Scott Tobias
Select another critic »For 1,915 reviews, this critic has graded:
-
46% higher than the average critic
-
3% same as the average critic
-
51% lower than the average critic
On average, this critic grades 3.9 points lower than other critics.
(0-100 point scale)
Scott Tobias' Scores
- Movies
- TV
| Average review score: | 62 | |
|---|---|---|
| Highest review score: | Sansho the Bailiff | |
| Lowest review score: | AVPR: Aliens vs Predator - Requiem | |
Score distribution:
-
Positive: 975 out of 1915
-
Mixed: 723 out of 1915
-
Negative: 217 out of 1915
1915
movie
reviews
- By Date
- By Critic Score
-
- Scott Tobias
Produced in partnership with YouTube and distributed by National Geographic Films, the documentary Life in a Day is offspring with the worst genetic traits of both: narcissism on a global scale, speckled with pretty pictures. In a world without books or magazines, this is the movie people would watch in the waiting room at the dentist's office.- NPR
- Posted Jul 29, 2011
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
The indie rom-com/sitcom L!fe Happens is a case study in how bad movies can turn an ordinary, relatable situation into a grotesque distortion with only a passing resemblance to the way actual human beings live and interact with each other.- The A.V. Club
- Posted Apr 11, 2012
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
With Cop Out, Smith works from a script other than his own for the first time--this one penned by siblings Mark and Robb Cullen--but his slack direction siphons the energy out of this tongue-in-cheek throwback to ’80s mismatched-buddy comedies.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Taken together, these stories are a symphony of inconsequentiality, drained of tension and purpose until all that remains is a vague sense of collective ennui.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Few of the scenes in The Perfect Game feel authentic, but the ones in Monterrey are especially lacking in flavor.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
No doubt the list of talent involved in this remake sounded great, but the project hasn't been thought through as anything more than an arch exercise in style. And even in that trifling end, it fails utterly.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
The cutaways to this cop-on-the-edge plot are jarring and lacking in conviction, and when the whole tortured mess comes together in a twist-filled third act, Safe Haven becomes a full-blown calamity.- The A.V. Club
- Posted Feb 13, 2013
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
It's now a straight-up crime and retribution flick, capped off by the dumbest wolf-feeding coda a 13-year-old ever dreamed up.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
The emotions at play in Bella are no doubt heartfelt--and must have resonated with a few hundred people, anyway--but they're so cut-and-dried that the mawkish script virtually writes itself.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
It takes guts to remake what many believe to be Hitchcock's first masterpiece, but what Ondaatje's done with The Lodger could not be mistaken for ambition.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Thornton is one of America's finest actors, but after this, "Bad News Bears," and "School For Scoundrels," his run of loveably irascible authority-figure roles should probably come to a close. He's kicked around one child too many.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
The film is curiously sterile and lifeless, hardly the stuff of revolution. It feels more like an ideologically reversed "Tucker: The Man And His Dream," written and performed by robots.- The A.V. Club
- Posted Apr 16, 2011
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
If there were a shred of sincerity to its straight-faced exposé of African strife, the film would be easier to forgive, but since it's really just a cheap horror-thriller about an ancient predator, the austere tone does it no favors.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Red Dawn without the jingoism is like a pie without the filling - it collapses into splintered mush.- The A.V. Club
- Posted Nov 21, 2012
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Nowrasteh constantly overplays his hand, not realizing that some horrors speak for themselves.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Writer-director Mary Harron, a supremely intelligent adaptor who did wonders with the screen version of Bret Easton Ellis' "American Psycho," simply doesn't have the chops to give this story the florid kick it needs.- The A.V. Club
- Posted Apr 18, 2012
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Though he labors endlessly to account for her behavior, which is explained away by flashbacks to her decadent parents and a glamorous mother-figure played under Vaseline lens by an uncredited Sandra Bullock, Bacon fails to make her seem human.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Disney has once again constructed a digital environment out of cutting-edge special effects, only this time, it isn't merely silly; it's as dry and talky as a PBS panel show.- The A.V. Club
- Posted Dec 16, 2010
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Spacey has made a career out of projecting the smarmy elitism of the powerful, but Casino Jack is so painfully clunky that he gets dragged down along with it.- The A.V. Club
- Posted Dec 16, 2010
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
A film so utterly lacking in conviction, it needs a 25-year-old Tom Cruise vehicle just to keep its spine straight.- The A.V. Club
- Posted Jun 16, 2011
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
These are all legitimate concerns, which Navarro supports with testimony from economists, politicians, union leaders, and businesspeople, but they're undermined at every point by a sky-is-falling hysteria that registers as white noise. It's the documentary equivalent of a raving street-corner derelict.- The A.V. Club
- Posted Aug 22, 2012
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Krasinski knows how to play off Williams--his pained looks are all too appropriate in the face of Williams' desperate shtick--but it's disillusioning to see him here, because he seems too smart for this film.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
It's loud, relentless, and difficult to endure, capturing the experience of ground-level alien warfare with woeful verisimilitude.- The A.V. Club
- Posted Mar 10, 2011
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Director Rob Whitehair doesn't do much to complicate what's essentially a promotional featurette for Wiede and Tucker's Wild Sentry organization, presenting the anti-wolf faction as rabid, irrational, and extreme. But he can't be blamed for wanting to stoke the drama a little: Without it, True Wolf would be a lesson in the care and feeding of an exotic pet.- The A.V. Club
- Posted Aug 15, 2012
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Arriving late to the scene, Another Gay Movie coughs up the same awkward gags about coming of age via false starts and sexual humiliation, only the genuine sweetness and camaraderie that made the first "Pie" movie bearable has been replaced by glib self-awareness.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
The film looks to do for reflective surfaces what "Amityville 4" did for killer lamps.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
The characters in The Burning Plain are so narrowly defined by tragedy that they reveal no other facets of humanity.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Dane Cook plays a smug jerk in the dismal comedy My Best Friend's Girl. Strike that: He's only ACTING like a smug jerk.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
As the plot unfolds, brick by brick, the structure starts to wobble until it finally collapses into unintentional comedy.- The A.V. Club
- Posted Jan 25, 2012
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Bratt’s character is stuck in old ways of thinking, and the movie, for all its well-meaning social intent, is right there with him.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Features a running gag about a little boy in the midst of potty training who doesn’t always go where it’s appropriate. In a nutshell, that subplot explains everything that’s wrong about the film.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Stiller's continued efforts to court the broadest possible audience has taken the edge off his comedy. Whenever he shares screen time with Williams, it looks like the grim future he's mapping out for himself.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
The whole thing is rigged for crowd-pleasing payoffs - a bit about chocolate pie gets more mileage than a Prius - and those payoffs are about honoring white viewers for not being horrible racists. Kudos to them.- The A.V. Club
- Posted Aug 10, 2011
- Read full review
-
- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
With minimal flare and maximal gore, Boll simply delivers the turgid drama and incompetently staged action sequences that have made him the unstoppable Big Boss of the gaming community.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
It's a measure of the film's lack of imagination that Morris Chestnut, as an aspiring songwriter logging time as a mall Santa, can't even think of a good fake occupation.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Monte Carlo finally resolves itself in a farcical climax that at least shows a little energy, but it isn't enough to overcome the discomfiting tensions and indifferent formula filmmaking that plagues nearly every scene.- The A.V. Club
- Posted Jun 30, 2011
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Too often, Formula 51 fails to differentiate between gleeful excess and white noise.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
At some point in the production process, co-writer/director Greg McLean must have believed he was making John Cassavetes’ “Poltergeist,” but this odd fusion of psychodrama and supernatural hokum gets away from him.- Variety
- Posted May 17, 2016
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
The action never stops once the first car bomb is triggered, but the second half of London Has Fallen takes place mostly in the dark, where nobody can see the budget.- Village Voice
- Posted Mar 2, 2016
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Alejandro González Iñárritu is a pretentious fraud, but it’s taken some time to understand the precise nature of his fraudulence.- The Dissolve
- Posted Oct 16, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Afternoon Delight is one of those bad films that seem to drift further and further away from a recognizable reality the more we get to know it.- The Dissolve
- Posted Aug 29, 2013
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
The impression left by Harmontown is that the podcast and the tour are feeding the beast, worsening a pathology that casts him as the “mayor” of whatever stage he happens to be occupying at the moment.- The Dissolve
- Posted Sep 29, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Premature isn’t nearly as inventive and witty as Groundhog Day or Edge Of Tomorrow about finding fresh angles on repeating events, and it overestimates how much the audience might care about the self-improvement of a bland, clueless douchebag.- The Dissolve
- Posted Jul 1, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
In reviving the beloved Disney property, Robinson attempts to resuscitate the fast-motion shots and sub-Three Stooges physical comedy of classic Herbie, but the new model seems distantly related to the innocent, peppy little car of old.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Though Parker’s assured performance, along with the enchanting backdrop, eases the action toward harmless gentility, they’re hijacked by a plot that mimics the plate-spinning business of classic screwball, but moves at agonizing half-speed.- Variety
- Posted Feb 5, 2016
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Basically a prim, desexualized "Carrie," told from the prom date's perspective and featuring Peter Coyote in the Piper Laurie role.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Though dumber than a box of rocks, Saw forges ahead with the kind of conviction and energy that will keep bad-cinema junkies sitting bolt upright.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Impossible to swallow as truth, this Rambo treatment is equally hard to enjoy as escapism.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Brill’s point that there should be no such thing as a “walk of shame” is a good one, but he lacks the conviction to see it through honestly—or humorously.- The Dissolve
- Posted May 3, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Gomez-Rejon has erected a gleaming shrine to adolescent narcissism.- The Dissolve
- Posted Jun 9, 2015
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
There are reasons why everyone on screen looks as unhappy as they do, but Llosa puts viewers in a place where they can’t understand precisely why, so the only choice is to sit there marinating in misery and boredom.- The Dissolve
- Posted May 21, 2015
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
All would be forgiven if director Brian A. Miller were the next John Woo, but the shootouts and car chases call to mind adjectives like “requisite” and “obligatory,” and the ready-made New Orleans ambience is nonexistent, probably for budgetary reasons.- The Dissolve
- Posted Aug 22, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
The trouble with Black Or White is that it feels reverse-engineered, as if Binder wanted to deliver one big statement about race, and rigged an entire movie to make that possible.- The Dissolve
- Posted Jan 29, 2015
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
De Niro and Murphy are visibly uncomfortable with each other. Their improvisation seems chaotic and mismanaged, and the movie follows in kind.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Variety
- Posted Apr 23, 2018
- Read full review
-
- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Channels Toback in his purest form, which will probably be a treat for auteurists and a headache for just about everyone else.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Bad Boys II is the rare case in which escapism involves leaving the theater.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Monahan isn’t required to satisfy bloodlust or to pay off conventional plot points, even if his screenplay for “The Departed” displayed an abundant talent for doing so. But he assumes too much in believing that the audience will connect in any way with a sour, prickly narcissist who’s trapped in the gilded cage of wealth and fame.- Variety
- Posted Jan 20, 2016
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
In the absence of sincerity, Cletis Tout creates a vacuum that flushes out the entire story, leaving nothing but its own hollow cleverness.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Bruce McDonald’s Hellions is an unpleasant muddle of the visceral and the abstract.- Variety
- Posted Sep 13, 2015
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
While discipline and self-control certainly figure into Ladouceur’s teachings, there’s also a passion and drive that’s totally absent from Caviezel’s performance. It’s not that the film needs any more goosing—it’s broad and shameless even by inspirational-sports-movie standards—but its basic lack of plausibility starts with him.- The Dissolve
- Posted Aug 21, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Virtually nothing happens in the film that enhances viewers’ understanding of the situation. Winterbottom and company merely survey the scene, kick around a few half-assed moments of atmosphere and suspense, shrug their shoulders, and pack it in for the night.- The Dissolve
- Posted Jun 18, 2015
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Dracula Untold boldly attempts to retell the Dracula origin story by sinking its teeth into Bram Stoker’s novel and draining it of all the passion, sensuality, and ambience that have seduced readers and moviegoers since the turn of the 20th century.- The Dissolve
- Posted Oct 8, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
The only redeeming moments come from Walken, whose assured, effortless screen presence stands out from his faceless co-stars. Taped to a leather chair and bleeding profusely from a severed finger, he's still the most powerful person in the room.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Opens with its snazziest effects sequences and gets cheaper from there, as if studio executives were constantly scaling back the budget as the filmmakers went along.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
The movie offers more of the same, only more: more T&A, more conspicuous consumption, more cameos, more Jeremy Piven yelling, and significantly more Mark Cuban than anyone outside the city of Dallas needs to see.- The Dissolve
- Posted Jun 1, 2015
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
It reduces a large cast to an unwieldy collection of simpletons and caricatures.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
At least White summons the camp energy that Lake Placid is fecklessly seeking.- The Dissolve
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Everly tries to patch together a profile out of borrowed news clips and shoddy videography. In the process, Frank's charisma and force never emerge.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Joseph winds up with an disorganized mishmash of visual gimmicks, empty exoticism, and soundbites worthy of “This is Spinal Tap.” Great music and some dynamic, up-close concert footage gives it the occasional life, but The Reflektor Tapes will appeal to Arcade Fire devotees only and even their patience might be tested.- Variety
- Posted Sep 22, 2015
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Between the loaded conversations and metaphors, and the phony overlay of a children's fairy tale, The Playroom can't stop telegraphing themes and interpreting itself. There's nothing left for the audience to do.- NPR
- Posted Feb 8, 2013
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
At a minimum, a parody should be funnier than the film it’s sending up, but Fifty Shades of Black, a quick-and-dirty riff on last year’s S&M romance “Fifty Shades of Grey,” falls a laugh or two short of even that low standard.- Variety
- Posted Jan 29, 2016
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
An aggressive black comedy that seeks to satisfy a bloodlust already quelled many times over.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Nothing is more dangerous than a sequel to a wildly successful awful movie, because the artisans involved have to preserve the franchise, which means honoring the original formula as if it were a cure for cancer.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Free Birds feels like Hollywood brining small children for the blockbusters they’ll pay to see when they’re older. It’s littered with quips, but the film puts a premium on loud, effects-driven action that mistakes nonstop intensity for cartoony entertainment.- The Dissolve
- Posted Oct 30, 2013
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Even allowing The Identical its premise, the reframing of the Elvis myth as a wholesome example of following God’s plan is not as inspirational as the film seems to believe. Rock fantasies are rarely this milquetoast.- The Dissolve
- Posted Sep 4, 2014
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Sorting through the shards of the Ottoman Empire requires a historical complexity that eludes Crowe, who flattens the landscape into bromides on family and country, and the hard-won glories of being Russell Crowe. His on-screen persona could stand to be as modest as his filmmaking abilities.- The Dissolve
- Posted Apr 23, 2015
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Though serviceable as a primer on Soviet history under Stalin, the film's sloppy assemblage of dull interviews and stock footage never comes close to illuminating a life that the Russian people have long cherished as a precious enigma.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Perhaps it was deliberate strategy on the part of McCann and his screenwriter, Anthony Di Pietro, to neutralize the politics of a mass killing and focus more on the psychic stress that triggered it. But even if that was the case, it doesn’t make the film any less crushingly banal.- The Dissolve
- Posted Feb 12, 2015
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
There's no forgiving the home-movie slackness of Greendale for its numbing dearth of imagination.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
LaPaglia brings the hero into a world of greed and compromised values, but his fork-tongued monologues aren't remotely seductive, which makes the ending a foregone conclusion.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
This Arthur cravenly turns Susan into a monstrous status-seeker, making her less of a human being and thus much easier for Arthur to trample over in securing a meaningful adult relationship.- NPR
- Posted Apr 7, 2011
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
A major disappointment that lacks the courage to follow through on its premise's themes.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
In Dead Or Alive: Final, Miike trades his grimly comic, sex-and-blood insignia for a self-consciously wacky conflation of Hong Kong action cinema and Japanese anime, with a little cheap science fiction tossed in for good measure.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Wiig’s new comedy sulks limply along with her, unable to bring the kind of energy that might complement her tendency to underplay every scene.- The Dissolve
- Posted Jul 17, 2013
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Between the performances in the bedroom and on stage, 9 Songs gives off plenty of heat, but the whole project seems half-thought-out and hastily arranged, hampered by butt-ugly DV photography that turn skin tones grimy and make the Brixton scenes look as high-grain as a bowl of Mueslix.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Lawrence clamors for the spotlight. If he ever found a way to make desperation look like charisma, he'd be the funniest man in America.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Stevens wants to honor the living legends who have miraculously agreed to appear in his movie, but after spending a full hour treating their characters like cartoons, the about-face into heartfelt slop lacks the necessary gravitas.- NPR
- Posted Jan 31, 2013
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
It couldn’t be a simpler, more workable premise for a good B-movie, but the amount of effort put into making it fast and edgy is inversely proportional to the scant thrills it yields.- The Dissolve
- Posted Aug 28, 2013
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Chadha doesn't seem at home with either Austen or Bollywood, and her ambitions far exceed her competence in the song-and-dance numbers, which are a clutter of stiff choreography and silly original lyrics.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
As it stands, there are only enough comic ideas here, most of them bad ones, to reach 82 minutes; the other 11 are taken up by a postscript scene, a blooper, and closing credits that move, in the words of Scarlett O’Hara, as slow as molasses in January.- Variety
- Posted May 12, 2016
- Read full review
-
- Scott Tobias
Ritchie has said that it takes several viewings to fully understand what's going on in Revolver, but once will be enough for most to agree to take his word for it.- The A.V. Club
- Read full review
-
- The A.V. Club
- Read full review