The Legend of Zelda: The Wind Waker

 GameCube
User Score
9.0

Universal acclaim- based on 1644 Ratings

User score distribution:
  1. Positive: 1,460 out of 1644
  2. Mixed: 110 out of 1644
  3. Negative: 74 out of 1644
Buy Now
Buy on

Review this game

  1. Your Score
    0 out of 10
    Rate this:
    • 10
    • 9
    • 8
    • 7
    • 6
    • 5
    • 4
    • 3
    • 2
    • 1
    • 0
    • 0
  1. Submit
  2. Check Spelling
view
per page
  1. AndreB.
    May 12, 2004
    10
    This game is amazing. It is utterly perfect in every aspect. The graphics are beautiful. They look as good as any Xbox or PC game. The sound is great, including the music. The gameplay is perfect. This game has some of the best gameplay ever. It really feels like Zelda, even with the cel-shaded graphics. Of course it caused controversy, but now that I've played it I couldn't This game is amazing. It is utterly perfect in every aspect. The graphics are beautiful. They look as good as any Xbox or PC game. The sound is great, including the music. The gameplay is perfect. This game has some of the best gameplay ever. It really feels like Zelda, even with the cel-shaded graphics. Of course it caused controversy, but now that I've played it I couldn't imagine this game without cel-shading. Anyway, this game is perfect.… Expand
  2. TedWilsonMattosdeAzevedo
    May 5, 2004
    10
    It´s the game of the year, that´s for sure, some people can talk bad about the game, but who told that never played thegame well, I have this game, I finished, and I can say one thing: This is one of the best games ever created. Perfect cel-shading graphics, incredible battle style, the sea, everything is perfect, the only thing that don´t get to be a problem is because It´s the game of the year, that´s for sure, some people can talk bad about the game, but who told that never played thegame well, I have this game, I finished, and I can say one thing: This is one of the best games ever created. Perfect cel-shading graphics, incredible battle style, the sea, everything is perfect, the only thing that don´t get to be a problem is because the game is a bit short compared to the other Zeldas. But this game is perfect. even with that little defect.… Expand
  3. LiNkZB.
    Apr 20, 2004
    9
    I loved this game, I finished it twice and I don't get bored by it, although OoT is better in my opinion I still give this game a 9 ^_^.
  4. S.J.
    Apr 13, 2004
    10
    Beautiful absolutely beautiful, sound is crisp , and visuals are great.
  5. ArneL.
    Apr 1, 2004
    10
    It's great... everybody that says it's to similar to oot are right but oot is the best game of all time so thats not a bad score. if you don´t have it buy it.
  6. JarkkoJ.
    Mar 25, 2004
    10
    I think this game is one of the best games ever made. Graphics are fantastic and gameplay is excellent. There is only one bad thing... it was too easy.
  7. Mike
    Mar 11, 2004
    7
    If you're a real zelda fan the graphics won't matter to you. but there's a little too much sillyness with the looks of the poeple. all in all it pretty much followed the zelda story except with the botan and talking boat.
  8. BrianK.
    Jan 6, 2004
    3
    I really hated this game!! I gave it a 3 because of the pretty good graphics but thats it. Too Kiddy like!!
  9. CozoniW.
    Jan 3, 2004
    9
    My first Zelda experience. But allthough it has suberbly origonal graphics, immaculate combat and some genius puzzles- it wasnt perfect. The exploring over the oceans was flawed to say the least, became a little repetitive just when you thought the action was hotting up and also wasnt that difficult - expecially when you are flipping between Metroid Prime and Pro evolution soccer 3 which My first Zelda experience. But allthough it has suberbly origonal graphics, immaculate combat and some genius puzzles- it wasnt perfect. The exploring over the oceans was flawed to say the least, became a little repetitive just when you thought the action was hotting up and also wasnt that difficult - expecially when you are flipping between Metroid Prime and Pro evolution soccer 3 which really are hard! But you have to give it at least a 9 because it is part of a select few games who are on a different planet to 90% of other games.… Expand
  10. JonathanA.
    Jan 2, 2004
    10
    I love this game, Its non-stop action!!!!!!
  11. ChrisM.
    Jan 1, 2004
    4
    After the exciting epic that was Ocarina of Time (OOT) and the fun filled Majora's Mask this game was a big dissapointment. It just failed to capture my attention like OOT did.
  12. GreekBoyAndrew
    Dec 15, 2003
    9
    OK, we all know that the game play is great. There has been a big debate on wether the graphics are amazing or just crap. I think that the graphics are ok however they don't use the potenital of the gamecube. What people don't realise is that its not just the graphics, its the fact that link is small, skinny and gay looking. Can the hero of time really look as stupid????? on theOK, we all know that the game play is great. There has been a big debate on wether the graphics are amazing or just crap. I think that the graphics are ok however they don't use the potenital of the gamecube. What people don't realise is that its not just the graphics, its the fact that link is small, skinny and gay looking. Can the hero of time really look as stupid????? on the other hand if the graphics were the same but he was big, musclular and a hard ass then i dont think anyone would complain! in conclusion i feel that you should go out and buy this game because the storyline, gameplay and whole atmosphere of the game is amazing. you can't rate this game after 30 mins of playing it!… Expand
  13. NeilB.
    Dec 10, 2003
    10
    This is Truly the Best game I have ever played, the graphics are amazing! Me and my Best friend had hours of playing this! This is definitely a Must-Play Game!
  14. Sariachan
    Dec 7, 2003
    10
    One of the best Zelda game I ever played, I loved Link's new style of fighting, the cell-shaded graphics, the soundtrack, and the overall greatness of this game.
  15. Nathan
    Dec 5, 2003
    9
    First, i would like to say that i am 14. i thought this game was great. simply put. im giving it a nine because i think that making link a cartoon wasnt the greatest idea, but the storyline and game sequence was good. the side-quests were also very good. i have played past zelda games including the very first one, and i would have to say that this comes in third, behind the legend of First, i would like to say that i am 14. i thought this game was great. simply put. im giving it a nine because i think that making link a cartoon wasnt the greatest idea, but the storyline and game sequence was good. the side-quests were also very good. i have played past zelda games including the very first one, and i would have to say that this comes in third, behind the legend of zelda (the first one) and ocarina of time. also, if people are saying its 'gay', its only because the graphics couldve been better, but graphics dont make a game great...… Expand
  16. JaiDave
    Dec 3, 2003
    4
    [***SPOILER***] This game was a big disappointment to me. I am a very big Zelda fan from way back and have closely followed the story from nearly of all the games until now. The graphics were terrible considering they were planning to originally make the game with graphics like "Ocarina of Time". Instead, they decided to make the game very cartoonish and child-like, which is reflected in[***SPOILER***] This game was a big disappointment to me. I am a very big Zelda fan from way back and have closely followed the story from nearly of all the games until now. The graphics were terrible considering they were planning to originally make the game with graphics like "Ocarina of Time". Instead, they decided to make the game very cartoonish and child-like, which is reflected in the graphics of the game. Imagine how great it would be if they actually made the game with Gamecube graphics similar to the "Ocarina of Time". If you want a comparison, just look for "Zelda 128" and compare the graphics in the demo with the actually graphics of the finished product. Very disappointing indeed. Secondly, the plot of the game was horrific and seemed highly unrealistic and nearly impossible. I mean come on, do you really believe that Link would not show up to challenge Gannon? Of course Link would show up! Even at the very end of the game, the story does not make any sense. GAME ENDING SPOILER: Why would the King of Hyrule want to wish that his kingdom remain at the bottom of the ocean? He got to the Triforce first, and he could have wished for anything in the universe, but no, he had to wish for hyrule to remain submerged under the ocean instead of wishing for Gannon to be destroyed and Hyrule to live on forever. He could even wish for Gannon to be sealed away with a special power emitted from seven magical objects and then have them scattered all around the world so that Nintendo could make another game. END OF SPOILER: Third, the gameplay was VERY monotonous. Having to hit your weapon's teacher 500 times with your sword to gain a measly Heart Piece is not my idea of a fun time. If that wasn't bad enough, you have to put up with the countless hours sailing around the world, because 99% of the world is water and the other 1% is composed of scattered islands on the world map. Fourth, the music was mediocre. There was little variety in the various musical themes of the game. There wasn't the same amount of emotional intensity in the music as there was in previous games like "The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time" or "The Legend of Zelda: A Link to the Past". Lastly, the fun factor of the game dropped like a lead weight in water compared to the previous Zelda games. It was a refreshing relief when I played "A Link to the Past" after this game because "A Link to the Past" was so much more fun than this poorly made game. And this game became Game of the Year? Something is definitely not right here. If you are a true Zelda fan and have been playing Zelda games for as long as I have, you will feel cheated after you purchase this game. I feel like I have just spent $50 for nothing. Shiguru Miamoto definitely needs to wake up and see what has become of one of the best video game characters of all time (the best is Chrono from "Chrono Trigger") and make serious ammends for this awful game before this gamer will touch another Zelda game.… Expand
  17. MarkL.
    Dec 1, 2003
    9
    A masterpiece better than ocarina of time.
  18. DaveB.
    Nov 18, 2003
    7
    It's fun, it's a quality game, but it's not just a tad too childish, it's way too childish! I hope that the sequel is similar, but aimed at a broader audience.
  19. SaraB.
    Nov 8, 2003
    10
    It's really an 11 but they don't go up that high!it's the greatest game i've played since OoT! i love the cell graphics and the well there's to much that i like about the game to put it all on here!
  20. A.W.
    Nov 4, 2003
    5
    Pretty average. Ok, the dungeons were quite good and even though i'm against the cel-shading graphics, they are very good, but it's too short, the sailing and wind changing is one of the most tedious things i've ever done and, because of all the islands and finding maps etc., i could not be bothered doing all the side quests and mini games. 'nuff said.
  21. JoelS.
    Oct 29, 2003
    9
    All right all you little winers out there. MAYBE, JUST MAYBE! if you guys got around the graphix and stuff like that you might realize that the game is pretty good, ok i admit, it wasn't as good as ocarina of time but it was awesome, i was intrigued by the storyline, i thought it was awesome and the only other things i didn't really like to much where, the length, being too All right all you little winers out there. MAYBE, JUST MAYBE! if you guys got around the graphix and stuff like that you might realize that the game is pretty good, ok i admit, it wasn't as good as ocarina of time but it was awesome, i was intrigued by the storyline, i thought it was awesome and the only other things i didn't really like to much where, the length, being too short, and the talking boat rather then a horse and a baton, like come on wheres the " Ocarina " that was the Bomb!!!!!!! come on you people, besides the things i just named, theres nothing "bad" about the game and if you think its too "kiddy" or you think the graphix are "gay" and think the storyline sux and that nothing about the game is any good then DON"T PLAY IT!!! WINERS!!!!!! … Expand
  22. DamonZ.
    Oct 19, 2003
    10
    This is the best game i have ever had the pleasure of playing.
  23. EricH.
    Sep 28, 2003
    8
    The reviews written by magazine and internet critics explain the good parts of the game but I don't believe the game deserves a 10 or a 9. The reason is that the game has flaws. The game is too easy. Players do not get as many dungeons like in other zelda games. I find the small amounts of land in the game annoying but that is just a personal complaint. The first part of the game is The reviews written by magazine and internet critics explain the good parts of the game but I don't believe the game deserves a 10 or a 9. The reason is that the game has flaws. The game is too easy. Players do not get as many dungeons like in other zelda games. I find the small amounts of land in the game annoying but that is just a personal complaint. The first part of the game is real good. Then the second part is bleh... you have to find maps that lead to the triforce. The problem with that is to get the maps you have to go down several holes and fight bad guys which pose no challenge. Then you have to pay a fairy to decode the maps and then go pull up the treasure beneath the sea. … Expand
  24. JayB.
    Sep 28, 2003
    0
    Even if this game had the best graphics in the world, this would probably be one of the most overrated, poorly designed games I have ever bought in my life, being made only as a result of the publicity and money made from Ocarina of Time. Stop giving this sorry game pity votes!
  25. AzizK.
    Sep 22, 2003
    10
    LINK IS DA@BEST!
  26. CarolynB.
    Aug 10, 2003
    10
    The legend of Zelda: The Wind Waker is awesome! im always excited to see new boses and i love the animation. its a hard game with all the puzzles, but thats what makes so cool. this is why i rate this a 10.
  27. GameKing
    Aug 9, 2003
    10
    This game is the best GC game ive ever played (except for super smash bros melee.) i havnt even finished it and i still think its the best!!!!!! all my friends that have a GC have it. theres monsters to fight chalenges to take on etc.this is y i gave it a 10.
  28. GameDemon
    Aug 6, 2003
    6
    game is pretty good overall, but falls short in nearly every area (story, gameplay, etc.)
  29. LinkFan
    Aug 6, 2003
    4
    The gameplay is simplistic and easy. The story is poor and contradicts itself and the other Zelda games, it seems to be written by someone who read up on Zelda for 2 minutes before making the story, the graphics are horrible. It's not just the graphics, this game SUCKS. maybe a 5 year old would like it.
  30. AdamS.
    Aug 4, 2003
    1
    Poor.
  31. JohnW.
    Aug 4, 2003
    2
    If only link looked like he does in Soul Calibur II...
  32. BennettR.
    Aug 4, 2003
    0
    Find yourself some images of the Spaceworld 2000 preview graphics. Only THEN will you be able to see what a horror this game is.
  33. ChaCha
    Aug 1, 2003
    10
    Incredible. All you people talk about are the cartoon like graphics, but once I played through the game, I couldn't imagine anything else. Tell me what game can you sail stormy seas, fight gigantic creatures from the depths of the ocean, and watch clouds form and move in the sky. This game is truely a dream. No this game doesn't have the dungeon depth in the Ocarina of Time, but Incredible. All you people talk about are the cartoon like graphics, but once I played through the game, I couldn't imagine anything else. Tell me what game can you sail stormy seas, fight gigantic creatures from the depths of the ocean, and watch clouds form and move in the sky. This game is truely a dream. No this game doesn't have the dungeon depth in the Ocarina of Time, but I love its courage to explore the Zelda universe and actually include more defined NPC's. I rank it up there with A Link to the Past.… Expand
  34. ChrisCamp
    Jul 31, 2003
    6
    It's got gorgeous graphics, good controls and good sound. And the new battle features are great too. But I was put off by the fact that the dungeons are so easy to crack. In Ocarina of Time, you would find a new item (such as the hookshot) and return to an old dungeon that you'd already beat and find more treasure using the hookshot. In this one, you can get every treasure in It's got gorgeous graphics, good controls and good sound. And the new battle features are great too. But I was put off by the fact that the dungeons are so easy to crack. In Ocarina of Time, you would find a new item (such as the hookshot) and return to an old dungeon that you'd already beat and find more treasure using the hookshot. In this one, you can get every treasure in the dungeon the first time through. It's a good game but nowhere near as deep and addictive as OOT… Expand
  35. DuncanS.
    Jul 25, 2003
    6
    This is so pathetic compared to the Ocarina of Time!!! I was waiting to be amazed by realistic graphics like i was when Ocarina came out. WHY GO CARTOONY?!?! They used the name to their advantage hoping that it would bring them success. Well what do you know? If this game had been named "The path of Dean: Wind Waker" or something that didnt have the zelda name attached, people wouldnt This is so pathetic compared to the Ocarina of Time!!! I was waiting to be amazed by realistic graphics like i was when Ocarina came out. WHY GO CARTOONY?!?! They used the name to their advantage hoping that it would bring them success. Well what do you know? If this game had been named "The path of Dean: Wind Waker" or something that didnt have the zelda name attached, people wouldnt have liked it as much. As for the plot, the story line is so predictable, that a 6 year old would know how the whole thing goes after 5 min of game time. Game play is the only strong aspect of this game. I like all the cool weapons that you recieve. The sailing annoys me to the point that i want to fast forward my life half an hour to get to the next island!… Expand
  36. XISMZERO
    Jul 13, 2003
    8
    Fine visuals, and gameplay - that doesn't last long enough - Am I the only one who thought Wind Waker fell apart at nearing the end of the game with all those tedious tasks?
  37. Jason
    Jul 11, 2003
    4
    Didnt really appeal to me at all in the way previous ones have. the plot was typical, and the movie sequences and the ending was very childish. I didn't think it was all that difficult like previous ones we're. My suggestion is if your looking for a game that has a more grown up feel look elseware. That E for everyone all ages is exactly what it stands for...
  38. DevonN.
    Jul 8, 2003
    10
    Awesome game. Need I say more?
  39. YourasA.
    Jul 3, 2003
    7
    Oke game.
  40. AndoryuU.
    Jun 30, 2003
    10
    This game surpasses all others, an outstading play for all ages!
  41. BrennanL.
    Jun 30, 2003
    9
    This game is my #2 favorite Zelda only topped by Ocarina of Time this a Must-Buy for everyone even those who don't like Zelda if u can overlook the flaws of it's easiness and it's short story.
  42. O.CERVANTES
    Jun 29, 2003
    10
    EXCELLENT!
  43. MarshMellow
    Jun 29, 2003
    10
    As good as it gets!!!!!!!
  44. SomeoneYoudontknow
    Jun 24, 2003
    10
    People should be quiet about the cel-shading, all it does is bug us, and prevents this game (and console) from getting it's deserved creds. oh, by the way, there a neat glitch when your walking slowly up stairs.
  45. OoTFan
    Jun 18, 2003
    9
    When I first saw this game, I actually felt downcast because of the graphics, but after starting to play it, I found out this is an excellent game, just like all the other Zelda games in the series. Gameplay is tight, the bosses are fun to fight, (Link's sister is annoying and I want to kill her :D), and exploring the world will keep you busy for hours and hours. There is a good When I first saw this game, I actually felt downcast because of the graphics, but after starting to play it, I found out this is an excellent game, just like all the other Zelda games in the series. Gameplay is tight, the bosses are fun to fight, (Link's sister is annoying and I want to kill her :D), and exploring the world will keep you busy for hours and hours. There is a good storyline, which keeps you interested, and this is a great game, especially if you want to sit down, and fall into the world of Zelda. After I got this game a few days ago, I've been switching back and forth between Zelda and Splinter Cell, and it helps alot, after playing Splinter Cell, to cool you down and help you relax. (it gets aggravatingly annoying after failing a mission in one level 15 times.) There are a lot of weapons for link to use, and it's even more interesting when you can pick up a weapon from a fallen enemy. Bad: The cartoony graphics are fine, but it is still a violent bump from the loved and more serious games of the Zelda series. Though this is a fresh break from the solumn games of the past, the realism of The Zelda world in TWW is lost, and sometimes makes us remember where we are in reality. Though I'm not saying the cartoony graphics in TWW are bad, I'm saying just how much better TWW would have been with more realistic graphics. In my opinion, TWW is one of the best games you're going to see on the shelf for Nintendo, and this will get us through the summer with ease, while waiting for the expect releases of Rainbow Six 3 and Metal Gear Solid 2.… Expand
  46. LinktheHeroSwordsman
    Jun 17, 2003
    10
    The game is very cool and i like the fact that it is so long. It keeps players busy like me, I'm still trying to find Makar for the Wind God. Anyway I like the game better than any other game that I've ever played and it's a must have game for Zelda lovers.
  47. JakeW.
    Jun 14, 2003
    10
    Don't believe the haters... this game rocks beautiful. It will take over your dreams and make you worship at the altar of boundless substance meeting ultracool style. Why read user comments, just go buy it.
  48. ErikF.
    Jun 9, 2003
    10
    Best game ever!
  49. AmyC.
    Jun 7, 2003
    9
    The graphics are cool, the plot is thorough (many twists), and it's overall VERY fun. But here are the reasons I gave it a 9 rather than a 10: 1)That annoying TETRA! I mean, I know she's important (especially when you find out who she really is) but I found her to be extremely unlikable and I couldn't care less about anything bad happening to her. In fact, I really just The graphics are cool, the plot is thorough (many twists), and it's overall VERY fun. But here are the reasons I gave it a 9 rather than a 10: 1)That annoying TETRA! I mean, I know she's important (especially when you find out who she really is) but I found her to be extremely unlikable and I couldn't care less about anything bad happening to her. In fact, I really just wanted her to get killed by that bird. I mean, everytime I play this game with someone they constantly say (and i constantly say) "I hate that girl" or "When's that stupid girl gonna die?" I swear, I haven't met a single person who thought she was "cool". I mean she comes in handy, but I just didn't like her character. 2) Some of the adult characters such as the king of Hyrule, Ganon, and Zelda looked horrible as a cartoon. I mean, when they turned around so you could see their face, I burst out laughing and it was such a serious moment. I couldn't look at either one of them with out busting up. Zelda had makeup smeared on her (strangely enough, she had that problem in OoT) and a head that you could tell was bigger than her body. Ganon was fat and had sideburns bigger than the ones he had in OoT. And the king of hyrule was just plain creeeepy. Sorry, but I couldn't stand seeing them as cartoons. So I'd rather have them look more real. Plus, the plot seems less dark with cartoons. Overall, Windwaker is fantastic, but there were a couple of negatives I couldn't stand. But whatever, what do I know?!… Expand
  50. AmberT.
    Jun 3, 2003
    10
    Absolutely brilliant!!!!
  51. AntónioB.
    Jun 2, 2003
    10
    Fantastic.
  52. JuanG.
    May 31, 2003
    10
    Although I give this game a Perfect ten I still beilieve that Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time is better. The dungeons in this game are extremely difficult compared to the other Zelda games. I dont think that a person that never played Zelda before could beat it.
  53. TedL.
    May 31, 2003
    5
    This is a highly overrated game. The graphics are fine. Very cartoony, but the story was ridiculous, unless you're 7 or younger. I felt like the second half of the game wasn't even there, the game actually became easier as I played through it. I've never played a game like that before. Nintendo rushed this game out, so if you have to play windwaker play it for about an hour This is a highly overrated game. The graphics are fine. Very cartoony, but the story was ridiculous, unless you're 7 or younger. I felt like the second half of the game wasn't even there, the game actually became easier as I played through it. I've never played a game like that before. Nintendo rushed this game out, so if you have to play windwaker play it for about an hour and then give it to your kid brother.… Expand
  54. KeeganM.
    May 22, 2003
    10
    Well... when I first saw how the game looked, m I was scpetical, to say the least. Link just doesn't look good as a cartoon. That aside, it is easily thebest games I've ever played... except maybe ocarina of Time. And once you get used to the cartoon-style graphics, you'll see how much better they can animate the game.
  55. SnakeVenom
    May 16, 2003
    9
    I gave it a 9 because it is a really great game. it doesnt reach the full revolutionary posistion that Ocarina of Time did, but it is none the les a very great work of art. The cell shading and music really help to make you feel like you are in the game. Another thing that kep ot from being a 10 is that now a days people dont like to read alot of text, they want vioces. Bring in the I gave it a 9 because it is a really great game. it doesnt reach the full revolutionary posistion that Ocarina of Time did, but it is none the les a very great work of art. The cell shading and music really help to make you feel like you are in the game. Another thing that kep ot from being a 10 is that now a days people dont like to read alot of text, they want vioces. Bring in the vioces for Zelda and it'll be even better.… Expand
  56. Chucky
    May 16, 2003
    9
    I really really like this game. i would have given it a 10, but there are only 6 dungeons. OoT had 9, A Link to the Past had 12. I hope there's not only 3 in the next Zelda game.
  57. Chris
    May 13, 2003
    10
    Yeah, it's a bit easy in places... But it is, without doubt, the most enjoyable game I've ever played, OoT included. Explore the whole(enormous) world and it'll last for ages..
  58. JackintheBox
    May 11, 2003
    6
    Very disappointing compared to Ocarina of Time. It feels more like a step back for the franchise than a leap forward. I don't like the looks, the animation is glitchy (guards sticking *through* the barrel Link is hiding in, etc.) and it feels as a very empty, sterile world. Fortunately it came with a bonusdisc, and I'm actually playing through Masterquest and enjoying it a whole Very disappointing compared to Ocarina of Time. It feels more like a step back for the franchise than a leap forward. I don't like the looks, the animation is glitchy (guards sticking *through* the barrel Link is hiding in, etc.) and it feels as a very empty, sterile world. Fortunately it came with a bonusdisc, and I'm actually playing through Masterquest and enjoying it a whole lot more than Wind Waker.… Expand
  59. JesseK.
    May 10, 2003
    10
    This is one of the most interactive games I have ever seen. Despite the length of the game, I have never wanted to put the controller down until I saw the last bit of credits. I wish the dungeons were longer, but the Anime-style graphics were amazing! Later people! Peace to Brampton! Holla!
  60. KyleH.
    May 9, 2003
    10
    How on earth can you say that this game does not have godly visuals. Ive played the whole thing threw and was constantly amazed at the animation, character modeling, particle effects and every other detail that I would have never thought to add. This is how cell-shading should be used. This game has the most polished graphics I have ever seen, except perhaps for Splinter Cell running on How on earth can you say that this game does not have godly visuals. Ive played the whole thing threw and was constantly amazed at the animation, character modeling, particle effects and every other detail that I would have never thought to add. This is how cell-shading should be used. This game has the most polished graphics I have ever seen, except perhaps for Splinter Cell running on PC with a geforce4. Zelda definitley deserves a 10!… Expand
  61. SamA.
    May 9, 2003
    10
    Just got it and it is the best game ever! When you see the screenshots of it it looks rubbish but in action its as smooth as a babies bum. 10/10? Definitely
  62. MattR.
    May 9, 2003
    10
    This game is the best game on the GameCube, and is only rivalled by such titles as Final Fantasy on the PS2 and Halo on the Xbox. Every GameCube owner should buy this game because it boasts perfect gameplay, a huge storyline and graphics that (although many would consider them cartoony and a downside) grow on you until you wish all your other games looked like this. It looks like Zelda This game is the best game on the GameCube, and is only rivalled by such titles as Final Fantasy on the PS2 and Halo on the Xbox. Every GameCube owner should buy this game because it boasts perfect gameplay, a huge storyline and graphics that (although many would consider them cartoony and a downside) grow on you until you wish all your other games looked like this. It looks like Zelda has done it again.… Expand
  63. SamG.
    May 7, 2003
    10
    I haven't played this game yet but I a Zelda Fan!!! So I don't care what it looks like because its not about the graphics. Its about what type of game you like.
  64. Mechanori
    May 7, 2003
    9
    For those of you rating the game because of it's kiddy graphics, stop being so scared of graphics. Even though they are absolutely beautiful anyway, don't judge anything by how it looks. This is a great game, in all aspects, and unfortunately for you people that think realism is most important, it is most certainly not the basis of any previous Zelda game. Did the LttP sprite For those of you rating the game because of it's kiddy graphics, stop being so scared of graphics. Even though they are absolutely beautiful anyway, don't judge anything by how it looks. This is a great game, in all aspects, and unfortunately for you people that think realism is most important, it is most certainly not the basis of any previous Zelda game. Did the LttP sprite look anything like a real figure? Was it meant to? Did Link's eyes look like normal eyes in OoT? No, they were anime styled, and this game is taking that style to a new level.… Expand
  65. BLove
    May 6, 2003
    10
    The only complaint that I have is the game is a little too short. However, I simply can't give it less than a 10 as much as I enjoyed it. Can't wait for the next zelda on the gamecube.
  66. ScottM.
    Apr 29, 2003
    10
    This game is the most awesome and breathtaking game i've ever played.I've got all 3 next generation systems and this is by far the best game there is for all 3 systems.The Legend Of Zelda:The Wind Waker is the best game ever.Makers of zelda games, you rock!Thanks for the best game ever!
  67. AlucardM.
    Apr 28, 2003
    10
    This is a wonderful game. I insist you to buy it if you love the other Zeldas. It has a fresh new look to it and I'm fine with it. As always it has many things to explore and find. The story is very, very good. This is my favorite game, it even beat Halo for me. BUY IT!!!
  68. DougM.
    Apr 27, 2003
    9
    People who won't play this game because of the cel-shading are going to miss out on one great game. An awesome story and an incredibly huge world will have you playing for a while.
  69. JackR.
    Apr 24, 2003
    10
    This game is freakin' amazing. I've been playing it now for about 4 nights and I still keep seeing things that make me say "Wow!". The graphics are gorgeous, the sound is well done, the music is great, the control is tight, the story is amazing, and the game overall is just very well polished. However, there are a few flaws. The camera can be annoying at times, although this This game is freakin' amazing. I've been playing it now for about 4 nights and I still keep seeing things that make me say "Wow!". The graphics are gorgeous, the sound is well done, the music is great, the control is tight, the story is amazing, and the game overall is just very well polished. However, there are a few flaws. The camera can be annoying at times, although this problem plagues almost all 3d games. Traveling the map sometimes feels tedious. Certain repetitive sounds like Link yapping when he jumps can be annoying. These few problems are minor however, and don't detract overall from my enjoyment of the game. This game is so polished and does so well in keeping me interested and amazed that I gave it a 10. … Expand
  70. ChristopherG.
    Apr 24, 2003
    10
    This is my favorite game ever!!!!!!!!
  71. NathanP.
    Apr 22, 2003
    9
    Man oh man... everyone I knew kept on saying... "OMG, ZELDA IS GONNA SUCK ASS" I was the only one who still had faith in Miyamoto's ability to crank out great games. And boy was I right! Although I thought this game would be perfect, there are a few flaws (the camera can go haywire on your during a few battles), but they all are bearable once you can adjust to them. The graphics look Man oh man... everyone I knew kept on saying... "OMG, ZELDA IS GONNA SUCK ASS" I was the only one who still had faith in Miyamoto's ability to crank out great games. And boy was I right! Although I thought this game would be perfect, there are a few flaws (the camera can go haywire on your during a few battles), but they all are bearable once you can adjust to them. The graphics look gorgeous, and all those who said that the game was too "cartoonish" and "childish"... maybe its you who needs to grow up! I mean, seriously, Zelda brought back what video games was supposed to do in the first place- TO HAVE FUN. The dungeons are well mapped out, and the puzzles are there, but aren't too hard to solve, yet still keep you interested. So be a real grown-up and bring out your inner child and get Wind Waker. This game isn't perfect-- few games are-- but its almost there.… Expand
  72. TomB.
    Apr 18, 2003
    10
    When first I glimpsed Zelda's new look I was a bit apprehensive, but now that I have the game, I cannot give it anything less than a perfect score. Zelda is pure genius, and proves the gamer
  73. JonathanL.
    Apr 18, 2003
    10
    This game completely kicks *insert words here*. However it is very different but nonetheless it is amazing. The graphics are amazing the sound is also amazing and the battle style(much like the other zelda games but better)is awesome. If the rating could go higher I would rate it an amazing 1000. This has to be the greatest Zelda game ever. Those who claim the graphics are kiddy are just This game completely kicks *insert words here*. However it is very different but nonetheless it is amazing. The graphics are amazing the sound is also amazing and the battle style(much like the other zelda games but better)is awesome. If the rating could go higher I would rate it an amazing 1000. This has to be the greatest Zelda game ever. Those who claim the graphics are kiddy are just plain stupid and probably haven't played it. … Expand
  74. (Still)RemainingNameless
    Apr 18, 2003
    10
    i have 2 say one thing......WTF IS WRONG WITH ALL U PPL THAT DIDNT BUY IT JUST CUZ OF THE F...ING GRAPHICS?!?! this game is awsome! although the bosses were a sinch, the ending battle with ganon proved that zelda was useful 4 something other than screaming and running around. she actually fought! enev though the graphics were really screwed and it might have seemed kiddish, i bought this i have 2 say one thing......WTF IS WRONG WITH ALL U PPL THAT DIDNT BUY IT JUST CUZ OF THE F...ING GRAPHICS?!?! this game is awsome! although the bosses were a sinch, the ending battle with ganon proved that zelda was useful 4 something other than screaming and running around. she actually fought! enev though the graphics were really screwed and it might have seemed kiddish, i bought this game cuz i was a hardcore zelda fan, and u know what, i loved it. the graphics may make link look like a powerpuff girl, but who the fuck cares. its not graphics that make a good game, its gameplay and stroyline and this game followed that of zelda perfectly. this is aa amazing segment 2 the L.o.Z series and those of u that didnt buy it just cuz of the kiddish cartooning are seriously, SERIOUSLY F...ED! wicked game!!!… Expand
  75. RemainingNameless
    Apr 18, 2003
    10
    this game is wicked!!!!!!! the bosses r kinda easy though, but thats ok becuz the battle with ganon at the end was the best. finally zelda showed that she was useful 4 something other than screaming. even though the graphics r kinda screwed and the game is short, i think it was an amazing segment 2 the L.o.Z series! wicked game!!!!!!!!
  76. Avideogamefan
    Apr 17, 2003
    9
    A great game. Even though it's a little short, and there are no voices, an awesome game.
  77. MikeM.
    Apr 14, 2003
    10
    Great Game!!!
  78. j.jBoNd
    Apr 13, 2003
    10
    this game is the best i've ever played.
  79. CharlesJ.
    Apr 12, 2003
    10
    The most stunning, puzzle filled, action filled dungeons ive ever played!
  80. BrendanJ.
    Apr 12, 2003
    10
    WOW. this is one great game. anyone who gives this game less than an 8 obciously hasnt bought this game. "well i played a demo at target" what kind of thing is that to say. the dungeons are masterpieces, the puzzles, challenging enough to test you but not so hard you'll get stuck, the graphics...INCREDIBLE, the sound, amazing, and the overall gameplay and combat is truly tremendous. WOW. this is one great game. anyone who gives this game less than an 8 obciously hasnt bought this game. "well i played a demo at target" what kind of thing is that to say. the dungeons are masterpieces, the puzzles, challenging enough to test you but not so hard you'll get stuck, the graphics...INCREDIBLE, the sound, amazing, and the overall gameplay and combat is truly tremendous. anyone who claims its a kiddy game is insane about trying to prove how manly they are (weirdos) is missing out on the best Zelda game ever created. The combat is spectacular and dont expect your enemies to take turns like in poorly made games, they'll all come at you if once if they please. anyone who doubts the graphics or gameplay or anything is missing out on the greatest video game experience of all time. It blow metroid prime out of the water, its in a whole different league than metroid prime and thats a great game. anyone who doubts it is half witted. until you BUY and play this game you wont know how truly wonderful it is. playing a demo doesnt give you any perspective of the unbelieveably vast world of zelda. dont pass judgement until you play at least three full dungeons, they are mind boggeling.… Expand
  81. MarkH
    Apr 12, 2003
    10
    Best game EVER!, if you don't buy it this instant.....then.....then.... Your just a friggin mad man.
  82. WingWong
    Apr 11, 2003
    7
    I think this game is pretty good, but I don't think it should have been a Zelda game. The story's plot is a little disconnected with Zelda herself. The feel of the controls, especially the L targeting and the shielding is awkward (I keep on crawling whenever I try to shield against a guy!) Overall, this game didn't really have the "Zelda" feel to it that I had been hoping I think this game is pretty good, but I don't think it should have been a Zelda game. The story's plot is a little disconnected with Zelda herself. The feel of the controls, especially the L targeting and the shielding is awkward (I keep on crawling whenever I try to shield against a guy!) Overall, this game didn't really have the "Zelda" feel to it that I had been hoping for. Though it was not a Zelda material, it would have been a superior game if it was its own series.… Expand
  83. Diogoluz
    Apr 11, 2003
    10
    its super colorfull and the controls are very easy.
  84. Kilik
    Apr 11, 2003
    9
    Were gonna get some action yeah were gonna get some action soon trapped in a world of ordinary nightmares...blah blah cant remember-does anyone believe this is me i tried to tell you there is something like that more to meeeeee. I tried to tell you. Yeah this is a good game. The camera is good whoever that was that said that probably has no coordination and cant reallly use the Were gonna get some action yeah were gonna get some action soon trapped in a world of ordinary nightmares...blah blah cant remember-does anyone believe this is me i tried to tell you there is something like that more to meeeeee. I tried to tell you. Yeah this is a good game. The camera is good whoever that was that said that probably has no coordination and cant reallly use the controller. The story is good as for the guy who said it doesn't make sense go back to pre school it is very simple. a good game . play . it. now.… Expand
  85. GanonS.
    Apr 9, 2003
    10
    All I have to say is WOW! And maybe, WOW! again. I never doubted Miyamoto for a second, and neither should have you! This is definetely the best, standing with OoT, Zelda game ever! You know what I'm going to say to everyone who goes on crapping about the kiddy graphics, so I just won't say it. And for everyone who thought they were going to be cool, you were right! The All I have to say is WOW! And maybe, WOW! again. I never doubted Miyamoto for a second, and neither should have you! This is definetely the best, standing with OoT, Zelda game ever! You know what I'm going to say to everyone who goes on crapping about the kiddy graphics, so I just won't say it. And for everyone who thought they were going to be cool, you were right! The cel-shading adds a whole new concept of gaming, for this series at least, and I hope the next title will be the same. Sound and FX are great as always, as well as an excellent story line which I believe blends in very nicely to Ocarina. Also, the addition of a few sword combos, as well as the hurricane spin double the sword-swinging fun! This is truly an instant masterpice; the game of the year without a doubt, and one who's legend will live on for ages to come...… Expand
  86. D.C.
    Apr 3, 2003
    10
    Ups: Awesome graphics and visuals, incredible environments, great overall theme, fun combat and cool new items Downs: The Ocarina was better than the Windwaker, but if you're patient and don't mind sailing A LOT then there isn't much to complain about.
  87. DanW.
    Apr 1, 2003
    6
    As I peruse the "reviews" penned by the "critics" listed here on Metacritic, I get the impression more of a Miyamoto-san back-patting contest than of anything resembling objectivity. Indeed more shocking, however, are the reviews that touch on Wind Wakers significant flaws, and then proceed to give it a perfect score anyway. Yes, the game is gorgeous. The music and sound are passable, As I peruse the "reviews" penned by the "critics" listed here on Metacritic, I get the impression more of a Miyamoto-san back-patting contest than of anything resembling objectivity. Indeed more shocking, however, are the reviews that touch on Wind Wakers significant flaws, and then proceed to give it a perfect score anyway. Yes, the game is gorgeous. The music and sound are passable, though nothing extraordinary, usually just treading old ground again. The gameplay is a mixed bag. On the one hand, it's brilliant nearly all the time. On the other hand, the lock-on system varies from awkward to useless, and the camera is maddening, often positioning itself in the place most opposed to usefulness. In all, it's a great game with serious problems, like a supermodel with a club foot. It's certainly not a 10, or a 9. In fact, I give it a 6.… Expand
  88. Al
    Mar 29, 2003
    10
    WOW so far this game has been a worthwhile investment....great graphics, great gameplay, great music, and probably the greatest zelda story.
  89. RyanM.
    Mar 29, 2003
    10
    This game has so much style that I have to agree with the comments from the majority of the magazines. There will be no finer gaming experience this year. Miyamoto strikes again!
  90. Doobie
    Mar 28, 2003
    10
    That's a spicy tamale!
  91. Theimminent26
    Mar 27, 2003
    9
    I start this review with an important statement, this is my opinion so don't get angry with me if i insult you. To start off any single person who won't play this game because of "kiddie link" is missing out this is a very awesome game, in my opinion way better than ocarina of time, but still no link to the past. Next, for everyone who is avoiding "kid" link, that is pure I start this review with an important statement, this is my opinion so don't get angry with me if i insult you. To start off any single person who won't play this game because of "kiddie link" is missing out this is a very awesome game, in my opinion way better than ocarina of time, but still no link to the past. Next, for everyone who is avoiding "kid" link, that is pure imbecility and goes back to the argument of gameplay over graphics. I would understand not wanting to play if they made link original nintendo graphics after showing us 3d games, but because they make him a child its ruined (sarcastic), thats almost worst then saying something like "oh the main character in this game is a little girl or the hero doesn't look cool enough the game sucks now". As for the graphics I was surprised at first but I knew they could't screw this series up unless they made a barrage of mistakes. Now that I see the graphics I am nothing more than amused as was said earlier it is kind of like art to a degree. I admit some character models are stupid but that won't stop this game from being awesome. Oh, and another thing for the whole its just the same exact controls over again no new sword moves argument my friend brought up the other day. Any person who has played a zelda game knows that you play for the quest and unique boss fights and new and classic item puzzles, not the swordfighting. ANYWAYS I give this game a 9 because of the fact that it is easier than normal and some very slight puzzle reptitiveness.......Apt. 26:) coming soon check it out… Expand
  92. NikoB.
    Mar 26, 2003
    10
    This is truly a great game. The cell-shading animation takes nothing away from the game, and only adds to its creativity. Gameplay is easy to understand, and this Zelda has the best fighting in any of the games. Definitely one of the two best Zeldas.
  93. ThomasW.
    Mar 25, 2003
    10
    A Masterpiece. It might be worse then OOT, it might be better. At this level of brillence its hard to tell. This game alone is a reason to own a Gamecube. (along with Metroid Prime, Eternal Darkness, even Super Monkey Ball)
  94. MichaelK.
    Mar 25, 2003
    10
    It's an absolute masterpiece, in graphics, sound, control, and gameplay. Elevates the gameplay of Orcarnia and Majora's Mask to unheralded new levels. Intense and emotional, with dark undertones that prove it's no kid's game. Like playing a Hayao Miyazaki film... already can see it being the best game of the year. Personally one of the best games I've ever had the It's an absolute masterpiece, in graphics, sound, control, and gameplay. Elevates the gameplay of Orcarnia and Majora's Mask to unheralded new levels. Intense and emotional, with dark undertones that prove it's no kid's game. Like playing a Hayao Miyazaki film... already can see it being the best game of the year. Personally one of the best games I've ever had the joy of experiencing.… Expand
  95. AbeH.
    Mar 23, 2003
    10
    This is the second best game I have ever played the first being Ocarina of Time. Its a masterpiece and do yourself a favour and buy this game. Buy two copies, one for playing and the other for collecting.
  96. Mr.Wha
    Mar 22, 2003
    10
    Da Best! NUFF SAID.
  97. PatB.
    Mar 21, 2003
    10
    This game is absolutely brilliaint. The people who say "This game is childish" are usually 9-14 years old! They feel if they say that, then play "mature" games, like Resident Evil, they are "mature. HA! Don't listen to the people who say it's childish. They are the children.
  98. Anonymousguy
    Mar 21, 2003
    0
    Nintendo did the one thing I never thought they would do. They turned Zelda (previously a great series) into a cash-in. Nintendo has really got to get its act together before it loses all of its fans. Unless you are under the age of 7 or very immature for your age you will probably not enjoy this game.
  99. Ness
    Mar 20, 2003
    10
    "Actually, when I first saw the toon shaded Zelda I was very surprised and excited by it. However, I was startled by the response we got from the press when we showed it off the first time. They all said, "Oh, so is Nintendo now taking Zelda and trying to aim it only at kids?" Really, the whole concept we had behind it was that we thought it was a very creative and new way to show off "Actually, when I first saw the toon shaded Zelda I was very surprised and excited by it. However, I was startled by the response we got from the press when we showed it off the first time. They all said, "Oh, so is Nintendo now taking Zelda and trying to aim it only at kids?" Really, the whole concept we had behind it was that we thought it was a very creative and new way to show off Link. All the sudden it had been interpreted as Nintendo's new strategy, and that was a shock for us. When it comes to Nintendo strategy, it's not that we want to make games for kids. It's that we want to make them creative while appealing to a wider audience. Obviously we see games as entertainment, and we want to find the best way to make the gameplay experience entertaining for everyone." -Shigeru Miyamoto… Expand
  100. Mr.Bobertz
    Mar 19, 2003
    9
    For all you who think this game is made for kids, you need to grow up. If Grand Theft Auto 3 was a cartoon with vegetables, youd hate it even if it was the same gameplay and missions, right? Why is it that everything cartoony is classified as "kids stuff"? What about South Park? That's animated, isn't that for kids? My point is, dont judge a game by how it looks. What lies here For all you who think this game is made for kids, you need to grow up. If Grand Theft Auto 3 was a cartoon with vegetables, youd hate it even if it was the same gameplay and missions, right? Why is it that everything cartoony is classified as "kids stuff"? What about South Park? That's animated, isn't that for kids? My point is, dont judge a game by how it looks. What lies here is a good game. Some good battle innovations, new weapons, and the GBA connectivity all add up. Personally, i like the cartoony look. It looks better than he does in Soul Calibur 2, but not as good as the demo video released before the GC was released. But I think that Orcarina of Time is better.… Expand
Page:

Awards & Rankings

1
#1 Best GameCube Game of 2003
1
#1 Most Discussed GameCube Game of 2003
4
#4 Most Shared GameCube Game of 2003

Critic Reviews

All reviews »
Metascore
96

Universal acclaim - based on 80 Critic Reviews

Critic score distribution:
  1. Positive: 80 out of 80
  2. Mixed: 0 out of 80
  3. Negative: 0 out of 80
  1. Weekly Famitsu
    100
    10 / 10 / 10/ 10 - 40 platinum
  2. NTSC-uk
    100
    When one picks up the controller, the ability to step into that time and place (never more hauntingly beautiful than in this latest instalment) never loses its allure. Even the most hardened of cynics would have to admit that this title is something else entirely. It's the stuff of dreams. [JPN Import]
    Read full review
  3. Eurogamer
    100
    Simply a stunning, magical game.
    Read full review
See all critic reviews »