The Legend of Zelda: Skyward Sword HD

 Switch
User Score
7.3

Mixed or average reviews- based on 700 Ratings

User score distribution:
  1. Positive: 467 out of 700
  2. Mixed: 104 out of 700
  3. Negative: 129 out of 700
Buy Now
Buy on

Review this game

  1. Your Score
    0 out of 10
    Rate this:
    • 10
    • 9
    • 8
    • 7
    • 6
    • 5
    • 4
    • 3
    • 2
    • 1
    • 0
    • 0
  1. Submit
  2. Check Spelling
view
per page
  1. CavemanCossy
    Jul 29, 2021
    8
    Skyward Sword is the final entry in the 3D overworld-to-dungeon exploration Zelda games, before Breath of the Wild truly shook up the formula. If you've played previous entries like Twilight Princess, Wind Waker, or Ocarina of Time, then you know what to expect already. Follow the plot in the overworld while doing some side-quests here and there, go to a dungeon, get an item in thatSkyward Sword is the final entry in the 3D overworld-to-dungeon exploration Zelda games, before Breath of the Wild truly shook up the formula. If you've played previous entries like Twilight Princess, Wind Waker, or Ocarina of Time, then you know what to expect already. Follow the plot in the overworld while doing some side-quests here and there, go to a dungeon, get an item in that dungeon which lets you clear it, culminating in a boss battle. Then, follow the plot again to go to the next dungeon, rinse and repeat. Usually said item from the dungeon also lets you find new paths in the overworld, which is how the game controls player progress and ensures that they follow a set path with minimal freedom to explore. Now this may sound repetitive, and to a certain extent it is, but for the most part it works perfectly fine. The game may not be incredibly original, but it is still engaging and keeps you entertained for the entirety.

    This is due to the story, the environments, improved gameplay, and in particular the sound. The relationship between Link and Zelda feels believable, as they struggle throughout the game to balance their responsibility of saving the land with expressing their implied mutual feelings towards each other. The land is colorful and bright, with the improved framerate and performance of the HD version greatly favoring it. The dungeon design for the most part is incredible and gets better as you progress through more complicated mazes. The graphics do look a bit dated though, but don't detract from the overall art direction. The music in particular still is one of the best soundtracks in the Zelda series, and arguably one of the best orchestral soundtracks in video games in general.

    Furthermore, the HD version introduces gameplay improvements over the Wii version. Most notably is the option to use buttons without any motion controls; moving the right stick draws and points your sword, flicking the right stick slashes in that path, and clicking the left stick lets you use your shield and bash enemies. It does take a bit to get used to, but luckily the game has a practice area at the beginning, and it's a lot more reliable than the motion controls the Wii game had. For what it's worth, the motion controls have also been improved, courtesy of being able to reset the more reliably gyro in the joy-cons with a simple tap of the Y button. This is particularly notable in the sky where you fly on your Loftwing, which was very clunky in the Wii version and is much smoother in the HD version.

    There are a lot of other smaller quality of life improvements too. The beginning of the game was infamously known to be slow, and although it still drags out, it is nice to have the option to fast-forward dialogue and skip cutscenes. In particular all the tutorials and advice notes from Fi (your sword familiar) are completely optional, which greatly saves time when doing a new playthrough in the games higher difficulty. The game now autosaves which means you don't have to constantly hunt bird statues, the only way to save in the original game. All these little things add up to the overall experience and make the game much more fun than the Wii version. One small unfortunate note though, the biggest quality of life improvement is locked behind an amiibo; the one that lets you fly to the skies from any part of the surface that isn't a dungeon. You can do it, but you need to own the Loftwing & Zelda amiibo to do so.

    By the time the original Wii version of Skyward Sword was released, the Zelda overworld-to-dungeon formula was already tried and tested, and it was starting to get stale by this game. Regardless, this is very much so a game worth playing at least once, specially if you have not played or finished the original. It's classic Zelda action, it's fun, and it will keep you entertained for the ~30 hours of gameplay you will find.    … Expand
  2. Nintendopost24
    Jul 29, 2021
    9
    So here we are at the end of this review, and just like the Wii version 10 years ago, this Zelda will be talked about. On many points this opus is part of the pinnacle of the saga (storytelling, dungeons, risk-taking), but its gameplay and its overall rigidity will always be debated. Regardless, The Legend of Zelda Skyward Sword HD is a great video game, a Legend just waiting to beSo here we are at the end of this review, and just like the Wii version 10 years ago, this Zelda will be talked about. On many points this opus is part of the pinnacle of the saga (storytelling, dungeons, risk-taking), but its gameplay and its overall rigidity will always be debated. Regardless, The Legend of Zelda Skyward Sword HD is a great video game, a Legend just waiting to be experienced. Go ahead, you won't regret it!

    Full review, in french, on my blog Nintendo Legacy. You can follow me on Twitter @NintendoLegacy1    … Expand
  3. Zebunker
    Jul 28, 2021
    0
    Watered down port that is essentaily $35 more than when it orginially came out, with the pay 2 win Amiibo you need.
  4. Bleeding_Jester
    Jul 28, 2021
    8
    they did a great job of porting this to the switch the controls are really good with the Pro Controller the only real issue ive had is with the camera and its a minor complaint
  5. Blacklich
    Jul 28, 2021
    9
    Finde Zelda Skyward Sword HD sehr gut abgesehen von dem Vollpreis.
    Die Knopfsteuerung ist nach einer Eingewöhnung gut zu Steuern.
  6. Timoerik3
    Jul 27, 2021
    10
    This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. This game is fantastic
    The Boss fites are varry good and ITs zelda so that's a 10    … Expand
  7. JuanaPalotes
    Jul 26, 2021
    10
    If this is your first time playing this game, I would absolutely recommend it, if not I would recommend it too!
  8. Flakegriffn
    Jul 26, 2021
    10
    Amazing game with amazing story telling! Glad they brought this over to help the new generation try out the first Zelda in the timeline!
  9. cc2224
    Jul 26, 2021
    10
    I already liked Skyward Sword back from the old Wii days. It also is one of my all-time favorite Zelda games, so I was looking forward to the HD version and in my opinion they totally delivered. It is so nice to see the locations from the past in HD graphics but the biggest positive change is the new motion control. It is way easier to handle than in the past and so fixes one of theI already liked Skyward Sword back from the old Wii days. It also is one of my all-time favorite Zelda games, so I was looking forward to the HD version and in my opinion they totally delivered. It is so nice to see the locations from the past in HD graphics but the biggest positive change is the new motion control. It is way easier to handle than in the past and so fixes one of the biggest problems of the original.… Expand
  10. revadb
    Jul 26, 2021
    10
    A great game in 2011, still a great game 10 years later.
    The QoL improvements really expedite the slower parts of the game experience, and replayability is much simpler with the ability to skip cutscenes. The visual really stand out in 1080p, 60fps.
    Finally, this game is always worth it just for having the best story in the series!
  11. scrump
    Jul 26, 2021
    9
    As a Zelda fan who missed this version, I have been hooked so far. Look forward to playing. Classic Zelda vibe with unique features. The only part that is annoying is the camera and having to move it around to focus. Since I didn't play it before I don't mind paying the full price, but if you owned it before I see no point in buying it again.
  12. agramonte
    Jul 25, 2021
    6
    There is just no way around it. The controls are awful. You would think that coming from Nintendo there would be a better solution than this. The flying, fighting, exploring... nothing feels natural.

    You stick with it and fumble along with the controls (well, mostly because it is a “Zelda” game), just to realize that the games has you backtracking and padding even the most trivial    There is just no way around it. The controls are awful. You would think that coming from Nintendo there would be a better solution than this. The flying, fighting, exploring... nothing feels natural.

    You stick with it and fumble along with the controls (well, mostly because it is a “Zelda” game), just to realize that the games has you backtracking and padding even the most trivial things... suffocating what fun you had managed to pull out of it a few moments before - basically insult to injury.

    I also find it crazy that one of the few quality of life update is locked behind a $25 Amiibo. For a game with no new content, barely a visual upgrade and a full $60 price tag - placing it as an extra DLC is just greedy. No idea how Nintendo is getting a pass on this,

    It is ok to skip this Zelda.... Again.    … Expand
  13. LudwigBeethoven
    Jul 25, 2021
    8
    One thing is for sure. This is more of a Zelda game than BOTW will ever be. Its rough around the edges, but the dungeons are some of the best in the entire series, which makes it worth playing.
  14. PimmyPete
    Jul 25, 2021
    10
    Not the best zelda game, but a lot of fun. I put in a 10 because so many people put in bad reviews, in fact, the original reviews were better, and the original game is unpolished. Totally worth the price. This game has about 10000x more effort put into it than most of these negative reviews do.
  15. profittsc
    Jul 25, 2021
    1
    The controls are awful in this game and make it a literal chore to play. Everything revolves around gimmick motion controls that in 2021 just don't hold up. The game is just almost unplayable, for example you have to run around with the L trigger held down just to be able to navigate the camera. Also the sword controls are terrible and just not fun at all, everything depends on you movingThe controls are awful in this game and make it a literal chore to play. Everything revolves around gimmick motion controls that in 2021 just don't hold up. The game is just almost unplayable, for example you have to run around with the L trigger held down just to be able to navigate the camera. Also the sword controls are terrible and just not fun at all, everything depends on you moving your sword in a certain way. Like diagonal up left or diagonal up right or diagonal down left or right or straight up or straight down. It gets really old, really fast !! I am not a Nintendo hater, I loved BOTW and many of the Mario games. Skyward Sword though just does not work at all, maybe if it was $15 dollars in a bargain bin but not a $60 stand alone game.… Expand
  16. Davidq
    Jul 25, 2021
    6
    I am a huge fan of the saga and this is not a good remastered, they have made big improvements over the original, but for a game revived in 2021 at this price it is not enough. They could further improve the graphics, the camera, the controls (which are really awkward and cumbersome) and add some innovations taking inspiration from Btow, but they didn't do it and this makes me sad ... TheI am a huge fan of the saga and this is not a good remastered, they have made big improvements over the original, but for a game revived in 2021 at this price it is not enough. They could further improve the graphics, the camera, the controls (which are really awkward and cumbersome) and add some innovations taking inspiration from Btow, but they didn't do it and this makes me sad ... The game is not to be rejected, but it certainly does not deserve 8-9. I hope that Nintendo returns to being what it once was, returns to being the Nintedo of Iwata and that you remember that in addition to the money there are also the players who have always loved and supported it.… Expand
  17. Asdrubbale
    Jul 25, 2021
    8
    It wasn't perfect in 2011 and, of course, it still isn't. The big problem remains the control system. In the most agitated moments it is not possible to do exactly what you want, in other situations, to meet the particular use of the sword, the enemies use patterns that ruin the atmosphere of the fight. Let's talk about the positives: the art direction is wonderful, the music is amazing,It wasn't perfect in 2011 and, of course, it still isn't. The big problem remains the control system. In the most agitated moments it is not possible to do exactly what you want, in other situations, to meet the particular use of the sword, the enemies use patterns that ruin the atmosphere of the fight. Let's talk about the positives: the art direction is wonderful, the music is amazing, the dungeons are inspired and the story finally gives roots to the legend of Zelda. If you are a fan of the saga it is a "must-play". If you're not, it still remains a very good game but you can safely avoid playing it.… Expand
  18. Kvr
    Jul 25, 2021
    10
    A great Zelda game! Has everything that a fan of the series will love. Great world, great music, funny npcs, rewarding sidequests, collectables! Amazing dungeons. Really nice story. This Zelda has it all!
  19. thedaarkbatty
    Jul 25, 2021
    0
    I played it for the first time last year and was shocked by how bad the graphics were. Seriousl, games released in 2008 have better graphics and effects than this garbage. Not to mention the gameplay is boring and unoirinal. I got about 30 minutes in before quitting. It's so hard because the controls suck. 0/10.
  20. Davesreview83
    Jul 24, 2021
    0
    Shamless cash grab that's over priced because Nintendo knows your going to buy the game
  21. zenn22
    Jul 24, 2021
    0
    absolute garbage, spent 3hrs wondering around with no idea where to go, omegalul
  22. Ughduty
    Jul 24, 2021
    4
    Boss battles are a pain in the a.. even after you somewhat got over the bad control scheme. There is nothing that really prepares you for them.
  23. DonnieTrump
    Jul 24, 2021
    8
    Yes, this game is better than you actually remembered!

    Did you know that – although there have been multiple Zelda release the last decade – Breath of the Wild is the only 'new' 3D Zelda that Nintendo has created in the last ten years? I didn't play the re-releases of the HD-versions of Twilight Princess and The Wind Waker and that means that Skyward Sword HD is my second 3D Zelda in a    Yes, this game is better than you actually remembered!

    Did you know that – although there have been multiple Zelda release the last decade – Breath of the Wild is the only 'new' 3D Zelda that Nintendo has created in the last ten years? I didn't play the re-releases of the HD-versions of Twilight Princess and The Wind Waker and that means that Skyward Sword HD is my second 3D Zelda in a decade. This is probably also the reason why I look at this HD-game with an entire new set of eyes.

    Reviews tend to be a descriptive analysis about a sequence of events in a game, but rarely a review describes the emotional experience a gamer is going through and that's why I want to focus on this aspect of gaming. After all, it's the game experience that is mostly valued by a gamer when playing a game. And the most defining aspect of a Zelda game is without a doubt its dungeons. These places test your wits and combat abilities in the most imaginative way possible. Certainly in Skyward Sword that has some of the best designed dungeons in the entire series.

    Ten years ago my opinion about the dungeons in Skyward Sword was mixed. Although I really like the design I was a bit disappointed with how easy some of the dungeons were. This is the era of the Wii we're talking about where the Super Guide was the norm and Nintendo tried to be as casual friendly as possible. Although the difficulty grade of the dungeons in Skyward Sword pales in comparison with Ocarina of Time or Twilight Princess it more than makes up for it with brilliantly designed dungeons. Some dungeons are designed with a big central room in mind where the puzzle is to go through all the smaller rooms in order to to activate a switch – or something else – in the big central room. Gone are the days with block puzzles and new puzzle elements are introduced with new weapons like the Beetle.

    The Beetle is a flying device that does some classic Zelda stuff such as activating switches, but also enables the capability to explore a room by flying through it. Later the Beetle is upgraded so it can carry bombs. Ideal for blowing up enemies or creating new paths by blowing up statues and other things. A decade ago Skyward Sword was criticized for keeping the same formularic design of the Zelda series, but it's in fact one of the most refreshing experiences in the series up until Breath of the Wild destroyed all conventions and re-established the series as an open world game.

    The design of the dungeons is complemented with a really wonderful art style that gives the game an unparalleled atmosphere in the dungeons. Ten years ago this game was described as a watercolour painting, but this was also done in order to mask the limitations of the Wii. With upscaled textures in HD and a very fluid sixty frames per second the HD-version of Skyward Sword finally gets the graphical style it truly deserves. Seeing the vibrant colours in the Earth Temple in a fluid motion is a joy for the eyes. The HD-version is – even more so than the original – a painting that comes to life.

    The most fun I had in the game was in the Laynaru Desert with the help of the time crystals. In a limited radius of these crystals objects and creatures come to life in an otherwise dead environment. The creative application of these time crystals result in some of the best puzzles and moments of the entire game. Some of the most challenging puzzles in the Zelda series are related to switching to past and current time in the Sandship. And did I also say there's some fun to be had with some mine carts?

    A special mention is also reserved for the last dungeon, Skyview. This is literally a jigsaw puzzle where rooms have to be connected in a maze-like structure. Each room is in old Zelda fashion themed after a certain area of the game and the difficulty grade is slightly increased. One or two rooms can be even called challenging, but seasoned Zelda veterans will find Skyward Sword too easy. I share that opinion, but it doesn't impact my enjoyment of the game for a bit. As you have read the last couple of paragraphs: I liked the dungeons, a lot!

    Then there are the small 'quality of life' improvements that have a considerable impact on the game. Plenty of people have already discussed this so I won't spend too much time on this. I can only say it makes the game a much more fluid experience making Skyward Sword HD the definitive edition of this game.

    For my conclusion I would like to come back to the statement of valuing game experience. As flawed as Skyward Sword is I really enjoyed my time with the game. Eighty to eighty-five percent of my time in Grooseland was a wonderful experience where I enjoyed the brilliant design of the dungeons and great atmosphere. The end of the game is a bit of a letdown with a series of fetch quests, but gets a quality boost at the very end with a fun final dungeon and the most moving story of the franchise.    … Expand
  24. Andreas1305
    Jul 24, 2021
    8
    The game is way better as most other reviewers are saying. Yeah it is expensive for a port, but the new motion controls for Switch are very nice and felt pretty refreshing.
    I definitely endorse playing the game, for the story alone. The music is great and the visuals are pretty good on Switch.
  25. Hassan123
    Jul 24, 2021
    0
    The game not ready to be play and also with this price is too much for port
  26. Syhlcam
    Jul 24, 2021
    8
    The Legend of Zelda Skyward Sword HD est un excellent jeu. Un jeu qui a tout le potentiel de se refaire une seconde jeunesse via cette sortie sur Nintendo Switch.

    Le choix d’avoir soit le motion gaming pour jouer comme il a été initialement pensé ou aux boutons, permet à tous d’y joué. Bien que le jeu ait 10 ans, excepté quelques défauts graphiques, ce lissage HD lui fait le plus grand    The Legend of Zelda Skyward Sword HD est un excellent jeu. Un jeu qui a tout le potentiel de se refaire une seconde jeunesse via cette sortie sur Nintendo Switch.

    Le choix d’avoir soit le motion gaming pour jouer comme il a été initialement pensé ou aux boutons, permet à tous d’y joué. Bien que le jeu ait 10 ans, excepté quelques défauts graphiques, ce lissage HD lui fait le plus grand bien.

    L’aventure qu’il nous conte, d’une grande importance pour la licence. Narrant la genèse de bien des éléments essentiels de la série. Il offre une très bonne expérience de jeu, via des donjons et des énigmes très les plus travaillé.

    Pour ceux qu’ils l’ont déjà fait sur Wii il n’est pas essentiel, mais pour les autres vous pouvez y aller.

    Avis complet >> https://www.geekexperience.fr/tag/avis/    … Expand
  27. Sabrewulf1
    Jul 24, 2021
    10
    The most under rated of the Zelda games, I remember purchasing this for my wii but never finished it because It was right at the back end of the wii life and I had purchased a ps3 and a then a wii u. Nintendo have absolutely smashed it out of the park again like they did with wind waker hd. You can feel the DNA of the last ocarina style game, the music and jumping is right out of ocarina,The most under rated of the Zelda games, I remember purchasing this for my wii but never finished it because It was right at the back end of the wii life and I had purchased a ps3 and a then a wii u. Nintendo have absolutely smashed it out of the park again like they did with wind waker hd. You can feel the DNA of the last ocarina style game, the music and jumping is right out of ocarina, with added bells. Feels like the more adult link from Twilight with an art style between windwaker and ocarina. But the way nintendo has had the gfx touched up is sublime. I loved BOTW (500 hours in, total completion) and I'm also pretty old, so when the first zelda came out on NES in '86 (I was 13) it blew my mind. This variation of links travels was unloved and wrong so. Its a classic. The dna of the wii is here with the motion controls, and I hope that we see more games from wii come over, becuase the motion controls actually really work well on the joycons. The nostalgia trip is jedi levels of fun, but the core game is right there, and will smash a smile on your face in that way only nintentdo seem to do. Perfection remaster.… Expand
  28. FortyOneDZ
    Jul 24, 2021
    10
    Once you get over the initial learning curve of the motion controls, there is a gripping story to get lost in.
  29. Flumazenil
    Jul 24, 2021
    10
    This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Fantastic game! Skyward sword is the beginning! Great story, development and puzzles! I love it. And they enhanced and improved the control system.… Expand
  30. Vanta77
    Jul 23, 2021
    2
    The most frustrating and boring 3D Zelda, a game that throws you endlessly in same areas/bosses the whole entire game. Cool updates to graphics but way too pricey.

    Should've done the same like they did with Mario Galaxy last year, but they wanted to max profit from Zelda fans
  31. SuperkenGaming
    Jul 23, 2021
    8
    Legend of Zelda Skyward Sword HD
    Too much game
    Legend of Zelda Skyward Sword is a 20 hour long action adventure game staring link, and in a way this is a bit of an origin story, timeline wise this is the first Legend of Zelda game to play, Basically you want to be a brave knight, Zelda gets captures, you gotta rescue her and save the world at the same time kinda story, so you hop on your    Legend of Zelda Skyward Sword HD
    Too much game
    Legend of Zelda Skyward Sword is a 20 hour long action adventure game staring link, and in a way this is a bit of an origin story, timeline wise this is the first Legend of Zelda game to play, Basically you want to be a brave knight, Zelda gets captures, you gotta rescue her and save the world at the same time kinda story, so you hop on your giant bird, and fall down to the land below.. .first impressions, this game is awkwards to play, whether its motion controls, or pro controller, it never.. and I mean never.. feels right to play, youll be slashing and rolling, using objects you unlock as you progress the game, none of it ever feels good.. the camera controls are awkward, and don’t even get me started on the rope swinging… you will be frustrated playing this game for its feel alone… but its that Nintendo magic that kept pulling me through, at least in the first area, the green forests, and the water, hunting down these forest creature, I loved if.. so nostalgic and magic feeling.. and then theres the rest of the game, deserts, factories, and dungeons, boring.. dull… I hate, and I mean hate, the dungeons here in skyward sword, theyre all needlessly convoluted, climbing through room after room, throwing this switch then that switch, so oyu can mov onto the next room to do the same, deal with annoing enemies to get to a new switch to pull, and run back to a previous room to open a door andpull its switch till you pull all of the switches and fights the boss…it all feels just so overwhelming and too much, so you get through all 3 main dungeons and then the game wants you to go back to previous area you’ve already been to, redo dungeons with a twist.. nah.. I hated doing it the first time, oi definitely don’t wanna do it a second time…
    That being said, Skyward Sword does offer a magical world that’s hard to put down, youll want to explore, find its secrets and get to this games amazing conclusion and twist.. but the awardsness f the gameplay mechanics and the constant dungeons make skwayrd sword feel like a chore to get through, this game should’ve been half the length, its too much, its overwhelming and frustrating, and never satisfying to get through, youll never think wow I cant believe I did all of that, youll think wow I hated that and I sure hope there isn’t more of that, but there is, its practically the whole game with only a tiny break and relized magic halfway through once oyu can swim underwater, but then its back to boring annoying dungeons…
    Skyward Sword is a great game, it really is, But theres plenty of fat here that needs trimmed…
    I give Legend of Zelda Skyward Sword HD
    an 8/10    … Expand
  32. rbs12
    Jul 23, 2021
    9
    Very solid Zelda game with lots of charm. Looks really nice in 1080p and 60 fps. I only give it a 9 due to the sometimes frustrating controls. I won’t be pouring anywhere near as many hours as I did in Breath of the Wild but that doesn’t matter, still a really rewarding experience to play.
  33. Legrand
    Jul 23, 2021
    9
    Un clásico de la saga Zelda ahora en Switch no es el mejor port que han hecho pero sigue siendo uno de los juegos más importantes de la sagaa
  34. bound4earth
    Jul 23, 2021
    0
    Talk about a cash-grab, they added no controller controls that work well and things like the flying roach aren't even fun to use. They keep saying how can we use the wii-mote, but never asked themselves, does this really add anything or equal more fun, and when you reach the no conclusion, ask why are we doing this? You can argue this game led to BoTW all you want, but it still makes it aTalk about a cash-grab, they added no controller controls that work well and things like the flying roach aren't even fun to use. They keep saying how can we use the wii-mote, but never asked themselves, does this really add anything or equal more fun, and when you reach the no conclusion, ask why are we doing this? You can argue this game led to BoTW all you want, but it still makes it a bad Zelda game. Tell me the first boss fight is fun and dynamic, oh wait... No it demonstrates how Link is no longer agile and the control scheme, even with Wii-mote controls is beyond flawed.

    It says HD but they didn't even try, the door textures like garbage. It would be worth $15, because they upgraded and changed nothing, but considering that, this is the new president telling fans to pay him $60 for nothing. Legit a zero effort cash-grab that fanboys will eat up. truly sad what they put up with and because of that, you will continue to see low effort trash like this and Mario All Stars, which also changed nothing and destroyed that name.    … Expand
  35. xrenderman
    Jul 23, 2021
    2
    One of the worst "AAA" games I ever played. First of all, it's super annoying. Repetitive animations, tedious time filters like super slaw climbing. Unskippable dialogs and cut scenes. This bird that you need to fly for 5 minutes to and from the island every time to "fast" travel. Motion controls just don't work properly. New button controls are also not at all comfortable. Every time youOne of the worst "AAA" games I ever played. First of all, it's super annoying. Repetitive animations, tedious time filters like super slaw climbing. Unskippable dialogs and cut scenes. This bird that you need to fly for 5 minutes to and from the island every time to "fast" travel. Motion controls just don't work properly. New button controls are also not at all comfortable. Every time you pick something up - again, same long unskippable animation. I could overcome all of this if the gameplay was good. But no. Combat is the pain in the ass because of motion. Puzzles are so primitive that doesn't require any brain activity. Visually it looks just awful. HD in a name is a joke. Everything is blurry and most of the time it's not a texture but just one color fill of a huge surface. The only good thing about this game is the music.… Expand
  36. Starfree
    Jul 22, 2021
    9
    All they did was improve the game. And the quality of life improvements make me want to hug Fi instead of kill her. This is the best way to play Skyward Sword.
  37. deplorable
    Jul 22, 2021
    4
    I'm not sure what nintendo were thinking. Take the worst Zelda 3D game we've ever made and re release it on the switch. I mean the HD graphics... do... nothing. I mean there's only a little difference to what we saw almost a decade ago. I feel sorry for Zelda, HD does not work well on her model.. looks like Ashlee Simpson before the nose job.

    Don't worry they improved the controls...    I'm not sure what nintendo were thinking. Take the worst Zelda 3D game we've ever made and re release it on the switch. I mean the HD graphics... do... nothing. I mean there's only a little difference to what we saw almost a decade ago. I feel sorry for Zelda, HD does not work well on her model.. looks like Ashlee Simpson before the nose job.

    Don't worry they improved the controls... no. no they didn't. I don't know how they managed it but they made the controls worse. I guess if you want to play with the joycons you can go with the terrible game design of waving your hands around like you're a legend in LARP but, that's just bad game design.

    If you want to play it with a controller, first of all the Right stick is not your camera, no because the right stick controls the sword (badly). If you want to use the camera, you gotta hold down another button and use the right stick, but careful in battle because the right stick is also your sword. Do you see the problem.. that's just the beginning.

    This should have stayed in the archives. They've managed to make a mediocre zelda game worse. Give us wind waker... please. maybe i'll forgive.

    Hell i couldn't even bring myself to even buy this game this time, i rented it from boomerang. There's no way i was paying nintendo for a decade old game that i remembered being terrible at the time. And i was half right, i didn't exactly expect them to make it worse. I mean that takes skill and talent.

    Maybe we are spoiled in how good BoW is... and how great it is. But i can play OoT on my DS as a remake, handles and plays fine. I can dust off my gamecube and play wind waker... brilliant zelda game along with twilight princess.

    I put this into my switch, and i just want to play any other game... hell i'd play jon trons bootleg games instead. Nintendo wanted a pay day with this, and they probably got it. But for the future of gaming, it's just another step backwards....

    I'm not sure whose rating this a 10 though, i mean rose tinted glasses are one thing - completely deluded is another. I hope they get the help they desperately need. You rate a game what it is... you don't look at the average and go "bump it up". That's not how it works, a game should stand on its own two feet...    … Expand
  38. snallegub
    Jul 22, 2021
    4
    DO NOT BUY THIS GAME. The game nearly is unplayable. You need to reset the motion sensor every 10 seconds. The rope walks for example is pure torture. Every time you try to aim you start by hitting the reset button to get the motion controls to work. You can disable those but then YOU CANNOT TURN THE CAMERA! That is because the sword is then controlled by the right thumb stick. This gameDO NOT BUY THIS GAME. The game nearly is unplayable. You need to reset the motion sensor every 10 seconds. The rope walks for example is pure torture. Every time you try to aim you start by hitting the reset button to get the motion controls to work. You can disable those but then YOU CANNOT TURN THE CAMERA! That is because the sword is then controlled by the right thumb stick. This game is pure agony avoid at all costs. Nobody ever wanted these motion controls and this game should never have been ported.… Expand
  39. Clyle2046
    Jul 21, 2021
    9
    This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. After playing this game and beating it while using solely motion controls, I can say that this is a very notable Iteration of the Zelda series. From the vibrant colors and great story line to the beloved dungeons and climax of the master sword and Hylian shield, I recommend this game to every and any player. This game reminded me of the love I had for the intricate dungeons and the awesome feeling of getting weapons that are key to the progression. The Final Boss fight…Man I wish Nintendo redid the BOTW boss fight because the previous zelda’s before it really nailed that category. Anyway, give the game a fair chance and try the motion controls. At the end of this game, I loved it so much I went ahead and bought the skyward sword joy-cons to pay homage to this awesome game + give Nintendo more money lol.… Expand
  40. joash
    Jul 21, 2021
    10
    This game is for you if you:
    - Love a good story
    - Love beautiful art directions
    - Love epic music
    - Love Zelda games
    - Love video games
    - Love fun
  41. dharma
    Jul 21, 2021
    8
    When it was released, I absolutely adores Skyward Sword and has no problem with its motion controls. Back in the days, I always thought that the Wii was a great revelation, and it was the console that brought me back to the hobby after many years of hiatus. So I am absolutely ecstatic when Nintendo decides to re release this game, remastered on the Switch. Now, I can see that SkywardWhen it was released, I absolutely adores Skyward Sword and has no problem with its motion controls. Back in the days, I always thought that the Wii was a great revelation, and it was the console that brought me back to the hobby after many years of hiatus. So I am absolutely ecstatic when Nintendo decides to re release this game, remastered on the Switch. Now, I can see that Skyward Sword is akin to the Wii U...a prototype of a something better (in this case, the Breath of the Wild), hampered by the limitations imposed on the system. Many people complained about the lack of thereof of available areas....well, it was made for the Wii after all. So to cut things short: great set pieces, dungeons and environments. The 'new' button controls are not as good as you thought and still require a high learning curve. Also due to its lack of environments, fetch quests galore in many areas of the game, hence its repetitive nature in some parts. For those still on the fence, not the best Zelda games, but it is a must play as a precursor to BOTW.… Expand
  42. Botwfan2
    Jul 21, 2021
    10
    I love this game. I wasn't too crazy about it when it came out on the Wii, but man is it much better now. It removed the Blurry backgrounds of the original, the text boxes have names so I know who's speaking now, and Fi is mostly optional! I didn't mind the motion controls on the Wii, but they're better now so i like them, and the button controls are perfect for when i want to lay down andI love this game. I wasn't too crazy about it when it came out on the Wii, but man is it much better now. It removed the Blurry backgrounds of the original, the text boxes have names so I know who's speaking now, and Fi is mostly optional! I didn't mind the motion controls on the Wii, but they're better now so i like them, and the button controls are perfect for when i want to lay down and play the game in bed. I still to this day think its story is the best in any Zelda game, and the way its presented is incredible. sure the exploration is sacrificed a bit for that, but i think its worth it. 10/10 would recommend… Expand
  43. Noitamies
    Jul 21, 2021
    0
    First Nintendo licensed game I sell straight away. Masochist. I played 5 hours. You cant just do such awful controls. It's not a game when you cant play it.
  44. SporadicDeviant
    Jul 21, 2021
    10
    I've already written a review of the original Wii version of the game on this site. and what I said in that review still stands here. Overall this version has some tweaks to the experience. Some are minor like text speed and some are major like framerate, and the ability to use button controls in lieu of motion controls.

    While I think the motion controls in both the original and the    I've already written a review of the original Wii version of the game on this site. and what I said in that review still stands here. Overall this version has some tweaks to the experience. Some are minor like text speed and some are major like framerate, and the ability to use button controls in lieu of motion controls.

    While I think the motion controls in both the original and the remaster not only work exceptionally well but also make the game a true 10 out of 10 experience, it's nice that those who couldn't use the motion controls in the original release (for whatever reason) can now have the chance to experience this wonderful game. Also there's no stick drift with motion controls. Just saying.

    The other changes aren't major unless you're the type who fixates on framerate/graphics. I like the new camera. I was not one of those who thought the item text boxes were a major issue and I knew that Fi's advice and dowsing were mostly optional so a majority of the quality of life changes didn't really "improve" the game for me because I never found those elements to be true objective flaws with the original version. Nevertheless the attempts to make the game more accessible to certain other gamers is admirable.

    If you are one of the people spamming 0's, 1's, or 2's, (because you have terrible taste in games) I advise you not to get your gaming takes from Youtube personalities (that may or may not have multiple This is How You Don't Play compilations dedicated to them).

    Whether on Wii, Wii-U, or Switch, The Legend of Zelda Skyward Sword is an objective masterpiece in terms of story-telling, game design, and especially controls.    … Expand
  45. IncognitoCheez
    Jul 21, 2021
    10
    This is a perfect Legend of Zelda game, and so by extension, also a perfect game. It holds the charm, character, and heartfelt story as when it first released a decade ago. It ties the wonderful story together with it's unique motion controlled gameplay. The HD version has been upgraded so those strange kids who probably put their sensor bar under their couch in the original version canThis is a perfect Legend of Zelda game, and so by extension, also a perfect game. It holds the charm, character, and heartfelt story as when it first released a decade ago. It ties the wonderful story together with it's unique motion controlled gameplay. The HD version has been upgraded so those strange kids who probably put their sensor bar under their couch in the original version can now play with button controls. Literally every complaint has been fixed with this game, aside from rewriting the game itself. The art style holds up stunningly in HD graphics, and this game running at a steady 1080p 60fps makes it just about the best running game on Switch. Having not played, the original game, this is an entirely new Zelda game and story, making it fully worth the 60 dollars. I've only had the game for 3 days and I've already easily sunk 15 hours into it. For fans of BOTW (which come on everyone loves), this is a must-play. This game has everything that makes Zelda games great; the wonderful creative dungeons (no complicated water dungeons!), the great, heartfelt story, the epic and emotional music, and impressive enemies. If you are a fan of Zelda or gaming in general, play this classic adventure that has shaped an entire generation (not many other games can say that can they hmmm?).… Expand
  46. Steyraus
    Jul 21, 2021
    10
    A master peice of a game and now even better at 60 FPs and more control options..
  47. Ryu_san
    Jul 21, 2021
    9
    Controls are still clunky at times, but improved over the Wii version. If you can get over that, then Skyward Sword HD is a great Zelda title with well-designed dungeons, puzzles, music, characters, and a watercolor-inspired art style that makes this much more enjoyable than the original version.
  48. mikeje
    Jul 21, 2021
    3
    если бы игра стоила косарик, другой разговор, а так если очень хочется поиграть, запустите на эмуляторе и пройдите, поверьте ни чего не потеряете
  49. weaselstink
    Jul 21, 2021
    6
    Skyward Sword has a well written story and some clever mechanics at play. The upscaled graphics look good, framerate is consistent.

    The motion controls are fidgety, sometimes unresponsive and require constant recalibration. Combat is more frustrating than a challenge. There are aspects of this game that were clearly put in place just to be a time sink (I'm looking at you underwater    Skyward Sword has a well written story and some clever mechanics at play. The upscaled graphics look good, framerate is consistent.

    The motion controls are fidgety, sometimes unresponsive and require constant recalibration. Combat is more frustrating than a challenge. There are aspects of this game that were clearly put in place just to be a time sink (I'm looking at you underwater notes).

    Skyward sword doesn't feel like much of an adventure, more of a never ending fetch quest sprinkled with puzzles. Worth it for the story, but fun is not a word I would use to describe this game.    … Expand
  50. DPV07
    Jul 20, 2021
    9
    I'm a huge fan of Zelda games, and I know when to notice their flaws, and I'm critic about them when they really hurt my experience without nitpicking like most of these HATERS out here and out there on the internet.

    I never owned or played the original Wii version of Skyward Sword, but now that I finally played it and beaten it today, I can't understand the freaking hate this game    I'm a huge fan of Zelda games, and I know when to notice their flaws, and I'm critic about them when they really hurt my experience without nitpicking like most of these HATERS out here and out there on the internet.

    I never owned or played the original Wii version of Skyward Sword, but now that I finally played it and beaten it today, I can't understand the freaking hate this game gets, specially if this version has fixed things that made people mad such as Fi. I liked Fi, I like the gameplay, music is GREAT as to be expected… Skyward Sword does some things better than the rest of 3D Zelda games (before Breath of the Wild came out), just like other 3D Zelda games do some things better than the others. That's how it has ALWAYS been.

    Skyward sword is MILES from being a BAD game. I will say that right now. I don't hate Twilight Princess, in fact it's one of my personal favorites, but that game is heavily flawed, even more flawed than Skyward Sword is, which I can say now, now that I have finally played it ( it was the last 3D zelda game I had left to play yet ).

    No Zelda game is perfect, and even despite the personal flaws I found myself with this game, I only had a few things that I didn't like about it:
    • Lack of region / zones variety: you only have 3 regions and the sky. The sky only has one big town, which is Skyloft, and very few NPC islands with barely much to do with them. In a way, it's as barren as Wind Waker's great sea was. BUT I WILL DEFINITELY SAY… that the sky in Skyward Sword, is waaay more fun to play around with than the sea from Wind Waker, which was slow and boring after a few hours of playing it. With Skyward Sword, at least the sky is fast to travel for most of your missions and more entertaining and dynamic with the Loftwing ( your bird mount friend ).

    The surface's regions, Eldin, Faron and Lanayru, are only populated by monsters you kill, and the good people in them are about one race at most per region. It makes sense because this is the first game in the timeilne after all, but you would think there would be at least one city or town for each race. You see a few gorons but there isn't a town for them? Like what the hell…

    But again, this was never gonna change in an HD port, so this is just basic complaints that I'm sure I was always gonna have with Skyward Sword.

    This HD port definitely fixes things that I noticed from the original game, and I'm glad my first experience was with these fixes they made.

    As someone whose favorite gaming series in life is Zelda, I easily consider Skyward sword among my top 5 favorite 3D Zelda games. As someone who loves the series, I know what I want from it, I don't just eat whatever they put in my plate that easily, but thankfully none of the 3D Zelda games has left me with a bad taste, like EVER.

    Skyward Sword HD definitely left me with a smile now that I played the first game in the Zelda timeline, the gameplay was fun and I was never bored swinging the sword and using the games' dungeon items, etc.

    This game OOZES with personality ( unlike Twilight princess where almost every character are dead inside and lack personality for the most part… and I say this as someone who still loved that game very much ) and the story is definitely worth playing the game alone as it is.

    If you are a Zelda fan who just wants a neat adventure with great story and fun characters, Skyward Sword should make you happy. The gameplay won't disappoint, sure you will find the lack of region / biomes variety a bit "mehh…" at some points, but most of times you revisit these few areas you are always finding something new to do in them anyway, so it's NOT the end of the world, specially if you liked Wind Waker, then there is no reason why you wouldn't be able to enjoy this game as well.

    Give the game a try, don't nitpick to oblivion, just enjoy the game for what it is and has to offer.

    If the price annoys you so much then have fun playing the outdated version on emulator, or have fun giving your money away to scalpers for the wii version of the game. Hell, I don't understand why you would even want to play a version of the game that has no fixes to the things you will complain EXTRA about (like Fi being annoying), nor be able to play the game on 60fps even. For me, this HD port was totally worth its price. As a Zelda fan, I wouldn't stop myself from experiencing this fun game just because it could be 10$ or 20$ cheaper in some people's minds. If you don't like the price, speak with your wallets, Nintendo is not gonna stop pricing their games for 59.99 just because you won't stop whining about it. It hasn't changed in all these years, it won't change later, speak with your wallet and be quiet about the whole price nonsense, it's TIRING to read.    … Expand
  51. Mrman23
    Jul 20, 2021
    9
    It honestly pains me to see so many people complain and cry about the motion controls still, the motion controls simply put has a 90% probability of being accurate with every swing of the joycon you make. I feel as if most people in sword combat swing the WRONG way, simply explaind people have a tendency (like my friend) to swing left in order to swing a broader right swing! This mistakeIt honestly pains me to see so many people complain and cry about the motion controls still, the motion controls simply put has a 90% probability of being accurate with every swing of the joycon you make. I feel as if most people in sword combat swing the WRONG way, simply explaind people have a tendency (like my friend) to swing left in order to swing a broader right swing! This mistake makes you swing left first making you stagger and do wrong in the game. A simple not so hard fix is to flick from the middle aka holding the joycon straight and flicking left for left and right for right. If you manage to do what I've said and still fail then you're honestly just horrible at direction, because after this rocket-science of a fix (apparently) its just impossible not to make the right swing 90% of the time! I absolutely adored this game playing it in 60fps with a 1080p resolution while engaging in interactive gamplay in which doing a parry with a shield feels so good! The dungeons are great and the music is phenomenal while it's really underrated for stupid and wrong reasons. Some people have complained that aiming in the game can be a hassle since you need to reset the gyro from time to time, but honestly how hard can it be if all you need to do is press "Y" A single time?… Expand
  52. MentalSeiz
    Jul 20, 2021
    10
    It's a great Zelda game which stands tall with the greatest of all time. It has a great story, some awesome dungeons, an amazing soundtrack and fun gameplay. I advise to ignore haters.
  53. Ninbreasy
    Jul 20, 2021
    9
    This remaster is at least a solid 80 out of 100 and has improved in every way on the original game, which was already quite good. Now: 1080p, 60fps, faster loading times, better motion controls, optional joystick controls, faster text, free camera controls, you can skip scenes, Fi is much less annoying, less annoying item info, auto-save, selectable save files and a lot of minor things!This remaster is at least a solid 80 out of 100 and has improved in every way on the original game, which was already quite good. Now: 1080p, 60fps, faster loading times, better motion controls, optional joystick controls, faster text, free camera controls, you can skip scenes, Fi is much less annoying, less annoying item info, auto-save, selectable save files and a lot of minor things!
    Back in the day these issues were the main quality of life complains of many people, which shows that Nintendo listened to his fans and tried to fix the game.

    Of course Skyward Sword (HD) is not perfect at all and has still its annoying flaws.

    It is a pity that there are so many people in this review section rating this game just for its price. If you think 60 bucks is overpriced and Nintendo should be ashamed of it.... you're probably damn right!
    (Ah, and if your joy-con is drifting than fix it! It is actually pretty easy.)

    But these things have nothing to do with the content of this game. Please go ahead and hate Nintendo for the price and the joy-con drift but not the game.    … Expand
  54. BrushedRed
    Jul 20, 2021
    7
    Whoever said that this is better than Breath of the Wild has lost their mind. Lol. But I will say that I am enjoying this HD remake more than the first time I played this on Wii. It's nice to play the game in 60 FPS and in high quality textures. The art style is quite gorgeous and the game has held up well over time.

    Prior to this HD remake, I never finished my original playthrough of    Whoever said that this is better than Breath of the Wild has lost their mind. Lol. But I will say that I am enjoying this HD remake more than the first time I played this on Wii. It's nice to play the game in 60 FPS and in high quality textures. The art style is quite gorgeous and the game has held up well over time.

    Prior to this HD remake, I never finished my original playthrough of the game. I got several hours into the game, but I did not enjoy the controls and I ultimately traded the game in. I had no desire to really get this again, but I had a ton of store credit and just decided to go for it anyway. I was leery of the motion controls, but they seem to work just fine. I am definitely enjoying the non-motion controls. They seemed like they'd be awkard, but they work pretty well once you get the hang of using them.

    Still, a lot of the glaring flaws the game has are present (and there's not much they could've done to fix them). Like, the silent realm, back tracking, repetitive nature. Those things were part of the original game and they're still here. It's not quite as much of a chore this time around, though, because of the controls. I'm looking forward to finishing the game getting all collectables. That's what I've done on all the Zelda games and I intend to continue the tradition.

    But, yeah, it's obvious to see why Nintendo changed the direction of Zelda after this.    … Expand
  55. REMOTER
    Jul 20, 2021
    10
    Do not doubt it. Masterpiece.
    It's been 10 years, but it's a game you can enjoy now.
  56. UmAlguem
    Jul 20, 2021
    10
    Skyward sword is the best zelda game with the link to the past formula and the hd remaster just makes it better
  57. brendanbarrett
    Jul 20, 2021
    9
    Excellent remake. The button controls become more intuitive after about 5 hours. The frame rate is steadily 60 FPS. More importantly, the game is just great.
  58. Ryzar
    Jul 20, 2021
    6
    As a preface, I've only played up to the second dungeon using the pro controller. In my opinion, the motion controls of Link's sword don't map well onto the analog stick and holding L+ right analog stick to move the camera doesn't feel very intuitive. Nintendo should have removed every component of Skyward Sword which was reliant on motion controls and remade the game catering aAs a preface, I've only played up to the second dungeon using the pro controller. In my opinion, the motion controls of Link's sword don't map well onto the analog stick and holding L+ right analog stick to move the camera doesn't feel very intuitive. Nintendo should have removed every component of Skyward Sword which was reliant on motion controls and remade the game catering a traditional button controller. In its current state, I wouldn't recommend it - not at full price anyway. Having said that, I love the story-driven, dungeon aspect of this game and one can only hope Nintendo strikes the right balance in the next iteration of the Zelda series. Hopefully, breath of the wild 2 will embrace its roots once again and combine it with the "open-air" vibe that a lot of people seem to like.… Expand
  59. SaigonBrit
    Jul 19, 2021
    0
    This is a beautiful looking and buttery smooth 60fps update of the original game with some welcome tweaks in terms of pacing, UI, quality of life improvements such as autosave and a lot less forced interventions/tutorials/reminders. It does lack open world exploration but the dungeons are among the best ever for any Zelda game and the soundtrack is regal (full orchestral score). The motionThis is a beautiful looking and buttery smooth 60fps update of the original game with some welcome tweaks in terms of pacing, UI, quality of life improvements such as autosave and a lot less forced interventions/tutorials/reminders. It does lack open world exploration but the dungeons are among the best ever for any Zelda game and the soundtrack is regal (full orchestral score). The motion controls can be ditched in favour of standard JoyCon or Pro Controller but you can still use gyro aiming for arrows, hookshot and so forth- excellent and far better than the old motion controls. Also, the story/narrative is easily the most developed and engaging of any Zelda game. It's not perfect but it is nearly perfect- 9 out of 10.… Expand
  60. manuel29
    Jul 19, 2021
    10
    A wonderful remaster, the controls are perfect, the improvements of qol have made a good game even more enjoyable. Although years have passed, motion control continues to entertain and has been a beautiful rediscovery. I would have put 9 but there are trolls...
  61. walbusch
    Jul 19, 2021
    10
    This is a great rework of the wii version almost all of the original issues from the wii version have been fixed. If you tried the original version and stopped cause of any of the many annoying issues I recommend coming back to try this new version as almost all the issues have been fixed.

    The story of Skyward Sword is by far the best of any in the Zelda universe and for that reason    This is a great rework of the wii version almost all of the original issues from the wii version have been fixed. If you tried the original version and stopped cause of any of the many annoying issues I recommend coming back to try this new version as almost all the issues have been fixed.

    The story of Skyward Sword is by far the best of any in the Zelda universe and for that reason alone it is worth picking up. The only major issue in my opinion is the having some quality of life functionality locked behind an amiibo however I have not found this to be an issue in my playthrough.

    In summary I think that this version deserves the score that the wii version got.    … Expand
  62. ocd_reviewer
    Jul 19, 2021
    0
    The quality of life improvements are definitely appreciated, but nothing that's being brought to the table can remotely justify the current price tag. Recent remakes like Mass Effect: LE, Mafia: DE, and Resident Evil 2/3 are offering so much more for a similar price tag.

    This would be a fine package if it was cheaper, but prices set expectations and Nintendo has failed to deliver.    The quality of life improvements are definitely appreciated, but nothing that's being brought to the table can remotely justify the current price tag. Recent remakes like Mass Effect: LE, Mafia: DE, and Resident Evil 2/3 are offering so much more for a similar price tag.

    This would be a fine package if it was cheaper, but prices set expectations and Nintendo has failed to deliver. Nintendo at the very least could have bundled an art book and soundtrack with this game, that would have gone a long way to justify the value on top of being a true celebration of this title's legacy.

    Pick this up if you're a big LOZ fan, otherwise, I would recommend waiting till it goes on sale for $45 or lower    … Expand
  63. Link_the_garden
    Jul 19, 2021
    9
    I never got off skyloft the first attempt and playing this so was really keen to give this a go. I'm about 5 hours in, playing with motion controls and I'm slowly getting used to it. I really think the controls are the only thing that lets this game down.
  64. GreenMenace
    Jul 19, 2021
    10
    Skyward Sword [SS] isn’t a game for everyone. With that out of the way, let me tell you why SS is my favorite Zelda game from my favorite franchise.

    First I’ll acknowledge its flaws. You can read other reviews and get a very solid understanding of those so I won’t waste your time. Most of them are correct. I would add that I would have liked more monster variety as well as more things    Skyward Sword [SS] isn’t a game for everyone. With that out of the way, let me tell you why SS is my favorite Zelda game from my favorite franchise.

    First I’ll acknowledge its flaws. You can read other reviews and get a very solid understanding of those so I won’t waste your time. Most of them are correct. I would add that I would have liked more monster variety as well as more things to do in the sky as the sky and its islands feel relatively empty.

    I loved Skyward Sword because of its story. It doesn’t do anything extraordinary, but it attempts to develop characters and introduce plot twists. In my opinion, any Zelda game without Ganon as its main enemy already deserves some attention. The characters are as goofy in this installment as other Zelda games. This game also stands out from the rest because it started to break away from the old Zelda formula that had been established.

    And while mandatory motion controls were/are unpopular, SS is the only Zelda that features them, creating an experience you can’t get with any other Zelda. The game was my first Zelda experience that had a hard mode. Two of the dungeons in the game are in my top three dungeons list (and I’ve played most Zelda games out there since A Link to the Past). Finally, I’d argue that the ending of the game was as epic as Zelda gets. This is a fantastic game that’s only getting better with the remaster. Not only that, but the game will also somehow be connected the next game in the series I’m super excited for—BOTW 2.

    SS was my favorite game on the Wii. On the switch I’m roughly 18 hours in. The game looks more crisp, it runs smoothly, and it’s now portable. The button controls work well, but they take away from the immersion factor that the game aimed for. The motion controls work, but because joy cons are uncomfortable for me to hold, I find myself using button controls most of the time. I’d recommend switching to motion controls for big events in the game like bosses.

    The game feels a lot faster paced since a lot of the wordiness can now be rushed or even skipped entirely at times. And the free roaming camera adds a lot to the experience as well.

    In conclusion, if you’re on the fence about considering giving SS a shot, I’ll wrap up with these thoughts. SS is a differently paced game from most Zelda games. Since it is a little slower with compact environments, it’s not a game for everyone. It places a different emphasis than BOTW. It doesn’t offer much to players who want to explore, but it offers an immersion factor, great dungeons, and good music. The story of SS is more important than any other mainline Zelda game. While marketing has focused on comparing the game to BOTW, I think it’s much more comparable to Twilight Princess. SS may not have aged as well as other remastered Zeldas, but it’s still a fantastic game and was a no brainer preorder for me.    … Expand
  65. colee909
    Jul 19, 2021
    1
    It looks like a 2021 link running through a gross blurry Wii world. Button controls SUCK and are completely unintuitive. The biggest improvements are to thinks like Fi and skipping cutscenes, which were inexcusable upon release, so acting like these are significant improvements is really disingenuous. Is the game better than the Wii version? I mean sure I guess. But I promise it's not thatIt looks like a 2021 link running through a gross blurry Wii world. Button controls SUCK and are completely unintuitive. The biggest improvements are to thinks like Fi and skipping cutscenes, which were inexcusable upon release, so acting like these are significant improvements is really disingenuous. Is the game better than the Wii version? I mean sure I guess. But I promise it's not that much better, especially compared to the $20 Virtual console release on Wii u… Expand
  66. MAM10
    Jul 19, 2021
    10
    one of the best zelda games it holds a special spot among zelda games. The game is fun with fantastic story and awesome music.
    with improved motion control and much better graphics now it deserves a 10.
  67. somepapi
    Jul 19, 2021
    0
    This review contains spoilers, click expand to view. Skyward Sword originally on the Wii of course had its flaws, the motion controls weren’t super fluid if you were incompetent and couldn’t figure out how to set it up. And it was really annoying to sit through tiny little interruptions every few steps you took unlike Ocarina of Time where Navi was ignorable. This time around in the HD remaster, you can be incompetent and still use the motion controls, and Fi shuts up. Unfortunately this comes at a cost, the accuracy and fluidity is all gone. The aiming constantly drifts with the Gust Bellows or the Beetle. And this isn’t due to stick drift it’s just general bad gyro drift that happens a lot in even some other titles. The motion controls for the bird and sky diving is bearable and the swimming sections aren’t too bad. But they aren’t what they used to be. The game does look really good being now of course in HD and 60fps…. for the most part. During the fire spider boss in the 2nd dungeon it lagged whenever I got close and looked at too many fire balls being thrown my way. It’s really depressing when I see a Nintendo original title, being incapable of being fully played at a constant and clean rate on its own console. On to other reviews i’ve seen, Nintendo almost literally payed off so many reviewers with giving them copies and other goodies, this game has been unfairly reviewed across Metacritic and other platforms like YouTube. They can’t really say the truth about how bad some controls are because they’re product was given for free. So “Brutally Honest Reviews” end up being more like “Im scared this company won’t send me more free stuff reviews”. It’s disappointing that something like this happens. But either way back to the game, I’ve played the first Half of the game already making it past the first Silent Realm. But I don’t need to beat the whole game to make this review since I already did 10 years ago. There is no need to criticize the games story and gameplay at this point because whatever’s been said before will just be said again. But honestly the only thing TO critique is the “NEW” controls that they used. Maybe if Nintendo released a new sensor bar or something for the Switch that would help it that would be incredible. But I doubt it, it would be pretty dumb. The aiming isn’t fun because for some DUMB reason they position the pointer wherever the system THINKS??? your pointer is and not just in the centre... Just put the pointer in the centre whenever it’s needed, and if they need to reset the gyro then reset it. Other wise it comes at a cost like your pointer being in the corner and causing you to aim incorrectly. I cannot stress how bad the 3rd dungeon was because of the Gust Bellow being so horrible, not in the practical sense because it’s a fun item. But because the aiming is actually bad…The sword motions are usually 85% accurate. It’s not accurate too many times for me to say 90% and higher. The bombs are pretty much the same. it always has a good idea of when your joy-con is upwards or downwards to roll it or Kobe it. The reason I’m really giving this game a 8 is because I just like this game and Zelda in general. I payed alot of money for the game, the Skyward Sword joy-cons and the Zelda Amiibo. I do love the story, the dungeons, the combat and characters, it’s Zelda, of course it’s gonna be amazing with you look at the rest and ignore the control aspect to the game. And if this was the Original Wii version I would’ve gave it a 9, not a 10 due to its controls and Fi of course. But this time around. The controls are truly a bit worse, and the whole controller complaints are NOW justified. We didn’t know how good we had it back then… And that’s it for MY TRUE BRUTALLY HONEST review.… Expand
  68. PS4_PC_LIFE
    Jul 19, 2021
    0
    Everyone seems to have a gripe with the controls, and they are right to do so, they are dated, should of just went with proper button controls, the sword action with the stick is not fun, and the camera controls are annoying, seems like a lazy port, a quick cash grab.
  69. toonlinkman
    Jul 19, 2021
    7
    I would have given this a 10 on the Wii. This is now my 4th play through of the game. Twice on Wii, once on Wii U and now on Switch.

    It is really great to go back to traditional dungeons and I even enjoy the linear style of the game. The graphics are better but then it looked better upscaled on the Wii U also. Why did I give this game a 7? It has aged a bit making it loss 1 point.    I would have given this a 10 on the Wii. This is now my 4th play through of the game. Twice on Wii, once on Wii U and now on Switch.

    It is really great to go back to traditional dungeons and I even enjoy the linear style of the game. The graphics are better but then it looked better upscaled on the Wii U also.

    Why did I give this game a 7? It has aged a bit making it loss 1 point. But the other 2 points are because of motion controls. The button controls are awful. If they reversed it made it so you press L button to use sword and R stick is for camera that would have been better.

    I actually think the sword combat is better on Switch than on Wii with motion controls. I'm not sure if it the 60fps making it easier, or if the joycons are better suited. But everything else like the sling shot, or the beetle I have to recalibrate every time I use it!    … Expand
  70. garyw_81
    Jul 19, 2021
    8
    positives.
    way better graphics(those saying it's not, go play it on the wii)
    improved motion controlls 60 fps level design story puzzle dungeons koloktus(sp?) is still in the top 10 all time boss fights in any zelda game addition of anologue stick in place of motion controlls if you don't want to use those. negatives retracing through levels you have already beaten not quite    positives.
    way better graphics(those saying it's not, go play it on the wii)
    improved motion controlls
    60 fps
    level design
    story
    puzzle dungeons
    koloktus(sp?) is still in the top 10 all time boss fights in any zelda game
    addition of anologue stick in place of motion controlls if you don't want to use those.

    negatives
    retracing through levels you have already beaten
    not quite as good as other 3d zelda games
    those silent realm bits ( ihate those)
    motion controlls. put this in both as, although improved I still dislike them    … Expand
  71. Gfzact1
    Jul 19, 2021
    4
    The texture's are almost the same it hase no new modes like in sc ultimate (rival rush.jade gost wisp.costumation And 4K)
  72. brunnossantos
    Jul 18, 2021
    9
    It's an excellent game, with an excellent story. The motion controls with the joycon are great and although the graphics are not sickening, it really looks nice considering it's a game from 2011. The only reason I didn't rate it 10 it's the full price
  73. truevoid
    Jul 18, 2021
    10
    A beautiful game, definitely one deserving a remaster. The art style is so fitting and the story telling is unbelievably good
  74. AndyCoaster
    Jul 18, 2021
    10
    Really enjoying this great experience for the third time. It's something about the dungeons and the weapons, and the new controls works surprisingly well. in my honest opinion, better than Breath of the Wild!
  75. Elm0_0
    Jul 18, 2021
    10
    Skyward sword gets a lot of hate for its price and that "the drift makes it unplayable". I got to agree that these are real problems and need to get a fix by nintendo. This ain't a reason to give this amazing game a bad review.

    The combat may for many be something that needs to get used to. But compaired to its old entery on the switch the combat has had a big 1up. The motion controles    Skyward sword gets a lot of hate for its price and that "the drift makes it unplayable". I got to agree that these are real problems and need to get a fix by nintendo. This ain't a reason to give this amazing game a bad review.

    The combat may for many be something that needs to get used to. But compaired to its old entery on the switch the combat has had a big 1up. The motion controles feel way smoother and if they are off just hold the joycon straight press y and boom all good. The button control is not the best. This ofc comes due to the game being build around motion controls. Even though the game has his lacks in some parts of the gamr its still a really solid 3d zelda game to give a try. People say 60 bucks is too much, but even though its 60 bucks you still have that zelda feeling to it. The characters (especially Groose) are great characters with fun/goofy designs. The story is one of if not they best in the zelda series.

    If there is a zelda game that has a big love/hate ratio its this game. That's mostly because of the many problems it had back in the day on the wii. All these problems are fixed besides some story things (these are difficult to remove by not making it a totally diffrent game) the game has his up and downs but the ups are there wayyyy more then the downs.

    All the other quality of life changes needed to be there and are all there. This game is a MUST play if you like zelda games. Because its one of if not they best out there.    … Expand
  76. BeeBoss
    Jul 18, 2021
    0
    I thought that this port will be a chance to appreciate this game, because I thought that the low resolution and poor motion control was the weakness points of this game on the Wii, but now I know that I was wrong. I like graphic but story and gameplay is really the worst in series.
    I feel like Nintendo has screwed on me (not for the first time)
  77. Maestra
    Jul 18, 2021
    7
    I did not play original game. "Storytelling" , game-play are fine. resolution of texture - normal. But sometimes I see non-remastered textures (e.g. in Chrono-factory). But both motion and stick control schemes are awful. I cannot catch ANY bug at all, I need to re-setup gyroscope every several minutes, I start using sword every time I want to change view if I use sticks control.I did not play original game. "Storytelling" , game-play are fine. resolution of texture - normal. But sometimes I see non-remastered textures (e.g. in Chrono-factory). But both motion and stick control schemes are awful. I cannot catch ANY bug at all, I need to re-setup gyroscope every several minutes, I start using sword every time I want to change view if I use sticks control.
    Resolution: I like situation that I can play this game without Wii. But it is pure remaster.    … Expand
  78. Zquaranteneuf
    Jul 18, 2021
    2
    This game is still the tedious, boring, and uninspired chore that it was 10 years ago. It wants to be epic, it tries really hard, but rather tell you that it is than make you feel it or experience it.

    Exactly like its Wii counterpart: - The beginning is painfully slow. The "tutorial" (the first two hours) lasts longer than the extended editions of the Lord of the Rings trilogy, but    This game is still the tedious, boring, and uninspired chore that it was 10 years ago. It wants to be epic, it tries really hard, but rather tell you that it is than make you feel it or experience it.

    Exactly like its Wii counterpart:
    - The beginning is painfully slow. The "tutorial" (the first two hours) lasts longer than the extended editions of the Lord of the Rings trilogy, but with none of the excitement. Mashing buttons and rolling your eyes through everything will make you question your existence.
    - The game treats you like a toddler that can't grasp even the most basic concepts of gameplay or logic. Most info is thrown in your face, explained by and large, repeated, and marked on your map. The game makes sure you are told everything. You CANNOT try out or discover things by yourself.
    - Movement is quite stiff and limited.
    - The world feels small, disconnected, and doesn't fulfill any sense of exploration whatsoever.
    - The sky is empty and doesn't bring any excitement at all.
    - Revisiting the same areas and bosses again and again and again gets dull really fast.
    - The main antagonist throughout the story is as cringe inducing as ever.
    - Since the game focuses heavily on story, sometimes at the cost of interesting gameplay, it is entirely linear. This can be fine, but certainly a point to consider in a Zelda game.
    - Aside from a few great themes, the orchestral soundtrack isn't that interesting or memorable, especially the harp songs (which bring nothing and feel tacked on just because Zelda always had musical components).

    In other words, it's still rock bottom for a 3D Zelda title, and in retrospect it's crystal clear why this game was the catalyst that made Nintendo rethink the whole franchise moving forward (which gave us the incredibly fresh Breath of the Wild).

    The only redeeming qualities it has to avoid labeling it as entirely creatively bankrupt is some of its dungeons and a few interesting mechanics. The story too is.. fine.. assuming you don't mind it stopping your progress all the time for cutscenes and questionable dialogue.

    In terms of remake, some tweaks and fixes make the game overall less frustrating, and Fi less inclined to make you want to drill a hole in your head, but the experience is mostly the same. The "quality of life" sure is improved, no doubt about it, but considering how low it was in the first place, I'm not even sure if we can call this revised version decent or not. That, I will leave up to you.

    Nice graphics though.

    In conclusion, this is THE Zelda game to skip.
    Don't trust the reviews that give this game a 10; these users also gave that score to Spiderman 3....    … Expand
  79. Metapyro
    Jul 18, 2021
    10
    I really feel the game is a strong 9 but I’m giving it a 10 to offset the trolls. It looks amazing. The controls just take a little getting used to. Once you get the hang of it it’s fine. Wonderful sound track as well. For me I know a game is good when it’s hard to peel myself away from it and when I am away from it I’m still thinking about it. This game has done that
  80. cosuo
    Jul 18, 2021
    9
    In my opinion the HD remaster of Skyward Sword runs flawlessly, the game looks really good, has great soundtrack, also the story is really engaging and overall the game gives great vibes, i never had any problems with motion controls and i have to say they really bring a lot of fun into the game once you get used to them u really can feel like Link. The only downsides for me i can think ofIn my opinion the HD remaster of Skyward Sword runs flawlessly, the game looks really good, has great soundtrack, also the story is really engaging and overall the game gives great vibes, i never had any problems with motion controls and i have to say they really bring a lot of fun into the game once you get used to them u really can feel like Link. The only downsides for me i can think of is the lack of voice acting and the whole sprinting ability doesn't feel great you can't jump or dodge attacks. Nevertheless the game is a great experience for all the gamers and Zelda fans. I think its a great purchase for the Nintendo Switch… Expand
  81. davygravy93
    Jul 18, 2021
    0
    Another minimum effort port by Nintendo that fanboys will gladly light themselves on fire to defend. The character models have been remastered in HD but the textures on the levels themselves did not get the same treatment, so there is this weird juxtaposition any time you're not in a dungeon(eg most of the time). Its nice that the motion controls are optional but this is somethingAnother minimum effort port by Nintendo that fanboys will gladly light themselves on fire to defend. The character models have been remastered in HD but the textures on the levels themselves did not get the same treatment, so there is this weird juxtaposition any time you're not in a dungeon(eg most of the time). Its nice that the motion controls are optional but this is something emulators figured out years ago, it hardly warrants a full 60 dollar price tag considering the only other improvement is making Fi talk less. The QOL improvements are nice but the core problems of SS weren't the controls or visuals but rather a lack of content both in the sky and in the ground below.

    Playing SS again its easy to see why nintendo moved away from this style of zelda, the intro alone takes hours before you even get the sword and up to that point its just dialogue and cutscenes which a stark contrast to Breath of The Wild a game that takes only minutes to get going. The pacing in general is pretty bad compared to most Zelda games and it comes down to the sheer amount of padding throughout the game. The amount of backtracking you have to do is beyond excessive, there's only 3 explorable areas and you'll be going back to each one THREE TIMES, I dare anyone who played this to tell me collecting the songs at the end was fun, I finished the game just for the sake of writing this review otherwise I would have dropped the game.

    Listen if you like SS that's fine, but allowing nintendo to release port after port with low effort and maximum price only tells them that you're okay with the same garbage being served to you over and over again. Idk about you but personally Id rather have new and innovative games like BOTW than lazy ports that dwell in the past.    … Expand
  82. Fatluou
    Jul 18, 2021
    10
    Incredibly fun game the controls are so much better now and is more fluent than the wii version, the game still looks stunning even after 11 years later, I recommend that you should buy it if you haven't
  83. Romadu
    Jul 18, 2021
    1
    Uncontrollable, awful camera management. Not fun. A complete waste of time!
  84. SuperFabian64
    Jul 18, 2021
    0
    Low effort port sold at full price. A product that has more or less been available on emulators since the original release of the game. This game deserved a proper remaster. If not, then cut the price in half and drop the HD branding. HD in this case just means it meets the bare minimum a game released today has to uphold; an HD resolution. The texture quality is still that of a Wii gameLow effort port sold at full price. A product that has more or less been available on emulators since the original release of the game. This game deserved a proper remaster. If not, then cut the price in half and drop the HD branding. HD in this case just means it meets the bare minimum a game released today has to uphold; an HD resolution. The texture quality is still that of a Wii game though. They barely touched this one, which kind of makes me wonder what it is that I'm paying for, when the original game exists for a third of the price. Mario's 35th anniversary got 3D All-Stars, and Zelda got this. I'm almost scared of what's to come.… Expand
  85. JohnnyPS5
    Jul 18, 2021
    9
    I love this game. I loved it 10 years ago, and still love it now. That being said, is it worth the $60. YES! I played the Wii version last year and I’ve watched side by side comparisons and it looks better in handheld than the Wii… and absolutely phenomenal while docked. It’s amazing the polish they put into it. The bad reviews are ridiculous. 1.don’t rate a game poorly because of anI love this game. I loved it 10 years ago, and still love it now. That being said, is it worth the $60. YES! I played the Wii version last year and I’ve watched side by side comparisons and it looks better in handheld than the Wii… and absolutely phenomenal while docked. It’s amazing the polish they put into it. The bad reviews are ridiculous. 1.don’t rate a game poorly because of an amiibo
    2. Don’t rate a game poorly because your joycons drift
    3. Don’t be that curmudgeon

    Honest negatives. 1. It’s the same game. If you hated it then, you’re gonna hate it now. 2. The start is tedious. It’s almost 2 hours to get to the first dungeon and every time it starts to go, you’ll get pulled back into an explanation, story, or tutorial. 3. The controls are WAY better but still clunky and going to be divisive. This game has a great story and is an important part in the evolution of the legend of Zelda series. There are moments in this game that are just breathtaking and it sucks that the controls and the slow start of the game keep people from loving this game like I do. Anything above a 70 rating is fair. Anything below is petty and misdirected displeasure at joy cons, amiibos, and Nintendo.    … Expand
  86. Mr_fettuccinee
    Jul 18, 2021
    8
    Great game, not without problems, memorable soundtracks, reminds me of many childhood moments, a little too pricey for a remaster but in the end I was happy to pay for the overall experience, you constantly have to reset the motion controls but the fact that you can do in any moment just by pressing the Y button makes it less annoying than I wold expect and Fi is still the most annoyingGreat game, not without problems, memorable soundtracks, reminds me of many childhood moments, a little too pricey for a remaster but in the end I was happy to pay for the overall experience, you constantly have to reset the motion controls but the fact that you can do in any moment just by pressing the Y button makes it less annoying than I wold expect and Fi is still the most annoying companion that you could ever immagine only second to Navi even if they tried to cut many unnecessary dialogues but in the end I’m glad that Nintendo waned to give a new life to the less liked of the 3D Zeldas, it’s also a great way for people new to the Zelda brand to discover the franchise and try something other than breath of the wild. So you should definitely give it a chance.… Expand
  87. Kakadu
    Jul 18, 2021
    10
    Absolutely fantastic. Controlls are more accurate than in the original and it looks and runs way better. Qol improvements make the game alot more fun. Fi isn't annoying anymore.
  88. TheOnlineGamer
    Jul 18, 2021
    10
    It should be a crime that the Skyrim Zelda Mod that is Breath of the Wild gets to have a **** near perfect score, while Skyward Sword (AN ACTUAL ZELDA GAME) gets rated this lowly...
  89. Zephyrion
    Jul 17, 2021
    10
    For me who never played the wii version this game is fantastic. Love the story gameplay is okey and the music wow
  90. Dipirocudo
    Jul 17, 2021
    9
    Show, jogo sensacional, faltou legenda em PT/BR, espero que a Nintendo resolva isso nos próximos jogos
  91. Doctor-J
    Jul 17, 2021
    6
    I'm a few hours into this game and just can't get used to the controls. The camera is impossible to deal, and link seems so dumb moving his sword around like an ape swinging a stick. I'm sorry, but this is not for me, and i truly love zelda games.
  92. NoUsernameYet
    Jul 17, 2021
    10
    A wonderful game, which is undoubtedly one of the best in the saga, having the best story,the best soundtrack, impressive dungeons, bosses and others that make this game very special. A version that corrects a large part of the errors of the past and offers luxuries to the most complaining or picky eaters, already full HD AND 60 PFS, and yes, I said in full HD haters;), without a doubt oneA wonderful game, which is undoubtedly one of the best in the saga, having the best story,the best soundtrack, impressive dungeons, bosses and others that make this game very special. A version that corrects a large part of the errors of the past and offers luxuries to the most complaining or picky eaters, already full HD AND 60 PFS, and yes, I said in full HD haters;), without a doubt one of the best Zelda, and an excellent way to relive this title in HD and 60 FPS.

    PS: Beautiful Zelink, the best.    … Expand
  93. gameing
    Jul 17, 2021
    3
    Definitely a fine game, but its really not worth the price. On the Wii Skyward Sword was released for 15 bucks, why is it now 60 on switch?
  94. Call-o-freak
    Jul 17, 2021
    4
    This doesn't look better than its Wii Counterpart. Do appreciate the control stick for doing sword swings, but because of joy con drift, I can barely make precise movements. Most of the problems from the wii version are included, such as the empty overworld, annoying character interactions, poor controls, and dragging gameplay. Would be ok if they added new content that didn't costThis doesn't look better than its Wii Counterpart. Do appreciate the control stick for doing sword swings, but because of joy con drift, I can barely make precise movements. Most of the problems from the wii version are included, such as the empty overworld, annoying character interactions, poor controls, and dragging gameplay. Would be ok if they added new content that didn't cost anything, but as we all know, nintendo right now are cheapskates.

    Overall, this game isn't very good, even for a remaster. Save your money for games like Nier: Replicant, Sonic Colors Ultimate, or Pokemon Unite.    … Expand
  95. Reed618
    Jul 17, 2021
    10
    Unfortunately ports are a target for review bombing so the user score probably won't be that reliable as people who haven't played the game will just give it a 0.

    I'm a few hours in and really enjoying the game though. The art style really holds up and this is such a great version of Zelda (the character I mean). I love her design and she's quite funny. The quality of life features make    Unfortunately ports are a target for review bombing so the user score probably won't be that reliable as people who haven't played the game will just give it a 0.

    I'm a few hours in and really enjoying the game though. The art style really holds up and this is such a great version of Zelda (the character I mean). I love her design and she's quite funny. The quality of life features make the experience noticeably better.

    I also really appreciate that I can use a gamepad. Joycon drift is a big headache so I just couldn't handle playing with joycons.

    Having tried the original version on wii just a few months ago I can definitely say this is hands down the best version of the game. Better control options, less annoying tutorials/pop up messages, visually it's far nicer (the old wii version looks awful on modern tvs), autosaves, camera controls etc. It really is a massive improvement.

    Is it better than breath of the wild? personally not at all. botw has a lot more to offer but skyward sword is full of charm and it's a fun adventure. I'd definitely recommend it.    … Expand
  96. CorixAsk
    Jul 17, 2021
    0
    Basically no change on graphics and game-play and they locked a new teleportation feature behind an amiibo and it's $59.99 when the original wii release was $49.99 this is another sick joke like Mario's anniversary
  97. fattythehutt
    Jul 17, 2021
    5
    If you have any drift at all in your right Joy-Con do not play this. If you play without motion controls sword attacks are mapped to the right thumb stick.
  98. sarisa
    Jul 17, 2021
    7
    Dungeons: 8/10
    Bosses: 9/10
    Music: 10/10 Surprisingly good working joycons. ... ....Graphics... 2/10 (Switch) and 9/10 (Wii) Yes. That's the point. Frame rate is very good. Game graphics is very sharp, but it doesn't go hand in hand with angular polygons... This really stings the eye. This graphics style designed for this game was clearly for lower resolutions.. And as such, this is    Dungeons: 8/10
    Bosses: 9/10
    Music: 10/10
    Surprisingly good working joycons.
    ...
    ....Graphics... 2/10 (Switch) and 9/10 (Wii)
    Yes. That's the point. Frame rate is very good. Game graphics is very sharp, but it doesn't go hand in hand with angular polygons... This really stings the eye.
    This graphics style designed for this game was clearly for lower resolutions.. And as such, this is where they screwed up. This game should have never been released as "remaster HD" in that state (what sort of remaster is this btw...?) Such games should be either remade or at least tiny effort in terms of remodelling should be put to earn "HD remaster" badge. Just compare Wind Waker HD or Twilight Princess HD from Wii U.
    Still this title has much to offer (just compare dungeons and story of SS with Breath of The Wild) in terms of superb story and gameplay.

    So to recap: it's good this game is on Switch for younger audience to taste one of the best Zelda in the series.
    Shame on Big N for another cash grab they did. The more they act this way, the more they justify homebrew scene.    … Expand
  99. bingobengo
    Jul 17, 2021
    9
    They fixed the most hand-holding dialogue and infuriating motion controls, delivering an undeniably amazing puzzle action game with some of the best music in the business.
  100. Cream147
    Jul 17, 2021
    9
    10 years ago The Legend of Zelda: Skyward Sword released to typical critical acclaim from the media, but an unusually mixed fan reaction for the series - and it has been the fan reception that has stuck with this game in the years since. That was mostly fair, there were definitely a number of issues with this game such as a very prolonged intro, no option to not use motion controls, a10 years ago The Legend of Zelda: Skyward Sword released to typical critical acclaim from the media, but an unusually mixed fan reaction for the series - and it has been the fan reception that has stuck with this game in the years since. That was mostly fair, there were definitely a number of issues with this game such as a very prolonged intro, no option to not use motion controls, a broadly empty sky world which seemed like it could have been so much more, and a particular annoying repeated boss, to name a few. Furthermore, the game was unusually linear for a Zelda game, with very little focus on exploration and more on environmental puzzle solving for progression, with the surface world areas essentially playing like dungeons in themselves. This felt like the opposite of what the fanbase wanted at that time - a large-scale exploration-based game with less of an emphasis on motion controls, as the craze about these had died down. Skyward Sword seemed like a dated game on release, rather than a groundbreaking game in one of their most beloved series.

    One important thing has happened in the Zelda series since Skyward Sword, and that is of course the release of Breath of the Wild, the Zelda game of many's dreams. With this game, pushing firmly opposite to the direction proposed by Skyward Sword, the future of the Zelda series as an open-world adventure rooted in exploration seems secured.

    And so we come to Skyward Sword HD. With this game clearly not indicating the direction of the series, we can perhaps view this game in its own right. The critical praise of Skyward Sword did not come from nowhere - there was always a lot right with this game:

    - The dungeon design was the best in the series, with some interesting ideas such as a dungeon which you largely traverse on a large boulder floating through lava, and general novel puzzle solving.
    - The dungeon design was helped by an interesting set of items including the return of some classics (e.g. bombs, bow and arrow etc.) and some new ones (e.g. a mechanical beetle that you obtain early on). Included are some new ways to use familiar items, such as the ability to roll bombs like a bowling ball, which add a few fresh puzzle and combat ideas.
    - Surface world level design, while linear, keeps focused and you are not running through large areas of empty space often.
    - The addition of a stamina wheel allowing you to run faster and climb higher objects than in previous games.
    - The ability to upgrade many of the items you obtain throughout the game giving the game more of an RPG-lite flavour than some previous Zelda games.
    - Fun sidequests up in the sky area give you some downtime can break up the more linear, focused action on the surface world.
    - A story that, while not fantastic, has its moments and is a suitable beginning to the Zelda timeline

    And then the HD version has made several key improvements, some of which directly address issues with the game:
    - It looks visually pleasing. They haven't done much modelling work so the geometry is jagged but the increased resolution and the more defined textures do wonders, and the geometry isn't particularly jarring in the surreal painterly style of Skyward Sword.
    - 60 FPS. People's mileage seems to vary on this, but for me 60 FPS is world's better than 30 and to see Skyward Sword as the first ever 3D Zelda game officially running at this framerate is a big deal for me and dramatically improves the experience.
    - The addition of button controls. These are unintuitive at times as ultimately the game was designed to be played with motion controls, but they do the job and provide an option for those who are not interested in motion controls (or want to play handheld, another feature this port naturally adds)
    - Several quality of life additions, such as faster text skipping, cutscene skipping, less interruptions from your partner, auto-saving and so on. These serve to greatly increase the pace of gameplay, if you're keen to progress quickly the game is going to stop your flow a lot less now.

    Some of the issues of the game are more inherent and have not been addressed, but by improving the overall QoL they are less problematic than remembered. Furthermore, in a world where now we are saturated with open world games, the old-school linear action-adventure gameplay may be refreshing (if it's to your taste), as they really do not make games like this anymore.

    The way I see this remake, I think this is a second chance for Skyward Sword. Selected improvements have been made to the experience to enhance it, motion controls are no longer mandatory, and perhaps most importantly, we have the context that the more ground-breaking experience of Breath of the Wild 2 is on its way. With that said, this may be an opportunity to enjoy Skyward Sword for what it is, rather than for what it is not. I thoroughly enjoyed my time with it, and if you have the right expectations, there's a good chance you can too.    … Expand
Page:

Awards & Rankings

56
#56 Best Switch Game of 2021
4
#4 Most Discussed Switch Game of 2021

Critic Reviews

All reviews »
Metascore
81

Generally favorable reviews - based on 106 Critic Reviews

Critic score distribution:
  1. Positive: 89 out of 106
  2. Mixed: 16 out of 106
  3. Negative: 1 out of 106
  1. Gamersky
    Dec 20, 2021
    77
    The Legend of Zelda: Skyward Sword HD on NS brought this once masterpiece back to the player's vision. However, its crappy control and a somewhat old-fashioned design make it seem less attractive nowadays.
    Read full review
  2. RPGamer
    Nov 22, 2021
    70
    Skyward Sword HD should be commended for its attempt to improve on the original. Having a new control scheme and making a good deal of Fi’s advice optional make it a more palatable experience. However, the game still suffers from pacing issues that made the original feel too bloated as well as a disappointing deemphasis on exploration. This remaster could have realistically improved upon a lot, yet it would still fall short compared to the series’ strongest entries. There is still enough for those looking for a more traditional 3D Zelda experience on the Switch provided they keep their expectations in check.
    Read full review
  3. JeuxActu
    Oct 16, 2021
    65
    Yes the picture is sharper, yes the game is smoother (60fps), yes there have been some improvements to make the adventure more enjoyable, but damn the gameplay has taken a hell of a beating in the back of the head. It was already painful in 2011, it is even more 10 years later, and it is not the tinkering in classic controls that will sublimate the gameplay of this Zelda : Skyward Sword HD.
    Read full review
See all critic reviews »