Robert K. Elder
Select another critic »For 245 reviews, this critic has graded:
-
66% higher than the average critic
-
2% same as the average critic
-
32% lower than the average critic
On average, this critic grades 5.1 points lower than other critics.
(0-100 point scale)
Robert K. Elder's Scores
- Movies
- TV
| Average review score: | 60 | |
|---|---|---|
| Highest review score: | The 39 Steps | |
| Lowest review score: | The Devil's Rejects | |
Score distribution:
-
Positive: 141 out of 245
-
Mixed: 55 out of 245
-
Negative: 49 out of 245
245
movie
reviews
- By Date
- By Critic Score
-
- Robert K. Elder
Serves as both an homage to and shameless thief of its influences. The result: a sprawling, deformed, undisciplined piece of cinema that hobbles along on weak, genre-splicing tactics.- Chicago Tribune
- Read full review
-
- Robert K. Elder
Although his is not a perfect film, Tollin employs his soap-opera dialogue and aim-for-the-solar-plexus message quite unapologetically.- Chicago Tribune
- Read full review
-
- Robert K. Elder
Plot doesn't matter much here, as Scary Movie 3 exists solely to reference and lampoon other movies, in this case "The Ring," "Signs " and "8 Mile."- Chicago Tribune
- Read full review
-
- Robert K. Elder
More effort could have been made to fully flesh out the international perspective on this "people's president," but as a play-by-play look at a modern coup, it's an amazing, insightful film.- Chicago Tribune
- Read full review
-
- Chicago Tribune
- Read full review
-
- Robert K. Elder
As psychological drama, In My Skin falls short. But as pure horror, it's unforgettable.- Chicago Tribune
- Read full review
-
- Robert K. Elder
The words "Welcome foolish mortals" open Walt Disney Pictures' The Haunted Mansion, a movie based on Disneyland and Walt Disney World's classic theme park attractions. The foolish mortals, of course, would be those who pay $9 a ticket at the door.- Chicago Tribune
- Read full review
-
- Robert K. Elder
Epidemic will never be confused with von Trier's great films. But it is an intriguing introduction to his later cinematic obsessions.- Chicago Tribune
- Read full review
-
- Robert K. Elder
As an intentionally campy film, Girls Will Be Girls dips a cinematic toe into shark-infested waters. Not only must it operate on several levels-making us care for deeply flawed characters and laugh at their bitter lashings-it also has to carry a cohesive story arc. On this count, Girls Will Be Girls fizzles a bit.- Chicago Tribune
- Read full review
-
- Robert K. Elder
Has the shelf life of a dented milk carton. Pop-culture movies in general age rapidly due to ever-changing slang and fashions.- Chicago Tribune
- Read full review
-
- Robert K. Elder
Errol Flynn deifies Gen. George Armstrong Custer in a silly though well-directed biopic. [25 May 2001, p.C1]- Chicago Tribune
-
- Robert K. Elder
Isn't without charm, or laughs. Director Shawn Levy's film features some of the best child actor casting since "The Little Rascals."- Chicago Tribune
- Read full review
-
- Robert K. Elder
As it turns out, "Liberty," a likable, light-as-air road comedy, is a much better movie than its sour-pun title.- Chicago Tribune
- Read full review
-
- Robert K. Elder
First-time director Timothy Bjorklund, who also shepherded Teacher's Pet on television, conducts some inventive, devilish sequences.- Chicago Tribune
- Read full review
-
- Robert K. Elder
So well cast and well captured is Touching the Void that it suspends disbelief, making us feel as if we're actually watching Simpson's own icy version of Dante's "Inferno."- Chicago Tribune
- Read full review
-
- Chicago Tribune
- Read full review
-
- Robert K. Elder
Like all B-movies (or in this case, pseudo B-movies), "Skeleton" contains sparkling moments of promise and camp performance.- Chicago Tribune
- Read full review
-
- Robert K. Elder
While some pedestrian camerawork and spotty acting from supporting players deflate Love Object, it has enough juice - and a surprising twist - to keep fans of the slow-burn horror genre enthralled.- Chicago Tribune
- Read full review
-
- Robert K. Elder
Minor but irresistible MGM musical capturing '20s college life through the prism of the jivin' '40s era. [18 Jan 2008, p.C2]- Chicago Tribune
-
- Robert K. Elder
It breaks director Billy Wilder's most important movie commandment: Thou Shall Not Bore. It's just not funny.- Chicago Tribune
- Read full review
-
- Robert K. Elder
Finally, a teen sex comedy that's funnier than both its trailer and its outtakes. More important, Eurotrip -- with its laser-guided sex toys and infectious theme song, "Scotty Doesn't Know" -- just might be the best comedy so far this year.- Chicago Tribune
- Read full review
-
- Robert K. Elder
An actor-turned-director, Stuhr appeared in many of Kieslowski's films and their partnership and friendship produced some stunning work. The Big Animal memorializes a complex man and his deceptively simple work, by a friend and colleague in a fitting tribute.- Chicago Tribune
- Read full review
-
- Robert K. Elder
The notion that stories are the lies that tell the truth isn't new -- even Shakespeare knew that -- but the central conceit of "let's save lives by putting on a play" seems not only artificial, but also hollow.- Chicago Tribune
- Read full review
-
- Chicago Tribune
- Read full review
-
- Chicago Tribune
- Read full review
-
- Robert K. Elder
Caruso, who showed flair in the Val Kilmer vehicle "The Salton Sea," has a penchant for the dark side. In this case, it's the plodding, predictable ZIP code of the dark side.- Chicago Tribune
- Read full review
-
- Robert K. Elder
Is it a political movie? Yes. A movie with strong ideas and issues? Yes. But propaganda with its heart in the right place is still propaganda, and seldom easy to watch.- Chicago Tribune
- Read full review
-
- Robert K. Elder
In his thoughtfully paced, well-acted film, Hoge doesn't set out to solve the "why" of Leland's ghastly crime. He's more interested in examining the reason why society needs to create and interpret a reason for horror.- Chicago Tribune
- Read full review
-
- Robert K. Elder
The movie's computer-generated castles, magic visuals and sloppy effects echo a low-budget fantasy movie on cable. It's glossy, shiny candy that tastes oddly familiar yet lacks sugary punch.- Chicago Tribune
- Read full review
-
- Chicago Tribune
- Read full review
-
- Robert K. Elder
In a case study of how to screw up a simple, powerful revenge story, director Jonathan Hensleigh punishes audiences with an unbearably sluggish action movie that requires the word "action" to be placed in quotes.- Chicago Tribune
- Read full review
-
- Robert K. Elder
To call this movie a dog would also be an insult to canines, so let's just say Scooby-Doo 2 is a Scooby-Don't.- Chicago Tribune
- Read full review
-
- Robert K. Elder
Downright scary in some places, Godsend might be more potent if it wasn't watered down by religious trope predictability.- Chicago Tribune
- Read full review
-
- Robert K. Elder
Though not a perfect comedy, it manages to be quite often laugh-out-loud funny. The film's strong cast, including scene-stealing "SNL"er Tim Meadows as the school principal, also helps smooth out most of the rough edges.- Chicago Tribune
- Read full review
-
- Robert K. Elder
Simply photographed and well acted, The Mudge Boy captures "Deliverance"-level disturbing images as it takes an unsentimental approach to its characters.- Chicago Tribune
- Read full review
-
- Robert K. Elder
A Foreign Affair's flaws make it even more of an enigma, as graceless as it is endearing.- Chicago Tribune
- Read full review
-
- Robert K. Elder
There's much to love about this "Rocky" on horseback, and those laughable blemishes just fold into jokes that Helgeland likely intends audiences to laugh at.- Chicago Tribune
- Read full review
-
- Robert K. Elder
Whatever the film lacks in presentation, it makes up for in laughs and ensemble performances that sing.- Chicago Tribune
- Read full review
-
- Robert K. Elder
Released in theaters five years after its 1999 Sundance Film Festival premiere, Kalem's film is too precious, too self-conscious and far too enamored with itself to ever have any kind of genuine emotional truth.- Chicago Tribune
- Read full review
-
- Robert K. Elder
It's a pitch-black, Grimm Brothers-style fable that enchants, frustrates and ultimately dares you to love it. Even if you don't, you'll be riveted.- Chicago Tribune
- Read full review
-
- Robert K. Elder
Ultimately, Stateside ends up a diluted, scattered drama--less than the sum of its parts, but with an impressive cameo list.- Chicago Tribune
- Read full review
-
- Robert K. Elder
The cinematic Garfield: The Movie feels like an 82-minute commercial for Garfield, The Brand rather than cinematic dumb fun.- Chicago Tribune
- Read full review
-
- Robert K. Elder
As a document of his history, it's breathtaking, inspiring stuff. As an overlong documentary, it still manages to be inspiring, but also an uphill viewing experience.- Chicago Tribune
- Read full review
-
- Robert K. Elder
It's not revolutionary filmmaking. But Seducing Doctor Lewis sails by on charm and confident character acting, even if it's navigating well-charted waters.- Chicago Tribune
- Read full review
-
- Robert K. Elder
A counterintuitive, riveting documentary so honest that it will either become a rock movie classic or a severe embarrassment for the heavy metal band.- Chicago Tribune
- Read full review