innuendo and dark humor to keep the drama at a satisfying low boil most of the way.- The Hollywood Reporter
- Posted Jan 26, 2020
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
The film’s virtues are modest, but Buscemi has come out on top by taking on people and a place he clearly knows inside out.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Precise, lucid and thrillingly disciplined, this story of boundary-testing in the early days of psychoanalysis is brought to vivid life by the outstanding lead performances of Keira Knightley, Viggo Mortensen and Michael Fassbender.- The Hollywood Reporter
- Posted Oct 24, 2011
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Whit Stillman's stiff directorial approach ill suits the sensual ambiance of the club scene so intently depicted, and the mostly self-conscious, uptight characters seem to have made a left turn out of "Metropolitan" and walked through the wrong door to turn up in this flamboyant druggie scene.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Absorbing, exciting at times and undeniably entertaining, and is poised to be a major commercial hit. But great it's not.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
A collection of five femme-oriented vignettes that are not intricately linked dramatically but overlap characters, this observant, emotionally acute drama is distinguished by a pronounced poetic sensibility.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Underachieves in its own way by trapping an expansive, probing story in a brittle, highly artificial style that constricts character and emotional development.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
A desperately slight romantic comedy marked by contrived romance and little comedy.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
This is a safe, serviceable, carefully crafted action drama in which the subversive seeds planted in the first story take welcome root.- The Hollywood Reporter
- Posted Nov 12, 2013
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Disappointingly, Death of a President shrinks from its promise as a piece of genuinely radical or adventurous speculative fiction.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
The bawdy jokes score big points, but it's the rueful acknowledgement of adolescent embarrassment and humiliation that most distinguishes Superbad, another ultra-raunchy and commercial sex comedy from the Judd Apatow laugh factory.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Structurally and thematically similar to John Frankenheimer's original but entirely different in style, feel and nuance, this political thriller about a brainwashed soldier being positioned for the White House provides a delectable network of dramatic tripwires that teases the mind and quickens the pulse. This is brainy popcorn fare.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
As a study of stasis and of people conscious of not living the lives they had imagined for themselves, the picture offers a bracing undertow of seriousness beneath the deceptively casual, dramatically offhand surface.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
An array of supporting craftspeople pull the viewer into a credible alternative world, even if the film itself is more prosaic than inspiring.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Cedar impressively creates a complex and intricately detailed portrait of the web of political, financial, social and religious affiliations that has everything to do with how the world works.- The Hollywood Reporter
- Posted Sep 16, 2016
- Read full review
-
- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
The film has nothing if not great vitality and an active creative spirit, but it has all been channeled here in a way that comes off as erratic and sometimes ill-judged.- The Hollywood Reporter
- Posted Feb 1, 2015
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
The mash-up of elements combine with a singularly unpleasant roster of characters to create a work of genuinely off-putting quirkiness.- The Hollywood Reporter
- Posted Jan 26, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
A passably entertaining hodgepodge of old and new animation techniques, mixed sensibilities and hedged commercial calculations.- The Hollywood Reporter
- Posted Dec 9, 2010
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
La Belle Epoque is the sort of vastly entertaining mainstream French film that was produced with regularity during the 1970s-'80s and was sometimes remade by Hollywood. Those days are long gone but it could happen with this witty, sexy and original romantic comedy that touches many points of satisfaction.- The Hollywood Reporter
- Posted Jan 15, 2020
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Engaging, intermittently insightful but too glib to wring full value out of its subject matter.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Everything the film has to offer is obvious and on the surface, its pleasures simple and sincere under the attentive guidance of director Jon S. Baird.- The Hollywood Reporter
- Posted Nov 7, 2018
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Nearly as extravagant as the characters it depicts, Martin Scorsese's comic, operatically-scaled film is, on a moment-by-moment basis, often madly entertaining due to its live-wire energy, exuberant performances and the irresistible appeal of watching naughty boys doing very naughty things.- The Hollywood Reporter
- Posted Dec 17, 2013
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Spielberg is such a talented director it’s a shame to see him lose all sense of subtlety and nuance.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Neither the establishing dramatic linchpin nor the final conversion of conscience is terribly convincing, leaving this pared-down rendition of the original work diminished in power and meaning as well.- The Hollywood Reporter
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
As usual, there are only fragments of thoughts, nothing is developed, and it will be left only to the tiny band of die-hard Godardians to try to make any meaningful sense of the disparate fragments stitched together here.- The Hollywood Reporter
- Posted May 24, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Has a jaunty, cosmopolitan air that proves appealing for considerable stretches, and Chin's love of cinema and mostly humorous approach to weighty themes will win points with buffs who have seen the same films the director has.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
More than the film that surrounds him, Jack Black is worth the price of admission in Bernie, an oddball May-December true life crime story that would have profited from being a whole lot darker and full-bodied than it is.- The Hollywood Reporter
- Posted Apr 21, 2012
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
For longtime Wiig fans, this uneven, overlong, emotionally involving and discreetly ambitious film will represent a welcome and overdue step up from her popular sketch work on "Saturday Night Live" to something sustained and searching, not to mention pretty funny.- The Hollywood Reporter
- Posted May 7, 2011
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
A career high point for Ralph Fiennes as both an actor and director, this unfussy and emotionally penetrating work also provides lead actress Felicity Jones with the prime role in which she abundantly fulfills the promise suggested in some of her earlier small films.- The Hollywood Reporter
- Posted Sep 15, 2013
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
A breezy, keen-to-please attitudes prevails, and director James Bobin (The Flight of the Conchords, Da Ali G Show for TV) moves things along with good cheer.- The Hollywood Reporter
- Posted Nov 18, 2011
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
With Gere’s character so lacking in memory and mental clarity, the film provides very little for an audience to latch on to. Tedium quickly sets in and is only sporadically relieved in this labor of love that simply doesn’t reward even the patient attention of sympathetic viewers.- The Hollywood Reporter
- Posted Dec 8, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
McCarten’s scene writing is tart and efficient and Wright infuses the drama with unquestioned energy. But this is a film in which every point and meaning is hit directly on the nose.- The Hollywood Reporter
- Posted Sep 2, 2017
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
A pounding, pulsating thriller that provides an almost constant adrenaline surge for nearly two hours.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
A full-blown musical that commutes between Disney's patented cartoon universe and the "real" world with cleverness and grace, this splashy production reminds one of nothing in the Disney canon so much as "Mary Poppins," not least due to the "star is born" aura that surrounds Amy Adams here, just as it did Julie Andrews 43 years ago.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Lightning strikes twice, but not as brilliantly as before, in Shrek 2. The welcome sequel to the monster 2001 Oscar winner about an ogre's unlikely romance with a beautiful princess successfully recycles many of the qualities that made the first one an instant animated classic and worldwide smash.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
An exemplary and dynamic work that goes about as far as a narrative film can in both analyzing a complex personality and portraying a cultural scene.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Blandness and lack of daring characterize nearly every minute of the very long two hours, which are marked by a high degree of professionalism at the service of little content.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Has a casual, freewheeling nature in contrast to the creeping grandiosity of some of Disney's A-list animated titles.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
In trying to merge this alarmist theme with an old-fashioned murder mystery, the filmmakers throw at least one plot-twist sucker-punch too many, leaving the viewer with an “Oh, come on” reaction to the entire film.- The Hollywood Reporter
- Posted Feb 3, 2013
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
A spectacular demonstration of what modern technology can contribute to dramatic storytelling.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Carlos Lopez Estrada’s debut feature brandishes brash exuberance and stilted storytelling tropes in roughly equal measure, yielding a result that stimulates just as it cheapens itself dramatically.- The Hollywood Reporter
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
This intelligently made picture is artful but not arty, political without being didactic.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Like "In the Bedroom," Little Children, at well over two hours, is somewhat long for an intense, intimate drama, and arguments could run many ways concerning what could be tightened or excised.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Intelligently conceived and well- acted, this compact, straightforward drama about two ordinary people caught in the ongoing political crossfire packs enough punch to command audience interest, but won't light up critics or the B.O. to the extent achieved by the team's previous outings, "My Left Foot" and "In the Name of the Father."- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
A superbly wrought yarn set in the milieu of first-generation Russian mobsters in London that is simultaneously tough-minded and compassionate about the human condition, Eastern Promises instantly takes its place among David Cronenberg's very best films.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Opulently produced, fittingly enough, and quite entertaining as a surface ride through the up, down and somewhat up again life of one of the New Hollywood's most colorful characters.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Barry Levinson goes deep with Liberty Heights, and the result is a grand slam.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Like a trot around the track for the thoroughbreds involved, and one of the results is that it takes them far too long to get to the finish line.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Particle Fever succeeds on every level, but none more important than in making the normally intimidating and arcane world of genius-level physics at least conceptually comprehensible and even friendly to the lay viewer.- The Hollywood Reporter
- Posted Mar 4, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Those who see it at fests, and in carefully tailored specialized release, will be struck by the adroitness with which it addresses touchy issues, as well as by the outstanding performance of Ryan Gosling in the difficult leading role.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Never really addresses why aspects of the ratings don't work, proposes concrete improvements or compares the system to those in other countries. Still, picture's bracing, hilarious and out-there elements make it a landmark.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
The formula of ingredients is familiar and time-tested, to be sure, but some cocktails go down much better than others and McQuarrie and company have gotten theirs just right here.- The Hollywood Reporter
- Posted Jul 24, 2015
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Energetic, humorous and not too cloying, as well as the first Hollywood film in many years to warn of global cooling rather than warming, this tuneful toon upgrades what has been a lackluster year for big studio animated fare.- The Hollywood Reporter
- Posted Nov 6, 2013
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Sad, compelling documentary leaves a few key questions frustratingly unanswered, but the raw materials here are sufficiently bracing.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
An excellent novel about the Iraq War and its homefront fallout has been turned into a rather flat and disappointing film in The Yellow Birds.- The Hollywood Reporter
- Posted Jan 25, 2017
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
A resourceful, if rather hyperbolic documentary that devotes 90 minutes to analyzing one of the most famous scenes in film history.- The Hollywood Reporter
- Posted Oct 12, 2017
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
It is nonetheless imaginative in a highly familiar and ultimately tedious way.- The Hollywood Reporter
- Posted Sep 22, 2012
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Goes down like stiff medicine, leaving one feeling exhausted relief when it's finally over.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
The result makes you realize how few realistic and three-dimensional date movies have been made in an era of throbbing hook-up encounters and R-rated horny teen gross-outs.- The Hollywood Reporter
- Posted Jan 31, 2016
- Read full review
-
- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Staccato, Mamet-style dialogue exchanges, breathless pacing and remarkably healthy, well-fed-looking actors create a cumulative sense of artificiality that seriously undercuts the devastating effect clearly being sought.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
After examining the rarefied world of debutante socialites with wit and obvious expertise in “Metropolitan,” Stillman opens up his artistic universe a bit more here and displays an increased ease with filmmaking craf- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Basically the film consists of a bunch of techies in white shirts and glasses laboriously discussing their views, exchanges you get the feeling the filmmaker thought would come off as humorous.- The Hollywood Reporter
- Posted Apr 22, 2013
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
In the end, The Last King of Scotland is much better when it plays it cool and amusing than when it tries to ramp up outrage and indignation.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
It's juicy, fascinating stuff, well orchestrated by Carion and finely thesped -- especially by Kusturica.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
An all-star remake of the all-star original, Ocean's Eleven is a lark for everybody concerned, including the audience. Breezy, nonchalant and without a thing on its mind except having a little fun.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Chris Hemsworth and Daniel Bruhl excel as, respectively, British wild man and hedonist James Hunt and Austrian by-the-books tactician Niki Lauda.- The Hollywood Reporter
- Posted Sep 3, 2013
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Little kids will enjoy it all, while parents, when not checking their cell phones, will be thankful for the thoughtfully brief running time.- The Hollywood Reporter
- Posted Jul 2, 2011
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Beautifully made pic will spur newsy media coverage and possible consternation on both sides of the Israeli-Palestinian divide, but members of the general public will be glancing at their watches rather than having epiphanies about world peace.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
What neophyte scripterscripter Jeff Maguire's plot comes down to, however, is the cat-and-mouse game between Horrigan and Leary, and the craftiness and strategies involved on both sides, while not exactly ingenious, are tantalizing enough to compel interest.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
The lead performances have power, whereas pictorially the film is pretty rough and ordinary.- The Hollywood Reporter
- Posted Jul 18, 2016
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
For all its derivative poetics -- as many exteriors as possible were shot during or just after magic hour, a la Malick -- the film is a lovely thing to experience and possesses a measure of real power.- The Hollywood Reporter
- Posted Mar 6, 2013
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
This story of suffering and almost inadvertent humanitarianism is harrowing, engrossing, claustrophobic and sometimes literally hard to watch.- The Hollywood Reporter
- Posted Nov 29, 2011
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
It may be a specialist’s rarified sort of work now, but Gordon and Abel really know what they’re doing. It’s gentle and admittedly closer to a divertissement than a full-course comic meal. But no one else is doing anything like this at the moment.- The Hollywood Reporter
- Posted May 22, 2017
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
An absorbing, shades-of-gray look at home-front intrigue in Nazi-occupied Denmark during World War II. Ole Christian Madsen’s accomplished fourth feature plays out on a much larger canvas than he’s used previously and offers nuance and ambiguity in equal measure with violence and tragedy.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
A vigorous and involving salute to professionalism and being good at your job, Sully vividly portrays the physical realities and human elements in the dramatic safe landing of a crippled US Airways jet on the Hudson River on January 15, 2009.- The Hollywood Reporter
- Posted Sep 2, 2016
- Read full review
-
- Variety
-
- Todd McCarthy
This grandly conceived and executed epic tries to give equal weight to intimate human emotions and speculation about the cosmos, with mixed results, but is never less than engrossing, and sometimes more than that.- The Hollywood Reporter
- Posted Oct 27, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
With "Shampoo" and "American Gigolo" now distant memories, the time evidently seemed ripe for another Hollywood stud movie. Despite Ashton Kutcher’s believability as an older woman’s kept boy, Spread isn’t a patch on those previous films.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Represents a passable follow-up to the venerable Peter Pan story and mercifully, at 72 minutes, is exactly half the length of the last attempt at same, Steven Spielberg's lamentable "Hook."- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
A seductively structured and superbly acted suspenser that breathtakingly piles swindle upon scam without giving away the game until the very end.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
A faithful, powerful and superbly acted adaptation of Andre Dubus III's international bestseller.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
A tough-minded, bracingly blunt look at the sometimes debilitating cost of doing business that casts an unblinking eye on the physical, emotional and moral bottom line.- The Hollywood Reporter
- Posted Nov 6, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Executed to near perfection in all artistic departments, this superior adaptation of the perennial favorite novel will find its core public among girls , but should prove satisfying enough to a range of audiences to make it a solid performer for Warner Bros.' family entertainment banner.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
In his bigscreen feature debut, director and co-writer Jonathan Mostow displays real flair for visceral cinema while adroitly sidestepping many of the usual tripwires of this sort of film, particularly silly coincidences, stupid decisions on the part of characters with whom you're supposed to identify, and superheroics performed by ordinary people.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
This can't-take-your-eyes-off-it documentary feels like both a mea culpa and a purge of lingering ghosts.- The Hollywood Reporter
- Posted Mar 16, 2020
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Inspirational on the face of it, Clint Eastwood's film has a predictable trajectory, but every scene brims with surprising details that accumulate into a rich fabric of history, cultural impressions and emotion.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
This very New York tale is old-fashioned in good ways that have to do with solid storytelling, craftsmanship and emotional acuity.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
For geeks, action freaks and sensation-seeking teenage boys of all ages, the price of admission will provide a one-way ticket to hard-boiled heaven.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Just as somber as "The Good Shepherd," the most recent domestic spy drama, but more tightly focused, Breach absorbingly zeroes in on how the FBI nailed the most damaging turncoat in American history.- Variety
- Read full review