Jack Mathews
Select another critic »For 1,391 reviews, this critic has graded:
-
49% higher than the average critic
-
3% same as the average critic
-
48% lower than the average critic
On average, this critic grades 5.7 points lower than other critics.
(0-100 point scale)
Jack Mathews' Scores
- Movies
- TV
| Average review score: | 60 | |
|---|---|---|
| Highest review score: | Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind | |
| Lowest review score: | Perception | |
Score distribution:
-
Positive: 810 out of 1391
-
Mixed: 296 out of 1391
-
Negative: 285 out of 1391
1391
movie
reviews
- By Date
- By Critic Score
-
- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
A giddy black comedy about a homicidal housekeeper in rural England, is a hilarious reminder of that 1944 Frank Capra classic about two old maids whose cellar is cluttered with the bodies of would-be suitors.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
This epic tale of survival, love and adjustment covers a 59-year period - from 1910, when a band of urban émigrés arrives to start a settlement, to 1969, when only one of them remains.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
This year’s foreign language Oscar scandal – there is always at least one – is the snub of director Cristian Mungiu’s disturbing, masterful realist drama following two college roommates as they carry out plans for one’s black market abortion in Communist Romania.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
The very thought of humanizing Hitler makes me queasy. If he had a good side, I don't want to know about it.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
No actress of her generation inhabits characters as thoroughly and convincingly as she (Streep) does, and this performance carries the movie- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
I don't mean to demean it; it's smart, inventive and well-crafted. But as a feature film, it's a novelty item at best.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
A great big sloppy kiss of entertainment for audiences weary of explosions, CGI effects and sequels, sequels, sequels.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
It takes a while to get used to the film's campy characters and its broad, "Ace Ventura" stylings. But Ferrell is the anti-Jim Carrey -- his deadpan comic mannerisms are infectiously funny, and his cluelessly narcissistic Burgundy is a joy to follow.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
Left-wing flame-thrower Robert Greenwald (Uncovered: The War on Iraq) gets after the global giant anyway, and he may have you thinking twice before entering another Wal-Mart parking lot.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
Clever, compelling, funny and unpredictable, and it has a lollapa-looza of an ending.- New York Daily News
-
- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
While it won't rival the Harry Potter movies as a cultural milestone, the luminous, irresistible Stardust is no less industrious at scavenging myths and legends and making something altogether new from the familiar pickings.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
It's often maddening, because of its structure, and some of its visuals are pretentious nonsense. But, as a story of undying love, it's certainly unique.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
The standout in the cast is James Todd Smith, whose acting talent may soon persuade him to shed his adolescent stage name of LL Cool J and concentrate on mainstream film roles.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- New York Daily News
-
- Jack Mathews
Though Borat has been likened to "Jackass," there's a huge difference. The "Jackass" movies are about extreme stunts. Borat is about interaction and gullibility, and its success is unique to both Cohen and to this one-time-only movie.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
In Crazy Love, friends of Burt and Linda express as much confusion over their relationship as we feel, and the Pugaches themselves make an unconvincing case for theirs being a love that conquered all. On the contrary, love doesn't seem to have had anything to do with them. She married him out of desperation, and he pursued her out of a sense of entitlement.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
Far from the smart historical epic some might have expected, is just another feisty summer shoot-'em-up.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
The playfulness evident in the hundreds of bondage photos that made a pious young Tennessee model semi-famous in the 1950s and an 82-year-old legend today is also the driving force of Mary Harron's superb The Notorious Bettie Page.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
a despairing movie that you can't look away from, though you'll wish you could.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
Ale's community is like a band of pirates - collegial, bickering, larcenous and supportive - and his life within it is both heartening and heartbreaking.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
Some of this is elemental psychology; blood is thicker than water, etc. But the movie also reveals how the privileged class ignored, condoned or denied the reality of the Holocaust.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
The Exorcist is still shocking, but mostly because of its graphic, anti-religious language. [2000 re-release]- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
A charming trifle, beautifully filmed in a Currier & Ives setting, with buttery-smooth performances from Binoche and Depp, and enough good tidings in its nougat center to get you through the holidays.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
Asylum is as dark as Dracula's mood on a moonless night, and people suffering from depression should think twice before opening the coffin. This thing would put off Mary Poppins.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
Ray and his writers found plenty of material to fill Cooper's capable hands. They've turned what must have been a tedious investigation into a sharp cat-and-mouse game between Hanssen and Eric O'Neill (Ryan Phillippe).- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
Until he was shot to death in 2000, Haitian radio journalist Jean Dominique was a lone voice for truth and freedom in his politically riven country.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- New York Daily News
-
- Jack Mathews
Sensational...as authentic as news footage, and far more intimate.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
The time-warp romantic fantasy The Lake House is a puzzle that is maddeningly obtuse, emotionally overstretched, and virtually absent a sense of interior logic.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
A captivating piece of visual wizardry. The house, which eventually frees itself from its moorings and chases after our trio of tweener heroes, is a genuine original.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
Like Stone in "Basic Instinct," van Houten has an audacity to match Verhoeven's. Hers is a role that Bette Davis would have killed Ingrid Bergman for, and she is so good in it that it seems only a matter of time before she'll star in a real Hollywood movie - as opposed to this pretender.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
So much is so good about The Recruit that you'll wish the ending were better. It's like opening the last lid in a Chinese box and having a clown figure pop out on a spring.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
With echoes of "Dave," in which Kevin Kline takes over for the comatose U.S. President he resembles, Kristoffer begins to feel the power given to him and to make his own decisions, leading to some hilarious situations and an unpredictable ending.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
Stamp, whose ability to make Wilson simultaneously coarse and charismatic is irresistibly entertaining.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
Written to skewer the upper class of its time, the script is now just a broad joke-fest, clever lines batted back and forth like badminton shuttlecocks.- New York Daily News
-
- Jack Mathews
The actresses create wonderfully rich characters, and Luis Callejo, as Caye's unknowing boyfriend Manuel, and Antonio Durán, as the sadistic civil servant, fill out the very strong cast.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
A metaphysical shaggy-dog story, whose unpredictable punchline is its only redeeming feature.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
What Andersen does best is capture the sense of growing up and living among the landmarks of Hollywood's authentic back lot.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
What keeps the film from becoming obnoxiously redundant is the conviviality of the comedians. These are funny people even when they're not telling the joke.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
In a sad twist of technological birth and infanticide, General Motors - with assists from the oil industry, the Bush administration, cowardly California energy officials and apathetic consumers - doomed the future car to the literal scrap heap of history.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
The successful bits, along with an amiable cast of losers and their prom-night prey, make American Pie a winner.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
If it weren't based on a true story, you might suspect Sydney McCartney's A Love Divided was created by a panel of militant Irish Protestants.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
Most of the film is way too goofy for all but the most thumbstruck Hitchhiker.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
The Specialist allows Eichmann to convict himself, not of complicity in the Holocaust -- to that he pleads guilty, by reason of nationalism -- but as a man unfazed by his own inhumanity.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
I watched A Good Woman with a fixed smile frequently interrupted by giggles, but I didn't believe a second of it.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
There isn't a flicker of chemistry between these old pros in Andre Techine's peculiar melodrama.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
At times, the giddy tone makes it feel like a musical set on the eve of Pearl Harbor, but the acting is uniformly good and it's an absolutely gorgeous film to watch.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
Just as surely as the shortest distance between two points is a straight line, this domestic comedy follows a direct path through every crisis, every resolution and every sentimental heartbeat laid out in the script.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
The dialogue between the captive and the captors gets a little didactic, and the ending is as contrived as it is cynical. Weingartner obviously has more in common with the rich man than the kids.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
That's a lot just to justify a cute title, but cuteness is the engine driving the slight, obvious but occasionally very funny film.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
Given the tragic events that actually happen, "Nickleby" ends not knowing what it was supposed to be. But those first two acts are nearly worth the price of admission.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
Josh Hamilton gives a marvelously engaging performance in this fish-out-of-water comedy.- New York Daily News
-
- Jack Mathews
Manhattan has always been a fat target for apocalypse filmmakers, but with its 9/11-inspired imagery, Matt Reeves' breathlessly fast-paced Cloverfield is going to resonate with New York audiences in a way no other horror film has.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
One of the most original and ultimately confounding mind games to reach the screen since "The Usual Suspects."- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
The Spanish writers-directors often overreach for humor, and really overreach for a happy ending. But there's a strong heart beating beneath the foolishness and one wonderful performance from Leonor Watling.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
Joy Ride is plenty spooky but there's also plenty of comic relief -- mostly from the perennially goofy Zahn.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
Like previous films by the literary-minded auteur John Sayles, Honeydripper takes forever to develop its characters, its period and its location. But once it's done all that, the payoffs are rich.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
The story feels as urgent as the latest bad news out of the Middle East.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
A grim, poetic, heart-wrenchingly fine ode to the lost children of Glasgow's forgotten class.- New York Daily News
-
- Jack Mathews
Japanese Story could have been a two-character play staged in front of a desert mural. It wouldn't have been as pretty, but it's that tight.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
Not wildly imaginative, and it has a tepid mix of movie references. But the physical environment and characters make it irresistible.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
The memories recalled here aren't epic tales, just moments that make life worth living. Like seeing a good movie. [12 May 1999, p.44]- New York Daily News
-
- New York Daily News
-
- Jack Mathews
Despite a relatively paltry $40 million budget, Stormbreaker has the sheen and special effects of a Bond movie, and the ambition as well.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
Minghella has certainly mounted a gorgeous movie and the battle scenes are brutally spectacular. But overall, "Cold Mountain" is like a fine piece of hand-crafted leather, where the stitching shows its quality. That looks good on a handbag, not so good on the big screen.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
What is lacking in suspense is more than made up for in passion and in sports cinematography virtuosity.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
Works on every level. The humor and language are as crude as an R rating allows, but Carell and Apatow's script is so hip, funny and - yes - innocent that it's never offensive.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
The actress' [Julianne Moore's] goodwill, alone, holds this schizophrenic story together - if just barely.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
The documentary plays it down the middle, neither condemning nor romanticizing the political outlaws, but making sense of who they were and what they did.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
Humorist and liberal radio talk-show host Al Franken is a funny guy, and most of the people he attacks - Ann Coulter, Bill O'Reilly, Sean Hannity, Dick Cheney - are not. But the joke was on him when George Bush won re-election in 2004.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
I'm no psychologist, but it took about half this film's overlong running time to figure out that Metallica's problem is that Ulrich is a major pain in the butt.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
As a story, Burton's Planet of the Apes is more of a comic-book creation than either of his "Batman" movies.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
For each joke that is fresh, there are at least three that fall thuddingly flat. Rock suffers a problem common to comedians moving from sketches to features; he hasn't quite been able to get his performance level above caricature. To his credit, he's made more of this than you'd expect from the lame premise.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
Locks in on its self-destructive subjects so precisely, it's almost unbearable to watch.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
Every once in a while, a performance pops out of a Hollywood movie that is so brilliant and unique to the matching of actor to role that it's impossible to imagine anyone else achieving it.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
Given the near total absence of intellectually ambitious American movies today, a critic's first impulse after seeing Francis Ford Coppola's reedited Apocalypse Now may be to treat it as the new, improved version he says it is and proclaim it a masterpiece - if not in 1979, then now. But it's not that simple: Apocalypse Now Redux is not a new movie, and neither is it necessarily improved.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
By describing the structure of a great trick in a movie about a great trick, The Prestige makes a promise it can't keep. Its third act is about as convincing as a photo of a cow jumping over the moon.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
If you have a serious interest in wine and the patience for this kind of rangy, undisciplined filmmaking, you'll learn something. But you'll have more fun at a winetasting.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
The performances are all terrific, but Gene Hackman is close to a career best as the family patriarch Royal, the most useless man you can't help loving.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
In a clear case of substance over style, this stark, clumsy documentary tells the heart-breaking stories of a dozen law-abiding Muslim or Arab immigrants and visa workers.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
Has the integrity of good dialogue and enough of a writer's preserved craftiness to make it a worthwhile date-night attraction.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
It has a nifty premise and outstanding performances from Ferrell, as the protagonist-in-progress, and Emma Thompson, as his blocked creator.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- Jack Mathews
This is a crazy, gorgeous, disturbing, darkly comic horror story about an early-18th-century Frenchman born in a Paris fish market without any odor of his own but with a sense of smell that would make a pack of bloodhounds wail with envy.- New York Daily News
- Read full review
-
- New York Daily News
- Read full review