Todd McCarthy
Select another critic »For 1,835 reviews, this critic has graded:
-
49% higher than the average critic
-
2% same as the average critic
-
49% lower than the average critic
On average, this critic grades 2.5 points lower than other critics.
(0-100 point scale)
Todd McCarthy's Scores
- Movies
- TV
| Average review score: | 63 | |
|---|---|---|
| Highest review score: | Mulholland Dr. | |
| Lowest review score: | Showgirls | |
Score distribution:
-
Positive: 947 out of 1835
-
Mixed: 724 out of 1835
-
Negative: 164 out of 1835
1835
movie
reviews
- By Date
- By Critic Score
-
- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Every conceivable button is pushed to achieve rote satisfaction in young viewers, while any notion of creating tension and suspense is dutifully ignored. Not for a moment is actual peril considered as something worthy of a dramatic climax.- The Hollywood Reporter
- Posted Oct 15, 2019
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
This overwrought and egregiously self-serious thriller about the poisonous fruit borne of child abuse grows more ridiculous by the quarter-hour and is poised for a theatrical life span scarcely longer than that of its eponymous insect.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
What fun there is falls to Jackman, who gives the grand old man of pirate characters plenty of fresh and unusual wrinkles and emerges better than the others simply by virtue of playing a two-dimensional, rather than one-dimensional, figure.- The Hollywood Reporter
- Posted Sep 19, 2015
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Rarely has a picture been so self-consciously designed to be a culturally meaningful touchstone, and fallen so woefully short, as Southland Tales.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
As it thuds along from one wolf attack to the next, Catherine Hardwicke's first film since taking leave of Bella and her toothy friends adamantly refuses to provide any wit, humor or fun.- The Hollywood Reporter
- Posted Mar 9, 2011
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
The director doesn't display the spirit of a natural entertainer; while intellectual notions abound, he never grabs the audience by the hand to pull them into the tale emotionally.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
There’s no denying that The Tomorrow Man has a knockout ending. But is it worth sitting through the mundane, relatively uneventful film that precedes it? Few will think so.- The Hollywood Reporter
- Posted Feb 1, 2019
- Read full review
-
- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
On a moment to moment basis, however, picture continuously skirts very close to the ludicrous in its advanced-stage grimness and outre forms of torture foreplay.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Gus Van Sant’s sticky, gooey side — previously on display in the likes of Finding Forrester and especially in the 2011 Restless — oozes out once more in the woefully sentimental and maudlin The Sea of Trees.- The Hollywood Reporter
- Posted May 23, 2015
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Despite its scaldingly hot cast and formidable writer/director combination, The Counselor is simply not a very likable or gratifying film. In fact, it's a bummer.- The Hollywood Reporter
- Posted Oct 23, 2013
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Awful scripting and an unimaginative approach to re-imagining material's potential have left Universal with a theatrical in-and-outer on its hands.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
It’s a waste of a good cast as well as a serious trip-wire for McCarthy, who may know what’s best for her talents but, on the evidence, needs a deft-handed outsider to make sure she’s maximizing them.- The Hollywood Reporter
- Posted Jul 1, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Passably interesting psychological study of emotionally wounded characters until it commits dramatic suicide by showing its true colors as a tricked-up "Fatal Attraction" wannabe.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Conservatives score a few political points but aren't very funny in An American Carol, a cheesy spitball directed at the very large target of a Michael Moore-like filmmaker.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Has there ever been a Hollywood adaptation of a major novel as faithful and yet so misguided and downright strange as the three-part version of Ayn Rand's Atlas Shrugged that now comes to a conclusion with the third installment?- The Hollywood Reporter
- Posted Sep 12, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
This mangy, dimwitted gender switch on "The Last Detail" won't even have the benefit of trial before being sentenced to the video brig, since it's virtually there already.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
With a far-fetched script that might barely have passed muster at the B units in the old studio days, this Dimension release will command a certain up-front attention due to cast topliners.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Star-driven, high-minded claptrap that, fatally, can't even rig a rooting interest in its central love story.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Embalming the simple and simplistic yarn in an amber glow that is all but suffocating and banishing from it any traces of humor and spontaneity, director Scott Hicks serves up this treacly tale with absolutely no trace of self-consciousness about the material's cliches or simple-mindedness.- The Hollywood Reporter
- Posted Apr 17, 2012
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
A dreadfully dull, completely conventional story of a young wife's recuperation from being unceremoniously dumped, this is a by-the-numbers bit of emotional calculation without a single fresh, original or offbeat move in its system, apart from a nifty opening sequence.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Arriving eight years after the lame third installment in Dimension's profitable series, this seems like far too little way too late.- The Hollywood Reporter
- Posted Aug 19, 2011
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
An admirable idea in theory proves to be a real slog to sit through in Everyday.- The Hollywood Reporter
- Posted Nov 12, 2013
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
The dramatic trajectory is frightfully obvious, the characters tediously one-dimensional, the dialogue banal.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
What's actually up onscreen in this vaguely ambitious but tawdry melodrama falls into an in-between no-man's-land that endows it with no distinction whatsoever, a work lacking both style and insight into the netherworld it seeks to reveal.- The Hollywood Reporter
- Posted Sep 25, 2013
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Nine very good actors are wasted, if not embarrassed, by the thoroughly unconvincing shenanigans perpetrated by first-time writer-director Michael Clancy, while a tenth -- Zooey Deschanel -- somehow manages to float ethereally above it all with her dignity intact.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
The ‘70s recreation is reasonable -- there are plenty of vintage cars and pop tunes of the moment -- but the characters never register beyond the surfaces of the scenes despite being equipped with long-festering resentments and grudges.- The Hollywood Reporter
- Posted May 25, 2013
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
An indigestible gumbo of Southern Gothic ingredients seasoned with snake oil, biblical hash and thoroughly unpalatable spice.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Sure to turn off general viewers due to its emotional inaccessibility, multitude of narrative problems and preoccupation with a torture Web site.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
It's something you'd think only the crassest of Hollywood producers would come up with - injecting sex appeal into an event as ghastly at the Nanjing massacre - but it's an element central to The Flowers of War, a contrived and unpersuasive look at an oft-dramatized historical moment.- The Hollywood Reporter
- Posted Jan 24, 2012
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
The effects are snazzy, even if they pass by quite quickly, and there's enough going on to keep audiences watching, if not entirely happy. Smith, Theron and Bateman capably handle the main roles, but such is the skimpiness of the scenario that no further characters make any impact.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
A creaky haunted house that, once the big twist is revealed, makes very little sense at all.- The Hollywood Reporter
- Posted Mar 2, 2012
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Blandness and lack of daring characterize nearly every minute of the very long two hours, which are marked by a high degree of professionalism at the service of little content.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- The Hollywood Reporter
- Posted Mar 5, 2019
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Far from the renegade, boundary-pushing, sexually explicit sensation that its makers have been suggesting, The Canyons is a lame, one-dimensional and ultimately dreary look at peripheral Hollywood types not worth anyone's time either onscreen or in real life.- The Hollywood Reporter
- Posted Jul 28, 2013
- Read full review
-
- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
The submarine goes deep but the story never does in U-571, a good old-fashioned WWII picture that is exciting in only the most superficial way.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Aspiring transcendent love stories don't come much more claptrappy and unconvincing than Winter's Tale.- The Hollywood Reporter
- Posted Feb 12, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
The film is essentially nothing but little and ineffectual bits of recycled shtick with no sense of freshness of invention. And the women never bond in even the most rote or superficial way that's expected in this sort of claptrap.- The Hollywood Reporter
- Posted May 5, 2015
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Lars von Trier cuts a big fat art-film fart with Antichrist. As if deliberately courting critical abuse, the Danish bad boy densely packs this theological-psychological horror opus with grotesque, self-consciously provocative images.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Feels like a film from several years ago, one of the many made in the wake of "Pulp Fiction" that tried and failed to be as clever as its progenitor.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Once the revisionist frisson of a black Jesus, not to mention Mary, Joseph and Judas, has worn off, one is stuck with more mundane matters such as story dynamics, visual style and character verisimilitude, much to the misfortune of the audience.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Blandly internationalized, generically derivative, drained of any personality, edited as if by computer and bleached of the slightest hint of emotion other than a holiday card-like sympathy for children and allegedly cute animals, The Meg is a one hundred percent inorganic meal, something made from pre-tasted and then regurgitated ingredients.- The Hollywood Reporter
- Posted Aug 8, 2018
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
A film that seems drained of life and ideas rather than sustained by them.- The Hollywood Reporter
- Posted Mar 3, 2013
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Despite a couple of unconvincingly upbeat tacked-on moments at the end, Project X basically reads as nihilistic, as not believing in or standing for anything. Not even fun.- The Hollywood Reporter
- Posted Mar 1, 2012
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Just compare their superficiality to the complex characters in "From Here to Eternity" and what's missing here becomes terribly clear.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- The Hollywood Reporter
- Posted Jul 15, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Basically the film consists of a bunch of techies in white shirts and glasses laboriously discussing their views, exchanges you get the feeling the filmmaker thought would come off as humorous.- The Hollywood Reporter
- Posted Apr 22, 2013
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Begins as though the filmmakers imagine that they're making a daringly anti-p.c. serio-comedy, but long before it's over, the picture is wearing its bleeding liberal heart all over its sleeve.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- The Hollywood Reporter
- Posted Oct 16, 2013
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Misguided, diminished and dismally done in every way, this late-summer afterthought will richly earn the distinction of becoming the first Ben-Hur in any form to flop.- The Hollywood Reporter
- Posted Aug 17, 2016
- Read full review
-
- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
The story of a veritable devil who comes to test and destroy a family of faith, The King is a noxious film morally and an aggravating one dramatically.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
The most banal and indulgent of Gus Van Sant's periodic studies of troubled kids, this agonizingly treacly tale comes off like an indie version of "Love Story" except with worse music.- The Hollywood Reporter
- Posted Sep 12, 2011
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
This hokey thriller reps what one can only hope will be a one-of-a-kind hybrid between a World War II actioner and a ghost story outfitted with innumerable false-alarm shock cuts and shot with enough colored lights and filters to delight Baz Luhrmann.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
There is no one to become attached to in The Four Feathers, no interest or sympathies appealed to or engaged.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Another tale of out-of-it working-class men cooking up a harebrained scheme to improve their lot in life.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
It’s impossible to buy into the film’s plea to be taken seriously at the end, just as the upbeat finale feels false.- The Hollywood Reporter
- Posted Jul 8, 2013
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
A noxious little tale of Wall Street types whose amorality knows no limit, Rick takes smarmy knowingness to ludicrous extremes.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Garishly unattractive to look at and lacking the spirit that made Wonder Woman, which came out five months ago, the most engaging of Warner Bros.' DC Comics-derived extravaganzas to date, this hodgepodge throws a bunch of superheroes into a mix that neither congeals nor particularly makes you want to see more of them in future. Plainly put, it's simply not fun.- The Hollywood Reporter
- Posted Nov 14, 2017
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
This butterfly just doesn't fly. Icy, surprisingly conventional and never truly convincing.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Dramatically and philosophically void and unprovocative on the grand scale of apocalyptic speculative fiction, this low-budget indie is somber and dreary on a moment-to-moment basis and leaves its talented cast stranded with few opportunities to alleviate the sense of stasis.- The Hollywood Reporter
- Read full review
-
- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Unfortunately, John Moore has directed these sequences in a way that makes the incidents look so far-fetched and essentially unsurvivable that you can only laugh.- The Hollywood Reporter
- Posted Feb 13, 2013
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Universal’s attempt to find gold by bringing to new life one of the mustier items in its vaults is pure hokum and scarcely of the first order.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Robin Williams and Billy Crystal can each provoke a lot more laughs in a minute of standup than they jointly manage during the entire running time of Fathers' Day.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
This low-rent, R-rated "Rush Hour"-ish comic caper could have been several notches better with more charismatic leads and some dialogue upgrades but still would have felt like a genre hand-me-down.- The Hollywood Reporter
- Posted Mar 30, 2011
- Read full review
-
- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
This is one of those high-concept pictures with a big windup and weak delivery.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
The way the picture dwells almost exclusively on cinematically exploitable elements -- gangbanger crime, prostitution, honor killing, terrorism paranoia -- gives it a sordid patina that even the classy, able thesps can't offset.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Homefront is sufficiently silly and low-down to be entertaining on a certain marginal level, but it wouldn't appear that those involved, with the possible exception of Franco, approached this with the idea that they might be making good trash; it looks too elaborate and costly for that and the script exhibits no self-aware humor.- The Hollywood Reporter
- Posted Nov 21, 2013
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Never comes close to making the case that its subject is worthy of the viewer's interest.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Just as the basic plot points are hard to swallow, even the most rudimentary aspects of the characters' interactions feel forced, artificial and unspontaneous.- The Hollywood Reporter
- Posted Apr 6, 2015
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
With unappealing one-note characters, retread concepts and implausible motivations, Chappie is a further downward step for director Neill Blomkamp.- The Hollywood Reporter
- Posted Mar 4, 2015
- Read full review
-
- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Like a long fishing day without a bite, Serenity invites impatience rather than excited anticipation, and the eventual payoff provokes a big “huh?”- The Hollywood Reporter
- Posted Jan 24, 2019
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Action scenes are accumulated as if mandated by a stop-watch and almost invariably seem like warmed-over versions of stuff we've seen before, in Terminator entries and elsewhere.- The Hollywood Reporter
- Posted Jun 24, 2015
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Traditionalists and older viewers in general will scoff, while pop culture addicts will no doubt go with the flow.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Cronenberg is a master of creating and sustaining a mood of insinuating cool and dark allure, but while the director remains firmly behind the wheel for the first hour or so, he cracks up toward the end with sequences that send the film and the audience into a ditch.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
An uncommonly dour and even grim action thriller that globetrots as diversely as a James Bond film but offers a very limited view politically, emotionally and dramatically.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
An exercise in improv-derived filmmaking that simply proves once again that there's no substitute for a good script.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Crude, repetitive and rigorously single-minded, the popular actor’s writing and directing debut lays it all on a bit thick, as the few points the film has to make are underscored time and time again.- The Hollywood Reporter
- Posted Apr 11, 2013
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Has the distinction of being a major motion picture that's far less imaginative, and quite a bit more stupid, than the interactive game it's based on.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Overall, pic’s conception of the future isn’t terribly original or inventive, and viewers not into the head trip of bigscreen computer graphics will want to download a lot sooner than Johnny does.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
An aggravating romance that runs only 78 minutes but ends not a moment too soon.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Screechily abrasive and sorely lacking in elements that engage the imagination.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Director Jon Turteltaub's insistence upon hammering every point home with giant closeups and relentless musical underlining makes this insufferably cloying and sickly sweet.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Roman Coppola's first film has sympathetic aims but is distressingly lacking in flair, style, wit or fun.- Variety
- Read full review
-
- Todd McCarthy
Guy Ritchie shoots a blank with Revolver, which replays the low-life criminal shtick from his first two features with an ill-advised overlay of pretension. The action, attitude and wise-guy talk all feel moldy this time around.- Variety
- Read full review