Maitland McDonagh
Select another critic »For 2,280 reviews, this critic has graded:
-
43% higher than the average critic
-
4% same as the average critic
-
53% lower than the average critic
On average, this critic grades 10.7 points lower than other critics.
(0-100 point scale)
Maitland McDonagh's Scores
- Movies
- TV
| Average review score: | 55 | |
|---|---|---|
| Highest review score: | Devil in a Blue Dress | |
| Lowest review score: | The Hottie & the Nottie | |
Score distribution:
-
Positive: 738 out of 2280
-
Mixed: 1,265 out of 2280
-
Negative: 277 out of 2280
2280
movie
reviews
-
- Maitland McDonagh
Del Toro's film ranks with the best examinations of children's inner lives, but be warned: Its haunting insights are best left to adults.- TV Guide Magazine
- Read full review
-
- Maitland McDonagh
The material is familiar, and doesn't have anything new to say about the ways men and women wound each other.- TV Guide Magazine
- Read full review
-
- Maitland McDonagh
The film satisfies on both visceral and emotional levels.- TV Guide Magazine
- Read full review
-
- Maitland McDonagh
Despite its length, the film only starts feeling as long at the end -- or, more correctly, ends. Serious fans of the novels will be prepared for the serial codicils, but the uninitiated are likely to think the film is over several times before it actually is.- TV Guide Magazine
- Read full review
-
- Maitland McDonagh
Contains several profanely amusing moments, but they don't add up to much.- TV Guide Magazine
- Read full review
-
- Maitland McDonagh
Ambitious, deeply flawed and studded with sequences that achieve pure, majestic greatness.- TV Guide Magazine
- Read full review
-
- TV Guide Magazine
- Read full review
-
- Maitland McDonagh
He (Allen) seems to have forgotten that comedy is all about timing, letting individual scenes meander -- often to accommodate his own stammering monologues -- and giving viewers far too much downtime in which to consider the staleness of many of the film's gags.- TV Guide Magazine
- Read full review
-
- Maitland McDonagh
It's a mixed blessing, in some ways even richer and more atmospheric than the original version, in others attenuated and logy.- TV Guide Magazine
- Read full review
-
- Maitland McDonagh
Above all, Jackson evokes an almost palpable sense of the will to power trapped within the ring. Without this evocation of the ring's insidious ability to sniff out the potential for corruption and capitalize on it, the entire enterprise would be precious drivel.- TV Guide Magazine
- Read full review
-
- Maitland McDonagh
Director Curtis Hanson keeps the hugely complicated story zooming along the boulevard of broken dreams without losing sight of the details that make the trip worthwhile.- TV Guide Magazine
- Read full review
-
- TV Guide Magazine
- Read full review
-
- Maitland McDonagh
Piercing, sweetly melancholy and acted with a breathtaking eye for nuance.- TV Guide Magazine
- Read full review
-
- Maitland McDonagh
The movie's greatest strength lies in phenomenal performances that reach from the leads right down to the smallest supporting roles.- TV Guide Magazine
- Read full review
-
- Maitland McDonagh
A stale rehash of Woody Allen-style "he's a neurotic Jew, she's a flaky shiksa" gags.- TV Guide Magazine
- Read full review
-
- TV Guide Magazine
- Read full review
-
- Maitland McDonagh
Pekar's autobiographical chronicle of day-to-day banality is a rich, if dingy, tapestry of ordinary life in all its infinite, homely peculiarity, which filmmakers Sheri Springer Berman and Robert Pulcini bring to uniquely eccentric life.- TV Guide Magazine
- Read full review
-
- TV Guide Magazine
- Read full review
-
- Maitland McDonagh
A loving, gently funny and slightly claustrophobic tribute to theatrical life.- TV Guide Magazine
- Read full review
-
- Maitland McDonagh
Bizarre, utterly original and truly indescribable comedy...You just have to see it for yourself.- TV Guide Magazine
- Read full review
-
- Maitland McDonagh
The result is truly a family film, not a kiddie time-waster that throws the occasional sop to adults; whether you like or love it is a function of how vividly the material reflects your own childhood fantasies.- TV Guide Magazine
- Read full review
-
- Maitland McDonagh
A cool indictment of television's near-irresistible pandering to the inner peeping tom.- TV Guide Magazine
- Read full review
-
- Maitland McDonagh
This film pivots on a romantic triangle as overwrought as it is stylized. It's like a Douglas Sirk melodrama ratcheted up with fists of fury and wrapped in apparently endless yards of shimmering silk.- TV Guide Magazine
- Read full review
-
- Maitland McDonagh
For what could easily have been a slickly vulgar variation on "American Pie" or "Porky's", this libidinous comedy explores some unusually complicated territory, and benefits greatly from Verdú's unpredictable performance as Luisa.- TV Guide Magazine
- Read full review
-
- Maitland McDonagh
It's a fearless performance and yields some squirm-inducingly funny moments.- TV Guide Magazine
- Read full review
-
- Maitland McDonagh
Anderson is a master of detail, from the film's ubiquitous fish motif to the elaborate carnival set piece that unfolds inside the claustrophobic confines of a spook-house ride called "Route 666."- TV Guide Magazine
- Read full review
-
- Maitland McDonagh
Lee occasionally stumbles as a documentarian... But the material is so profoundly moving that it hardly matters.- TV Guide Magazine
- Read full review
-
- Maitland McDonagh
But the real marvel is that beneath the ghoulish in-jokes and horror-geek allusions, there's a core of the same bittersweet truth that makes the best fairy tales resonate from one generation to the next.- TV Guide Magazine
- Read full review
-
- Maitland McDonagh
This thin, clichéd comedy of crime and social climbing contains some scattered laughs and whole lot of padding.- TV Guide Magazine
- Read full review
-
- Maitland McDonagh
The story is simple enough for young children to follow, and the computer-animated images are both bright and surprisingly complex. Adults won't find the action heart-stopping.- TV Guide Magazine
- Read full review
-
- TV Guide Magazine
- Read full review
-
- Maitland McDonagh
This second installment is heavy on battle sequences, which will thrill some viewers more than others.- TV Guide Magazine
- Read full review
-
- Maitland McDonagh
The film's tone is set by a bravura opening sequence that follows a single bullet from a factory conveyer belt to its resting place in a child's skull, and by Cage's flawlessly sardonic voice-over.- TV Guide Magazine
- Read full review
-
- Maitland McDonagh
Sentimental, formulaic, predictable and shamelessly manipulative, Marcos Carnevale’s tale of late-life love is also genuinely heartbreaking and heartening.- TV Guide Magazine
- Read full review
-
- Maitland McDonagh
Much of the film's appeal rests with Thai soap-opera actress Panyopas, whose bittersweet charm smoothes over the uglier aspects of Tum's spiral into crime.- TV Guide Magazine
- Read full review
-
- Maitland McDonagh
A rapt fascination with transcendent lunacy runs through Herzog's work, both fiction and documentary; while disdaining Treadwell's rhapsodically anthropomorphized vision of nature.- TV Guide Magazine
- Read full review
-
- Maitland McDonagh
Eminently worth seeing, even if it leaves you wishing it were as consistently inventive as Aardman's first feature, "Chicken Run" (2000).- TV Guide Magazine
- Read full review
-
- Maitland McDonagh
Moreno's subtly calibrated mix of intelligence, naivete, rebelliousness, charisma and practicality produces an unforgettable protagonist; even Maria's recklessness seems reasonable because it's so clearly rooted in desperation.- TV Guide Magazine
- Read full review
-
- Maitland McDonagh
Anyone looking for the comfort in a tense thriller ending in a satisfying restoration of order and psychological security will be bitterly disappointed, but Haneke isn't in the business of encouraging comforting illusions.- TV Guide Magazine
- Read full review
-
- Maitland McDonagh
Classic melodrama given a thoroughly modern, utterly Almodovarian face-lift.- TV Guide Magazine
- Read full review
-
- Maitland McDonagh
It's a sorry state of affairs when a goldfish and a frog (Ginger's prize specimen, unsubtly named Casanova) have more chemistry than a romantic comedy's human leads.- TV Guide Magazine
- Read full review
-
- Maitland McDonagh
Eastwood's slow-building story of loss and deliverance is a fine, understated piece of storytelling that earns every emotional body blow it lands.- TV Guide Magazine
- Read full review
-
- Maitland McDonagh
He (Anderson) manages to guide his cast of characters through an epic story of self-delusion with a skill and grace that many more experienced filmmakers would be hard put to match.- TV Guide Magazine
- Read full review
-
- Maitland McDonagh
Overall, the performances are surprisingly convincing, but the mockumentary elements – feel out of place and the intrusive.- TV Guide Magazine
- Read full review
-
- TV Guide Magazine
- Read full review
-
- Maitland McDonagh
This rambling exercise in local color has been a pet project of Duvall's for more than a decade, and it's to his credit that he managed to get such a low-concept picture produced. It's also to his credit that he resists the temptation to take easy potshots at religion, particularly of the revivalist variety.- TV Guide Magazine
- Read full review
-
- Maitland McDonagh
Though meticulously researched, well acted and filled with striking moments, the movie ultimately feels oddly disconnected.- TV Guide Magazine
- Read full review
-
- Maitland McDonagh
This ode to the peculiar strength and flexibility of love, romantic and platonic, is simultaneously perverse, overwrought, deeply creepy and truly moving, a high-wire act that finds humor in the grotesque and hope in emotional malformation.- TV Guide Magazine
- Read full review
-
- TV Guide Magazine
- Read full review
-
- Maitland McDonagh
The film's liabilities include Lustig's excessive reliance on flashy editing, tacky special effects and a blaring alterna-rock soundtrack that's used to make the characters' thoughts and motivations painfully obvious. Among its assets are the clever premise and generally appealing performances.- TV Guide Magazine
- Read full review
-
- Maitland McDonagh
It's the rare action picture whose adrenaline-driven thrills neither overshadow the characters nor degenerate into cartoonish preposterousness.- TV Guide Magazine
- Read full review
-
- TV Guide Magazine
- Read full review
-
- Maitland McDonagh
The Savages is funny in the if-you-didn't-laugh-you'd-cry way and superbly acted by all involved, including the supporting cast of home-care attendants, nurses, hospital administrators, intake personnel and nursing-home staff.- TV Guide Magazine
- Read full review
-
- Maitland McDonagh
This dazzling pop allegory is steeped in a dark, pulpy sensibility that transcends nostalgic pastiche and stands firmly on its own merits.- TV Guide Magazine
- Read full review
-
- Maitland McDonagh
Veers regularly into disease-of-the-week territory but is rescued by the powerhouse performances of Ken Watanabe (who was instrumental in getting the film made) and Kanako Higuchi.- TV Guide Magazine
- Read full review
-
- TV Guide Magazine
- Read full review
-
- Maitland McDonagh
The result is a vivid record of live acts whose rough-edged immediacy is an integral part of their appeal.- TV Guide Magazine
- Read full review
-
- Maitland McDonagh
Though the specifics of the story may be unfamiliar to Western viewers, its broad outlines and underlying themes are universal, and Christopher Doyle's ravishing cinematography transcends language.- TV Guide Magazine
- Read full review
-
- Maitland McDonagh
That Ledger stands out in such a powerhouse ensemble is a tribute to his radically unhinged interpretation of a familiar character: The lank hair tinged seaweed green, the darting tongue and faint lisp that call constant attention to the ghastly rictus of his mouth, the nightmarishly smudged make up… taken together, they make previous Jokers feel like, well, jokes.- TV Guide Magazine
- Read full review
-
- TV Guide Magazine
- Read full review
-
- Maitland McDonagh
Boon's film is both funny and heartbreaking, a supremely confident mix of political satire, free-floating paranoia, fractured family dynamics and the kind of comedy that regularly reconfigures itself into tragedy.- TV Guide Magazine
- Read full review
-
- Maitland McDonagh
Lafosse's razor sharp dissection of relationships strained to the breaking point is hypnotic in a road-accident kind of way.- TV Guide Magazine
- Read full review
-
- Maitland McDonagh
Steven Soderbergh's direction conjures an understated '70s vibe, striking an apparently effortless balance between grit and glamour.- TV Guide Magazine
- Read full review
-
- TV Guide Magazine
- Read full review
-
- Maitland McDonagh
Feels astonishingly fresh, filled with subtle performances and devastatingly understated images - Sautet's final shot of Davos alone in a Paris crowd is a killer.- TV Guide Magazine
- Read full review
-
- Maitland McDonagh
The screenplay, which differs significantly from the novel, is uneven, but the distorted mirror it holds up to the present is disturbingly clear.- TV Guide Magazine
- Read full review
-
- Maitland McDonagh
Extravagant special effects notwithstanding, this is really a triumph of casting: The aplomb with which Jones plays wry straight man to Smith's street-smart wiseacre is terrifically enjoyable.- TV Guide Magazine
- Read full review
-
- Maitland McDonagh
Black comedy of the deepest, richest darkness laid over an aching meditation on the atrophy of dreams.- TV Guide Magazine
- Read full review
-
- Maitland McDonagh
The film's greatest incidental pleasures are images of a time when outlaw musicians wore suit jackets and the craggy Dylan was a delicate, unconventionally handsome young man.- TV Guide Magazine
- Read full review
-
- Maitland McDonagh
Fart, feces and gonad gags notwithstanding, this knockabout comedy is no more vulgar than most contemporary children's films, and more good-natured than many.- TV Guide Magazine
- Read full review
-
- Maitland McDonagh
In light of the aesthetic of ugliness that informs von Trier's Dogme films, it's easy to forget how subtly beautiful his work once was.- TV Guide Magazine
- Read full review
-
- Maitland McDonagh
Crammed with outrageous turns of fortune and quicksilver shifts in tone, Almodovar's film is held together by performances so subtle and complex it's hard to single out only one as exceptional. But Cruz is astonishing.- TV Guide Magazine
- Read full review
-
- Maitland McDonagh
An Arthurian tale minus everything the average person knows or cares about Arthur and his knights.- TV Guide Magazine
- Read full review
-
- Maitland McDonagh
The second version of Graham Greene's sad and prescient 1955 novel about American involvement in Vietnam hews far closer to the book than the first, preserving the sophisticated ambiguity of his depiction of a tangled struggle for power played out on both personal and political fronts.- TV Guide Magazine
- Read full review
-
- Maitland McDonagh
If he were a more subtle director, it would be a great film; as it is, it's an extremely good one, anchored by the subtly devastating performances of Penn, Robbins and Bacon. The supporting cast is equally good, and blue collar Boston's mean streets take on a beaten-down life of their own.- TV Guide Magazine
- Read full review
-
- Maitland McDonagh
Production-designed within an inch of its life, this remake's best conceit is the casting of Crispin Glover as its socially maladroit rat fancier.- TV Guide Magazine
- Read full review
-
- Maitland McDonagh
The end is hardly in doubt, since this sweet-natured film treads a path worn smooth and hard by countless other tiny feet. Its message is as unimpeachable as it is familiar, differentiated from countless similar tales only by the Filipino setting.- TV Guide Magazine
- Read full review
-
- Maitland McDonagh
(Griffith's) appearance often verges on the grotesque. Which, come to think of it, could be said of the movie as well.- TV Guide Magazine
- Read full review
-
- Maitland McDonagh
The payoff doesn't quite equal the intensity of the spectacularly squirm-inducing premise, but Farrell takes his showboating star turn and runs with it.- TV Guide Magazine
- Read full review
-
- Maitland McDonagh
In the end it's all seductive surface and no substance, but Lough has a bold eye and a vivid sense of uniquely urban beauty.- TV Guide Magazine
- Read full review
-
- Maitland McDonagh
But what truly distinguishes the movie is Cage's performance, which is so off the wall that even if you don't like it you have to watch in awe.- TV Guide Magazine
- Read full review
-
- Maitland McDonagh
The battle sequences and lightsaber battles are gripping, and for every scene that doesn't deliver the goods, there's another that hums with surprising intensity.- TV Guide Magazine
- Read full review
-
- Maitland McDonagh
The film's major draws are R-rated gore and some nice physical effects, proof that a man in a top-of-the-line monster suit can still be more effective than CGI.- TV Guide Magazine
- Read full review
-
- TV Guide Magazine
- Read full review
-
- Maitland McDonagh
This melodramatic action opera is a lurid love letter to the guns and poses aesthetic of Hong Kong action cinema.- TV Guide Magazine
- Read full review
-
- Maitland McDonagh
The rare sequel that actually improves on the original, this robust entertainment's intelligence and emotional impact belie conventional wisdom that summer movie spectaculars are by nature brainless nonsense and only a stupid snob would complain about their cynical insubstantiality.- TV Guide Magazine
- Read full review
-
- Maitland McDonagh
Like "Air Guitar Nation," the stranger-than-fiction cast of characters is fascinating, and their high-stakes machinations are nothing short of mind-boggling.- TV Guide Magazine
- Read full review
-
- TV Guide Magazine
- Read full review
-
- Maitland McDonagh
Its minutely detailed revelations work their way under the skin like slivers of glass.- TV Guide Magazine
- Read full review
-
- Maitland McDonagh
Tarantino maintains a flawless balance between flat-out action, quirky dialogue, stylish homages to the glistening shadows of film-noir thrillers, the sun-baked brutality of Westerns (American and Italian), the ritualistic rhythms of Shaw Brothers martial-arts pictures from the 1970s and quietly dramatic moments, shifting between them with quicksilver facility.- TV Guide Magazine
- Read full review
-
- TV Guide Magazine
- Read full review
-
- Maitland McDonagh
An icily seductive parable about family, power, unconventional justice and the perils of answered prayers.- TV Guide Magazine
- Read full review
-
- Maitland McDonagh
Tim Burton's grand guignol fantasy transforms Stephen Sondheim's 1979 musical-theater piece into a cheerfully gothic morality tale.- TV Guide Magazine
- Read full review
-
- TV Guide Magazine
- Read full review
-
- TV Guide Magazine
- Read full review
-
- Maitland McDonagh
The appealing Knightley goes in a promising young actress and comes out a star, but the faultless cast of veterans and fresh-faced newcomers imbues every character with flawed and immensely appealing humanity.- TV Guide Magazine
- Read full review
-
- TV Guide Magazine
- Read full review
-
- Maitland McDonagh
Though O'Toole, whose ruined beauty Michell emphasizes in frequent and tight close-ups, and newcomer Whittaker have a striking rapport, the film's most haunting moments pair him with Vanessa Redgrave -- amazingly, this is their first movie together -- as his ex-wife. They evoke a lifetime of love, betrayal, regret and forgiveness in the space of a few lines, then move on without missing a beat.- TV Guide Magazine
- Read full review
-
- Maitland McDonagh
The film's underlying notion, that imperfection is the essence of humanity and the pursuit of bland flawlessness a kind of soul-killing drug, is far more compelling than its story of clichéd teen angst.- TV Guide Magazine
- Read full review
-
- Maitland McDonagh
Canet and Lefevre pruned subplots and fixed the novel's ending -- it's now merely preposterous rather than patently absurd – but it's the cast that makes the genre clichés feel vivid and even fresh.- TV Guide Magazine
- Read full review