I was excited for FMA:B after hearing it hyped as one of the best shonens around, but in the end found it quite disappointing for several reasons:
- The characters are flat and static. The only one who really changes is Scar, and he's a secondary character at best.
- Each character only has 1 power and they're pretty boring. The main character's main ability is to make a little knifeI was excited for FMA:B after hearing it hyped as one of the best shonens around, but in the end found it quite disappointing for several reasons:
- The characters are flat and static. The only one who really changes is Scar, and he's a secondary character at best.
- Each character only has 1 power and they're pretty boring. The main character's main ability is to make a little knife appear at the end of his arm to punch people with. BO-RING!
- The characters don't grow. The two leads are no more powerful when they fight the last boss than they were at the start of the first episode
- Way too many redundant flashbacks about everyone's tragic backstories (like every other shonen)
- Lack of compelling big-ticket fights, which are supposed to be the main hook of a shonen. Most major confrontations were short and rather dull, with people just fistfighting and using their 1 power. By the end of the series they become really repetitive.
- Too many characters, too little character development
- Generic villain with a generic "shoot a big beam of light into the sky and acquire THE POWER OF THE GODS" villainous scheme
- Animation was so-so. There wasn't much location variety and they were pretty visually bland. No strong sense of place
- Music was serviceable but forgettable
- Too much gore to be suitable for kids, but too simplistic and generic to be entertaining for adults
On the plus side, Winry was cute and I actually thought the chibi bits were pretty funny.… Expand