Jonathan Rosenbaum
Select another critic »For 1,935 reviews, this critic has graded:
-
42% higher than the average critic
-
2% same as the average critic
-
56% lower than the average critic
On average, this critic grades 4.1 points lower than other critics.
(0-100 point scale)
Jonathan Rosenbaum's Scores
- Movies
- TV
| Average review score: | 62 | |
|---|---|---|
| Highest review score: | Breathless | |
| Lowest review score: | Bad Boys | |
Score distribution:
-
Positive: 961 out of 1935
-
Mixed: 744 out of 1935
-
Negative: 230 out of 1935
1935
movie
reviews
- By Date
- By Critic Score
-
- Jonathan Rosenbaum
The first Ang Lee film I've seen that I've liked without qualification.- Chicago Reader
- Read full review
-
- Jonathan Rosenbaum
Much of this is hilarious as long as one can stay sufficiently removed from the realities of Siamese twins.- Chicago Reader
- Read full review
-
- Jonathan Rosenbaum
Some of the results ring false, but the memorable theme song and some equally memorable character acting (by Thomas Mitchell and Lon Chaney Jr. more than Lloyd Bridges and Katy Jurado) help things along.- Chicago Reader
- Read full review
-
- Jonathan Rosenbaum
Given the talent on board, there's an undeniable flair and effectiveness in certain scenes (such as Pacino dancing the tango with a stranger in a posh restaurant), but the meretricious calculation finally sticks in one's throat.- Chicago Reader
- Read full review
-
- Jonathan Rosenbaum
To Towne's credit, he's a thoughtful and conscientious romantic. He skillfully makes the two main characters a hot, volatile couple, deftly staging their courtship as if it were an erotic grudge match.- Chicago Reader
- Read full review
-
- Jonathan Rosenbaum
Neither the characters nor the events are exactly the same as those of the novel, but some of the same spirit comes across.- Chicago Reader
- Read full review
-
- Chicago Reader
- Read full review
-
- Jonathan Rosenbaum
But the material is still powerful, and the offbeat story of the patients remains both engrossing and moving even after all this abridgment.- Chicago Reader
- Read full review
-
- Jonathan Rosenbaum
The film's storytelling and heartfelt pantheism are both impressive.- Chicago Reader
- Read full review
-
- Jonathan Rosenbaum
This is like a Ferris wheel--the ride's enjoyable but you've gone nowhere once it's over.- Chicago Reader
- Read full review
-
- Jonathan Rosenbaum
This isn't a visionary western like "The Three Burials of Melquiades Estrada" (2005), but in its own quiet way it delivers the goods.- Chicago Reader
- Read full review
-
- Jonathan Rosenbaum
Klapisch self-consciously throws fistfuls of quirky film style at us, as if he were Francois Truffaut, but his characters are still interesting and his party sequences are especially good.- Chicago Reader
- Read full review
-
- Jonathan Rosenbaum
For my money, this version doesn't match the Siegel film, though it's a lot scarier and more memorable than Kaufman's low-key, New Agey version.- Chicago Reader
- Read full review
-
- Chicago Reader
- Read full review
-
- Jonathan Rosenbaum
Jay Craven's stilted adaptation of a novel by Howard Frank Mosher lacks the urgency, the poetry, or the feeling for period that might have brought the material to life, while the cast seems to be largely squandered.- Chicago Reader
- Read full review
-
- Chicago Reader
- Read full review
-
- Jonathan Rosenbaum
Assisted by Gordon Willis's cinematography and John Houseman's performance as the demanding Professor Kingsfield, director James Bridges manages to do a fair job with the semihokey material.- Chicago Reader
- Read full review
-
- Jonathan Rosenbaum
For me the film creates more embarrassment than sympathy, but at least it's a kind of embarrassment that's instructive.- Chicago Reader
- Read full review
-
- Jonathan Rosenbaum
On a mindless exploitation level this is pretty good, but on other levels it seems to make promises that it fails to deliver on; none of the deaths carries any moral weight, and the climactic special-effects free-for-all tends to drown out all other interests.- Chicago Reader
- Read full review
-
- Jonathan Rosenbaum
Director Jonathan Kaplan clearly has a feel for the material, but he's at the mercy of a pedestrian script by David Arata and producer Adam Fields.- Chicago Reader
- Read full review
-
- Jonathan Rosenbaum
The late 300-pound transvestite Divine, John Waters’s most enduring muse, makes his/her first star entrance in this 1969 feature—the first Waters movie to play outside Baltimore—driving a 1959 Eldorado to the strains of “The Girl Can’t Help It.”- Chicago Reader
- Read full review
-
- Chicago Reader
- Read full review
-
- Jonathan Rosenbaum
The story's resolution isn't very satisfying, but I considered most of this movie time well spent.- Chicago Reader
- Read full review
-
- Jonathan Rosenbaum
Even though it's scripted by a woman (Kelly Masterson), this tale of buried family resentments rising to the surface as the brothers plot to rob their parents' jewelry store is concerned only with the guys, and it's marred by an uncharacteristically mannered performance by Albert Finney as the father.- Chicago Reader
- Read full review
-
- Jonathan Rosenbaum
Elliptical, full of subtle inner rhymes...and profoundly moving, this is the most tightly crafted Kubrick film since "Dr. Strangelove," as well as the most horrific; the first section alone accomplishes most of what "The Shining" failed to do.- Chicago Reader
- Read full review
-
- Jonathan Rosenbaum
This 1981 release is one of Brian De Palma's more interesting and better-made thrillers, though it's even more abjectly derivative than his Hitchcock imitations (borrowing mightily this time from Antonioni's Blowup, as the title suggests).- Chicago Reader
- Read full review
-
- Jonathan Rosenbaum
As usual, Lee tries many kinds of stylistic effects and uses wall-to-wall music (by Aaron Copland and Public Enemy); what’s different this time is how personally driven the story feels.- Chicago Reader
- Read full review
-
- Jonathan Rosenbaum
The whole thing's so worthy that I wish I liked it more. It makes time pass agreeably, but Square John still seems about as innocent of fresh ideas (aesthetically and otherwise) as most of his characters, and for this kind of leftist multiplot I found his "City of Hope" more engaging.- Chicago Reader
- Read full review
-
- Jonathan Rosenbaum
Just about everyone in this sharp, passionate feature is chillingly good.- Chicago Reader
- Read full review
-
- Jonathan Rosenbaum
A lot of superwimp gags executed by Luke Wilson grow out of this premise, as do some tacky 50s-style special effects. The movie's too slapdash to keep its characters consistent, but this has its moments.- Chicago Reader
- Read full review
-
- Jonathan Rosenbaum
Though the basic brains-versus-beauty tension suggests a female variation on "The Nutty Professor", this is a softer version of the dilemma than Jerry Lewis offers -- easier to take and easier to forget.- Chicago Reader
- Read full review
-
- Jonathan Rosenbaum
The actors make this fun if you can overlook the ludicrous view of Jeremy Leven's screenplay.- Chicago Reader
- Read full review
-
- Jonathan Rosenbaum
Wong Kar-wai's idiosyncratic style first became apparent in this gorgeously moody second feature.- Chicago Reader
- Read full review
-
- Jonathan Rosenbaum
Like many sequels this is actually a remake, and it suffers from the law of diminishing returns.- Chicago Reader
- Read full review
-
- Jonathan Rosenbaum
A top-notch courtroom drama that will keep you guessing if you haven't read the book; even if you have, it is still a very well crafted story.- Chicago Reader
- Read full review
-
- Jonathan Rosenbaum
Both actors work hard to give this disturbing crime story some flavor and substance, but the narrative is overextended and poorly organized.- Chicago Reader
- Read full review
-
- Chicago Reader
- Read full review
-
- Jonathan Rosenbaum
An accomplished, effective, grisly, and exceptionally sick slasher film that I can't with any conscience recommend, because the purposes to which it places its considerable ingenuity are ultimately rather foul.- Chicago Reader
- Read full review
-
- Jonathan Rosenbaum
This may be Reed’s most pretentious film, but it also happens to be one of his very best, beautifully capturing the poetry of a city at night (with black-and-white cinematography by Robert Krasker that’s within hailing distance of Gregg Toland and Stanley Cortez’s work with Orson Welles).- Chicago Reader
- Read full review
-
- Jonathan Rosenbaum
It's entertaining and stylish, though maybe not quite as serious as it wants to be.- Chicago Reader
- Read full review
-
- Jonathan Rosenbaum
For torture and violence freaks, every clank and thud is duly and hyperbolically registered.- Chicago Reader
- Read full review
-
- Jonathan Rosenbaum
Too preoccupied with personality and emotion to qualify as porn, but still very much concerned with the kind of interaction that goes on in such a place, this is a touching if relatively specialized chamber piece.- Chicago Reader
- Read full review
-
- Chicago Reader
- Read full review
-
- Jonathan Rosenbaum
One thing I especially like about it, apart from the flavorsome 40s decor in color, is that it's silly in much the same way that many small 40s comedies were.- Chicago Reader
- Read full review
-
- Jonathan Rosenbaum
Pivots on the characters' racism and xenophobia, playing tricks with our own biases and ultimately justifying an extravagant array of coincidences and surprises.- Chicago Reader
- Read full review
-
- Jonathan Rosenbaum
Despite the fitful energy and the beauty of the settings, the ugliness of the mise en scene and the crudity of the editing tend to triumph.- Chicago Reader
- Read full review
-
- Chicago Reader
- Read full review
-
- Jonathan Rosenbaum
Director Tom Tykwer (Run Lola Run) and cowriters Andrew Birkin and Bernd Eichinger preserve some of the novel's storytelling flair, and Dustin Hoffman does a swell turn as the antihero's Italian mentor. But despite a fairly spectacular climax, the material's generic limitations eventually catch up with the plot.- Chicago Reader
- Read full review
-
- Jonathan Rosenbaum
An enjoyable though distinctly second-degree comedy by writer-director Andrew Bergman. Full of fun around the edges, it's rather flat and unfelt at the center.- Chicago Reader
- Read full review
-
- Jonathan Rosenbaum
Despite the cast -- Kevin Bacon, Matt Dillon, Neve Campbell, Denise Richards, Daphne Rubin-Vega, Theresa Russell, Robert Wagner, and Bill Murray -- I found it preposterous.- Chicago Reader
- Read full review
-
- Jonathan Rosenbaum
A first-rate police thriller (1948) directed by Jules Dassin when he was still in his prime and before he was blacklisted, shot memorably in New York locations.- Chicago Reader
- Read full review
-
- Jonathan Rosenbaum
Writer-director Robert Shallcross believes in it so passionately that he came close to convincing me too.- Chicago Reader
- Read full review
-
- Jonathan Rosenbaum
Writer-director Marcos Bernstein is more interested in how a melodramatic imagination can distort reality, a concept he explores with charm and tact.- Chicago Reader
- Read full review
-
- Jonathan Rosenbaum
James Whale’s brilliant and surprisingly delicate 1936 rendition of the Kern and Hammerstein musical, which was based on an Edna Ferber novel, is infinitely superior to the dull 1951 MGM Technicolor remake and, interestingly enough, less racist.- Chicago Reader
- Read full review
-
- Jonathan Rosenbaum
There's nothing really new...but it has craft, pacing, and an overall sense of proportion, three pretty rare classic virtues nowadays.- Chicago Reader
- Read full review
-
- Jonathan Rosenbaum
A masterpiece of some kind, though clearly destined to be controversial and contested everywhere it shows—not only for the sexist, racist, and homophobic rage it exposes but also for its brilliant confrontational style.- Chicago Reader
- Read full review
-
- Jonathan Rosenbaum
Despite a certain grace in the dialogue and casual plot construction, this is positively reeking of a desire to be cheerful in the face of adversity.- Chicago Reader
- Read full review
-
- Jonathan Rosenbaum
Payne's entertaining but familiar comedy lacks the insolence of his "Election" and the freshness of his work with Kathy Bates in "About Schmidt."- Chicago Reader
- Read full review
-
- Jonathan Rosenbaum
Combining the gentle with the vulgar as only the English can, this lively comedy is bursting with character and energy.- Chicago Reader
- Read full review
-
- Jonathan Rosenbaum
As satire it's toothless and at times close to incoherent; its predictable swipes are aimed equally at conservative racists and bleeding-heart liberals.- Chicago Reader
- Read full review
-
- Jonathan Rosenbaum
What makes the strongest impact is the superb documentary photography and the "found" audio segments--telemarketing ads left as voice messages.- Chicago Reader
- Read full review
-
- Jonathan Rosenbaum
The main novelty of this conventional, slight, but charming youth picture is that it's English and therefore more class-conscious than most American equivalents.- Chicago Reader
- Read full review
-
- Jonathan Rosenbaum
For better and for worse, this is seductive storytelling as well as investigative journalism, and I wasn't always sure which mode I was in.- Chicago Reader
- Read full review
-
- Jonathan Rosenbaum
Probably the most influential of all silent films after The Birth of a Nation, Intolerance launched ideas about associative editing that have been essential to the cinema ever since, from Soviet montage classics to recent American experimental films. And in the use of crosscutting and action to generate suspense, the film's climax hasn't been surpassed.- Chicago Reader
- Read full review
-
- Jonathan Rosenbaum
Stylistically captivating, subtly nuanced, and structurally unpredictable.- Chicago Reader
- Read full review
-
- Jonathan Rosenbaum
Every effect is so calculated that only the conscious minds of filmmakers and viewers are engaged--and not by very much or for very long.- Chicago Reader
- Read full review
-
- Jonathan Rosenbaum
This cagey and compelling 2004 documentary looks at the world of wine, but it's actually a nuanced, provocative piece of journalism about globalization and its discontents.- Chicago Reader
- Read full review
-
- Jonathan Rosenbaum
David Morse, who plays the driver, gives a relatively sharp and understated performance -- for me the only bearable thing in the movie.- Chicago Reader
- Read full review
-
- Jonathan Rosenbaum
It’s a historical marker in a way that few other films are — not only the nail in the coffin of the French New Wave and one of the strongest statements about the aftermath of the failed French revolution of May 1968, but also a definitive expression of the closing in of Western culture after the end of the era generally known as the 60s.- Chicago Reader
- Read full review
-
- Chicago Reader
- Read full review
-
- Jonathan Rosenbaum
Misogynistic claptrap about a divorced husband (Dustin Hoffman) fighting for the custody of and learning to cope with his little boy (Justin Henry) - a movie whose classy trimmings (including Nestor Almendros's cinematography) persuaded audiences to regard writer-director Robert Benton as a subtle art-house director.- Chicago Reader
- Read full review
-
- Chicago Reader
- Read full review
-
- Jonathan Rosenbaum
Ben Stiller directs Lou Holtz Jr.'s script with plenty of unsettling edge, and Carrey throws himself into his part as if it meant something.- Chicago Reader
- Read full review
-
- Jonathan Rosenbaum
There are a few pretty good design effects en route, but not enough to compensate for all the embarrassments.- Chicago Reader
- Read full review
-
- Jonathan Rosenbaum
As for remakes, it stands to reason that if you try to redo a work of art without the original artist, you're bound to damage the artistry as well.- Chicago Reader
- Read full review
-
- Chicago Reader
- Read full review
-
- Jonathan Rosenbaum
The film never strays much beyond the obvious, despite a conscientious effort by Tim Robbins to humanize a white security officer.- Chicago Reader
- Read full review
-
- Jonathan Rosenbaum
Yet some of the laughs come too easy and linger too long; for the film's message to have maximum impact, the laughter has to stick in your throat.- Chicago Reader
- Read full review
-
- Jonathan Rosenbaum
Unprecedented in its intellectual ambition, this is endlessly stimulating; it probably tries for too much, but it shames many other contemporary essays that try for too little.- Chicago Reader
- Read full review
-
- Jonathan Rosenbaum
An epic about the Irish patriot (Liam Neeson) during the last years of his life (1916-'22), it clearly represents a lot of thought on Jordan's part, yet it's dramatic and cinematic sludge.- Chicago Reader
- Read full review
-
- Jonathan Rosenbaum
Reasonably entertaining spy-versus-spy shenanigans were for me partially undercut by the hypocritical pretense that the CIA and its various forms of mischief were somehow being ridiculed.- Chicago Reader
- Read full review
-
- Jonathan Rosenbaum
Overwritten by Billy Crystal and Peter Tolan, overdirected by Joe Roth, overplayed by most of the cast, yet typically undernourished.- Chicago Reader
- Read full review
-
- Jonathan Rosenbaum
If the relatively prosaic Minghella, making his movie debut, lacks the suggestive poetic sensibility of Lewton, he does a fine job in capturing the contemporary everyday textures of London life, and coaxes a strong performance out of Stevenson, a longtime collaborator. Full of richly realized secondary characters and witty oddball details, this is a beguiling film in more ways than one.- Chicago Reader
- Read full review
-
- Jonathan Rosenbaum
As with Nostalghia, Tarkovsky’s previous work of exile, it’s possible to balk at the filmmaker’s pretensions and antiquated sexual politics and yet be overwhelmed by his mastery and originality, as well as the conviction of his sincerity.- Chicago Reader
- Read full review
-
- Jonathan Rosenbaum
A provocative and stirring climax to the Corleone saga, as well as an autonomous work that sometimes shows Coppola at his near best.- Chicago Reader
- Read full review
-
- Chicago Reader
- Read full review
-
- Jonathan Rosenbaum
What we don’t know about these characters–and what we don’t see in certain scenes–is often as interesting and as important as what we know and see, and Assayas’s sense of how relationships evolve between people over time is conveyed with a rich and vivid novelistic density.- Chicago Reader
- Read full review
-
- Jonathan Rosenbaum
Beginning with almost no dialogue at all, Le samourai unfolds like a poetic fever dream.- Chicago Reader
- Read full review
-
- Jonathan Rosenbaum
Harry Kumel's stylish Belgian vampire film with a cult reputation (1971) is worth seeing for several reasons, not least of which is Delphine Seyrig's elegant lead performance as a lesbian vampire who operates a luxury hotel. The baroque mise en scene is also loads of fun.- Chicago Reader
- Read full review
-
- Jonathan Rosenbaum
This 2005 farce about a hellish Passover seder panders to middle-class Jews as gleefully as Tyler Perry's movies pander to middle-class African-Americans, though there's less religiosity and a greater degree of self-hatred in the vulgar stereotypes.- Chicago Reader
- Read full review
-
- Jonathan Rosenbaum
Despite the familiar story arc and MTV visuals, Bendinger puts this across with a certain amount of pizzazz, and the competitive gymnastics are often spectacular.- Chicago Reader
- Read full review
-
- Jonathan Rosenbaum
The unfocused story is so bereft of any clear sense of period or location that the political melodrama sometimes seems to be taking place inside a cigar box.- Chicago Reader
- Read full review
-
- Jonathan Rosenbaum
In its own quiet way this is an astonishing film, both as a medical detective story that sustains taut interest over an extended running time and as a piece of cinema combining unusually resourceful acting and direction. If any movie of recent years deserves to be called inspirational--a much-abused term that one hesitates to revive apart from exceptional circumstances--this one certainly does.- Chicago Reader
- Read full review
-
- Jonathan Rosenbaum
Powerfully illustrates what globalization has been doing to underdeveloped countries around the world.- Chicago Reader
- Read full review
-
- Jonathan Rosenbaum
If Wahlberg in a beret is your idea of fun, don't let me get in your way.- Chicago Reader
- Read full review
-
- Jonathan Rosenbaum
Heckerling still has some of the sensitivity she showed in handling actors in Fast Times at Ridgemont High and she has a deft way of illustrating her heroine's fantasies about possible mates without any fuss.- Chicago Reader
- Read full review
-
- Jonathan Rosenbaum
Experimental films are frequently criticized for being boring because they say and do too little, but the best of them put us in exhilarating overdrive because they offer too much.- Chicago Reader
- Read full review
-
- Jonathan Rosenbaum
Stupid, vicious, and pretentious, though you may find it worth checking out if you want to experiment with your own nervous system.- Chicago Reader
- Read full review
-
- Jonathan Rosenbaum
If Bertolucci had restricted himself to Siddhartha’s story he would have remained on solid ground, at least as a storyteller, for the interpolated religious tale is far and away the best thing in the movie, full of enchantment and wonder.- Chicago Reader
- Read full review
-
- Jonathan Rosenbaum
Of course the movie's real raison d'etre is watching Ice Cube tear up government facilities and blockades with a tank, spout Schwarzenegger-style kiss-off lines, and commandeer the kind of babes and high-tech cars that James Bond usually plays with.- Chicago Reader
- Read full review