David Edelstein
Select another critic »For 2,169 reviews, this critic has graded:
-
47% higher than the average critic
-
2% same as the average critic
-
51% lower than the average critic
On average, this critic grades 0.9 points lower than other critics.
(0-100 point scale)
David Edelstein's Scores
- Movies
- TV
| Average review score: | 65 | |
|---|---|---|
| Highest review score: | First Cow | |
| Lowest review score: | Funny Games (2008) | |
Score distribution:
-
Positive: 1,257 out of 2169
-
Mixed: 709 out of 2169
-
Negative: 203 out of 2169
2169
movie
reviews
- By Date
- By Critic Score
-
- David Edelstein
Brokeback Mountain could use a little more of it--by which I mean more sweat and other bodily fluids. Ang Lee's formalism is so extreme that it's often laughable, and the sex is depicted as a holy union: Gay love has never been so sacred.- Slate
- Read full review
-
- David Edelstein
One way you know that D.J. Caruso is a resourceful director is that he scares you silly with a minimum of violence and a few smears of blood. His job was certainly made easier by Morse, whose glassy demeanor and high, soft rasp suggests horrors that not even Quentin Tarantino could imagine.- New York Magazine (Vulture)
- Read full review
-
- David Edelstein
It's on the verge of being really good...his narrative peters out without a decent payoff. It's a testament to the rage and anxieties that he has brilliantly tapped into that he can't get away with a subdued conflagration and a lame twist at the end.- Slate
- Read full review
-
- David Edelstein
Very entertaining (and doesn’t overstay its welcome) but it’s a little depressing to contemplate.- New York Magazine (Vulture)
- Read full review
-
- David Edelstein
This is very much a first feature, with all the hyperbolic, sometimes indiscriminate cinematic energy of a student film. But it's also sensational, a febrile meditation on the mathematics of existence.- Slate
- Read full review
-
- David Edelstein
She's (Jolie) the most amazing special effect in movies. The best thing in Lara Croft: Tomb Raider is a bungee-jumping ballet that Lara performs late at night in her mansion, soaring high and low in Japanese silk pajamas and with her hair pulled tightly back.- Slate
- Read full review
-
- New York Magazine (Vulture)
- Read full review
-
- David Edelstein
A Serious Man is not only hauntingly original, it’s the final piece of the puzzle that is the Coens. Combine suburban alienation, philosophical inquiry, moral seriousness, a mixture of respect for and utter indifference to Torah, and, finally, a ton of dope, and you get one of the most remarkable oeuvres in modern film.- New York Magazine (Vulture)
- Read full review
-
- David Edelstein
For all the horror, it's the drive toward life, not the decay, that lingers in the mind. As a modern heroine, Ree Dolly has no peer, and Winter's Bone is the year's most stirring film.- New York Magazine (Vulture)
- Read full review
-
- David Edelstein
Cooper's performance is outlandishly great, but Phillippe’s knocks Breach down a peg.- New York Magazine (Vulture)
- Read full review
-
- David Edelstein
Praying With Lior engages us on so many levels it transcends its middle-class Jewish milieu.- New York Magazine (Vulture)
- Read full review
-
- David Edelstein
As Bolt, John Travolta is inspired: His voice still cracks like an adolescent’s, and he has the perfect dopey innocence.- New York Magazine (Vulture)
- Read full review
-
- David Edelstein
Unlike your average comic-book blockbuster, The Hulk isn't a bad cartoon. It's a bad modern Greek tragedy. It's a swing at the moon that looks (and smells) like green cheese.- Slate
- Read full review
-
- Slate
- Read full review
-
- David Edelstein
Begins too cruelly and ends too sappily but holds you somewhere between the two extremes until the semisweet finale.- Slate
- Read full review
-
- David Edelstein
The movie would be more bearable without the unyielding score by Clint Mansell, which somehow melds the worst of Minimalism, art rock, and New Age music. It's what you'd hear if your massage therapist wanted to induce a stroke.- New York Magazine (Vulture)
- Read full review
-
- David Edelstein
This is the ultimate female take-back-the-narrative movie, and frankly a lot of it is silly and sophomoric. But it’s also juicy and fun.- New York Magazine (Vulture)
- Read full review
-
- David Edelstein
Head-On doesn't sound like a lot of fun, but it keeps you on edge, laughing nervously, appalled and, against all odds, entertained.- Slate
- Read full review
-
- David Edelstein
The credits had just started and I was already looking for a barf bag.- Slate
- Read full review
-
- David Edelstein
Hot Fuzz is fun, and it's nice to see all the English character actors who aren't busy in Harry Potter films, but it lacks its predecessor's freshness.- New York Magazine (Vulture)
- Read full review
-
- David Edelstein
Spike Lee is a virtuoso filmmaker, a wizard at selling a sequence, but he'll never make an entirely coherent movie until he learns to go deeper into his subjects instead of wider with them.- Slate
- Read full review
-
- David Edelstein
It's no wonder young musicians say they learned to be rock stars from This Is Spinal Tap. It came to satirize and stayed -- and stays on -- to celebrate.- Slate
- Read full review
-
- David Edelstein
I wouldn’t believe that Run, Fat Boy, Run was co-written by Simon Pegg (of Shaun of the Dead and Hot Fuzz) if he weren’t up there on the screen in teeny briefs and with his gut stuck out, trying to endear himself to the American audience in material maybe a notch above Rob Schneider’s.- New York Magazine (Vulture)
- Read full review
-
- David Edelstein
One of those half-straight, half-spoof comic-book extravaganzas that don't ever work, and what's neat is that this one does--beautifully.- Slate
- Read full review
-
- David Edelstein
Hanks and Zemeckis (and writer William Broyles Jr.) are so intent on making an epic of the spirit that they can't bring themselves to acknowledge the comic, narcissistic side of their desert island fantasy. And so on simple, human terms, the picture gets all gummed up.- Slate
- Read full review
-
- David Edelstein
The movie is clipped, blunt, and grimly realistic. It is practically a POLICIER , although the suspense is mitigated by our knowledge that the investigation will end badly.- New York Magazine (Vulture)
- Read full review
-
- David Edelstein
You could get high on this movie's technique, dizzy on its storytelling. Yet it's one of the most lucid bad trips ever made.- Slate
- Read full review
-
- David Edelstein
Liam Neeson has gravely splendid pipes as Ponyo’s father, a once-human wizard who lives underwater and despises humankind for polluting the planet.- New York Magazine (Vulture)
- Read full review